Splinter Cell: Conviction Vs Uncharted 2: Round 2 - Replay Factors

Cinemablend:

"In the words of Ryan Rigney from last week's round, "What a ridiculous comparison! How can you compare a third person shooter with climbing mechanics to a third person shooter with climbing mechanics and an outdoors setting?!"

[Tinted Eyes]

Why continue to compare them?

[cyguration]

You ask why compare them and then you post in the open zone that Uncharted wins???

Anyway, I'm looking forward to both games.

[ATY]

It is a silly comparison.

It be same ridiculous use of the PC version running on a 3000 dollar PC for footage and screenshots. Just like Gears of War, Mass Effect, Alan Wake, etc all try to pull with either lies of 'this footage comes from the 360. Honestly! Not lying' or absurd claims 'the 360 version will look just as good. No really!'

[GiantEnemyCrab]

1.1: hahah he owned himself. Stop pretending to not be a total Sony knob gobbler.

However, I do agree that we don't have all the details of SC:Conviction. They have not talked about the multiplayer at all and we have very few details. While with Uncharted they've had a beta and the game is basically all but announced.

How can you compare replayability when you don't even know what one of the games will entail?

It's a bogus and loaded VS comparison.

[Tinted Eyes]

I owned myself? LOL

[Cwalat]

Uncharted 2 wins imo, NaughtyGods have always been developing topnotch titles.

Splinter Cell is also a great game, but not my cup of cake.

[mal_tez92]

I've played through Drake's Fortune over 20 times and I'm no where close to being bored of it.

[frnkyl]

Who puts cake in a cup?

[militant07]

Alan Wake was running on X360 because the PC version is cancelled for now...

[deadreckoning666]

Splinter Cell wins because of the freedom given to the player. Ur not limited to ONE path of play. But as GiantEnemyCrab says, the only real winners are the people who get both.

@Mezzo- Its ur opinion, but would u mind explaining how Uncharted 2 "seems" to have the better gameplay as opposed to SC: Convicion?

@Obama- The FIRST 2 Splinter Cells were very boring, but we ALL know that Conviction is a new type of Splinter Cell that is faster and more engaging. Conviction is proving that stealth doesn't mean slow gameplay.

[-Mezzo-]

Both Games Looks Marvelous, in their own way/console, but i agree that Uncharted 2 seems to have better Gameplay then SC:Conviction, and needless to mention better graphics.

I am looking forward to Uncharted 2 myself. as well as towards SC:Conviction.

Agree, Then Click That Bubble ++++++ thank you. lol.

[menoyou]

There is no comparison. Uncharted raises bars, Splinter Cell simply doesn't.

[BkaY]

wrong wrong comparison...

compare it with MGS4 not uncharted 2..

[jetlian]

but uncharted will be good. uncharted doesn't have the skill set to be in the running. sam would distroy nathan. splinter cell has more pathways,toys, moves etc. same if you put SC against mgs

[vhero]

If 360 owners think Splinter Cell is their answer to Uncharted 2 then they are totally mistaken. I'm not saying it not gonna be a great looking title nor play good but Uncharted 2 will probably be 2009 GOTY. Only 360 fanboys will obviously disagree but whatever you should do what I did and get both consoles so you can enjoy the best of both :).

[jetlian]

uncharted doesn't need to be answered to. its a good series but its not as big as you would hope

[potenquatro]

Uncharted looks better imo. It's just stylisticly better directed. SC goes for gritty, Uncharted goes for WOW.

[WMW]

"uncharted doesn't need to be answered to. its a good series but its not as big as you would hope" 3 million sold, 88 rating and has better graphics then every 360 game UC2 tops the 1st in length, graphics, replay value and many other things while also adding new things also it won more awards and more important awards then anything else at e3 so you go ahead an tell yourself its not a big game if that makes you feel good about not being able to play it

[pixelsword]

...if a person only owns one console and does not/can not buy the other console, then who really cares what the other game does.

This it just an opinion piece meant to generate hits. If you can get both, wait for the demos and think for yourself. If you can get only one game or have only one console then again; wait for the demo. I'd also suggest that you may want to ignore articles like this because whether the game you want to get wins or loses this comparison, this type of article will only serve to demoralize people by writers who... wait for it:

*actually never played either game to completion yet to have sound judgment to give counsel on either game*

I mean, c'mon! If you did decide to look at the article, did you notice that they don't even have a pic of Uncharted 2? That pic was from the first Uncharted.

Remember, this is all just an opinion: so if it's not YOUR opinion, then why let someone's opinion override yours?

[gaffyh]

This is a stupid comparison, as bad as comparing Gears vs Uncharted. But even then Uncharted wins in every category i can think of, graphics, replayability, story, gameplay. All of them I feel like will be better in Uncharted than in Splinter Cell. Although that doesn't mean that SC won't be a great game.

[jetlian]

win on graphics, replay or gameplay. and the graphics haven't changed much either

[gamesR4fun]

* Splinter Cell: Conviction 13%
* Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 87%

[Tinted Eyes]

Uncharted wins.

[xb0x_trashie]

Splinter Cell fails.

[Nitrowolf2]

Uncharted 2 for the win

[GiantEnemyCrab]

I'll have both.

I Win.

[DevastationEve]

Forza versus Gran Turismo. Alan Wake versus Heavy Rain. Gears of War versus Resistance. Halo versus Killzone.

Who says Xbox 360 hasn't produced heavy hitters? Even still so many PS3 fanboys won't yield even an inch. They can't believe that Xbox 360 can produce such competitive games, especiallly when it comes generation leading visuals and presentation. It's an impossibility to them.

[fenix1300]

GT5 will destroy forza in every way imaginable. heavy rain is going to kill AW in terms of the way the story is being told (can't say much about Alan wake's game play, but from what I have seen it looks amazing. too bad they cancelled it for PC). and resistance obliterates Gears in every way, shape, and form (I mean come on 60 players online!?!? I have the games and it still blows me away). and please don't try and compare KZ2 to halo. I mean your comparing a game that gives gut wrenching realism to a game where you run around shooting pink and blue lasers and jump 10 feet into the air.

[DevastationEve]

The pink and blue lasers of Halo 3 have been viewed by upwards of 10 million Xbox 360 gamers.

Millions of Xbox Live subscribers have logged on to play what has become the pinnacle of this generation's online gaming. Many of them having never played on Xbox Live, or even online period. Halo 3 has recieved many accolades for its online multiplayer, from casual and hardcore gamers alike.

It continues to smash sales records as we speak, and there are on average 200000 users logged on daily throughout the US and Europe and many other countries across the globe.

OSDT will continue to exhibit why Bungie was a force to be reckoned with. Even though Bungie haven't made any significant changes to their engine with Halo 3 and ODST (besides the remarkable work they've done), Halo Reach will offer a new and revived Halo for the fans.

Correction. For the world.

Do not disrespect the Halo.

edit:

No, what I'm saying is that Bungie's formula works :) gurrilla's doesn't :(

(ew, guess what? you can only disagree with me once per account...time to log in that other one!)

[fenix1300]

so what your telling me is that a company managed to give the same product under a different name, without changing the game play or innovating anything?!?! god you people are dumber than I thought. GT5 will revolutionize the racing genera, MAG will revolutionize online play, HR will revolutionize story telling in video games. HALO will be HALO and there will never be anything revolutionary about it. BTW the wii has outsold every console this generation, by your definition that must be the best system ever. (not to knock on the wii I loved metroid Prime)

no I only have one account sorry to disappoint :(
and your telling me that GG's formula doesn't work on the basis of sales??? damn your funny. oh btw you wanna know where bungie got their formula from play a little game called Unreal tournament!!! you'll find that it looks strikingly similar lol. bungie just used cut and past and put a different name on it.

[DevastationEve]

PS3 fanboys need to let go of the supremacy act. Xbox 360 has consistently matched PS3 pixel for pixel in HD gaming. Especially in graphics.

But most of all...a game like Halo 3 proves that gameplay must ALWAYS win in the end. What good is all the tech talk if KillZone 2 (a game in development for many years) STILL can't even match the original Gears (a 2006 game in development for about 1.5 years) in terms of impact on the industry.

I'm not even gonna try and make this a sales thing. LITERALLY look at the impact KillZone 2 made in the industry. Nothing. Now look at Gears. MAJOR impact, it was the most played online game on XBL for a long time. What does that tell you?

That a game's true value is in what it contributes to the gaming community. When that community turns its back no amount of CellBE overhype or SPE talk can make up for the fact that the game DIDN'T MAKE IMPACT.

...okay. I've spared you the talk about sales.

And now onto sales ;)

edit:

You have lost all respect by saying that Halo got its formula from Unreal. Are you effing kidding me? You could've done better and gone as far back as the original Doom or Quake or Duke Nukem 3D even Castle Wolfenstien.

It shows that you really don't go that far back and that you really don't know much FPS gaming history. I'll give you benefit of the doubt, but seriously Halo and Unreal don't anything the same. Nada. Oh, they shoot in first person. But really the similarities ends there.

[fenix1300]

umm no there is no game on the 360 that can match uncharted or MGS4 and don't even try and push anything else if you want proof watch.
http://www.youtube.com/watc...

please don't mistake impact with lack of choice. if people are forced to play a certain game on a console then people will play it (isn't COD 4 play significantly more anyway?). and Killzone 2 is not just about the graphics, is about the sound the physics all of which create a new level of immersion into a game that delivers a gut wrenching realistic experience all in one package. (has anyone noticed that players on European servers on KZ are way better than on the american servers). ps3 has pushed the boundaries on what is possible this console generation from title to title. the 360 gives you the same stuff that you have been playing since 1999. oh and it allows you to see the bottom of an avatars shoe!!!

You know because I'm craving for your respect /sarcasm

Edit:
lol that was funny!!!

[kalebgray92]

your bio

"PS3 fa nboys nee d ai r. Th eir b rain s a re no t so g ood. The y a re no t v e r y sma rt, th oug h the y t hink the y a re"

shut up dude

[DevastationEve]

To infinity and b3yond ;)

edit:

I'd rather the both of you just not reply in a 360 section if it's of no interest to you or if all you have to say is something negative. Really.

edit 2:

...you ask me to go to the openzone when I simply began this whole thing by saying that Xbox 360 has games that compare well with PS3 games and then Fenix went out of his way to insult each one that I listed. And then after being very organized with my case that Halo 3 specifically had a lot to bring to this generation he persisted.

Help me out here, I don't see how your logic works.

[kalebgray92]

your name says it all i hate fanboys who play victim when they put another console down at the same time and this isnt a 360 section im pretty sure it says Splinter cell and Uncharted 2....please use open zone for now on

edit: and really disagrees... does your bio say something different im confused?

[DevastationEve]

I went way outta my way. So here's me saying I'm sorry. We part as friends.

[corywebb93]

Iff you dont agree you need to get a eye exam and a brain check

Splinter cell is in league off his own

Dont even compare this game is a insult to splinter cell

Uncharted should get compared to a crapy game in its league like vampire rain

[Tinted Eyes]

Its in a league under Metal gear

[xb0x_trashie]

splinter already dropped out of the league and cannot compare to any game past the nes

xbox fails agaain..

[deadreckoning666]

Gameplay-wise, Splinter Cell wins on variety and the freedom given to the player. One situation can be tackled in so many different ways. The fact that Uncharted 2 has fighting AND stealth mechanics is impressive but the campaign has a linear path with the objective of shoot ur way from point A to point B.

Graphics- Uncharted 2, because its Uncharted 2.

@Saaking- "Splinter Cell is a poor man's MGS4" Are u out of ur mind?? Do u really thk anyone would give MGS4 a second look if its wasn't for its story? Can Snake "spot and mark"? Can Snake infiltrate a mansion full of guys in less than 5 minutes? Can Snake climb up a pole, hang off a ceiling, and shoot a chandelier, making it fall out top of his enemies? No, he can't. From the SC trailer, its obvious that Sam moves are done MUCH MUCH more quicker and deadlier than Snake's. When has Snake even SLAMMED A GUYS FACE INTO A WALL "DURING GAMEPLAY?" Stop being a fanboy Saaking, u don't know what ur saying. One thg we can agree on is that WE BOTH want to see Conviction come to the PS3.

[redsquad]

When comments likt that come from someone with more than three bubbles, I'm immediately suspicious.

[YellowLightzOfDeath]

I love how the silly ps3 fanboys always jump right into the "VS" articles and always claim. "its wrong to compare these two, its like comparing a helicopter to an airplane" LOL, for once free yourselfs of your fanboyism ignorance and do some research. Yes we understand they are both on seperate consoles and yes one has better gameplay mechanics then the other, but lets not forget their simularities defenitly can and WILL be compared. First of all uncharted 2 gameplay offers no such sneaking, all i've seen in gameplay videos is mindless run and gun shooting, Although i got to admit some of the guns look impressive. Splinter cell conviction on the other hand offers the greatest sneaking mechanics this generation, and gameplay improvments never seen in videogame history which i believe will revolutionize espionage gaming altogether. Uncharted 2's settings are ok, they take place in alaska and in a rural town. I like some of the details in some of the trees's but lets not forget splinter cell conviction takes place all around the world, including the mediterranian islands.

[Nitrowolf2]

really no sneaking in Uncharted? i remember some of that in number 1.

[The Swordsman]

I'm sure I read somewhere, when the game was first announced, that there would be stealth elements in Uncharted 2.

[Obama]

One thing for sure though, is that SC story will be as boring as the previous titles. I have played the first 2 splinter cell, and found the story boring and characters uninteresting, especially Sam Fisher. The gameplay in the first one is not bad, but not that impressive either.

Do people ever talk about Sam Fisher? As far as I am concerned noone really cares about the character.

[DaTruth]

They stated that in Uncharted 2 you have a choice to stealth or gun or a little of both; That is why he has so many stealth moves! Lol, they take features out of Uncharted 2 for the comparison's sake and still it comes up on top!

The first screenshots that released show the stealth gameplay!

You have a Gears of War avatar, and you speak badly of "teh mindless run and gun gameplay"!

[Ri0tSquad]

Lol, and you tell everyone else to do research. Looks like you didn't do enough yourself.

"Splinter cell conviction on the other hand offers the greatest sneaking mechanics this generation, and gameplay improvments never seen in videogame history which i believe will revolutionize espionage gaming altogether."

Yet you probably haven't even played it.

Your whole post just screams irony.

[Unicron]

LOL... someone didn't read ANY hands on with Uncharted 2. No stealth..? Haha, lol. Poor poor hypocrite. Also, no sneaking = bad game now? Damn, then Madden 2010 sucks!

Can't wait for another great espionage game with the most boring main character EVER. sigh. Pity too, Ironside is the man.

Both games will rock, be nothing alike, and I will purchase and enjoy both. Wooo!!!

[Noctis Aftermath]

@YLOD: ironic huh?

[god_o_war]

i dno i mean this is pretty sneaky

damn image never worked!

http://psinsider.e-mpire.co...

[shadow2797]

"LOL, for once free yourselfs of your fanboyism ignorance and do some research."

"Uncharted 2's settings are ok, they take place in alaska and in a rural town."

Great research there, buckaroo. I also love how you say that these games are really similar and should be compared and then go on a rant about how different they are. Haha.

Now to set you straight. As has been said, Uncharted contains both stealth and gunning. It's a mini-sandbox just like Splinter Cell. Uncharted 2 also takes place around the world. That "Alaska" you've seen is actually in the Himalayas. Here's the list of known locations: "You start in Turkey, and then go through Borneo, Nepalese cities, and then mountains in Tibet and the Himalayas, and more."

I'm looking forward to both games for different reasons. They're both going to be great games.

[Morituri]

Keep dreaming your little dreams meathead. We'll see which game is better when the dust settles.

[Saaking]

Uncharted 2 is a TRUE exclusive and TRUE next gen game unlike SCC which is a poor man's MGS4. Uncharted 2 is set to be GOTY 2009. Besides, PS3 owners will get to play both so what does it matter. SCC will come to PS3.

[Deadman64]

Oh it will? So like a year or so from now right? Like Bioshock?

Playing it a year after its out is cool I guess...that is if it DOES go to PS3

[Saaking]

doesn't really matter when or if. SCC doesn't compare to Uncharted 2 and that's a fact.

[Serg]

I actually don't believe it will come to the PS3.

But let's just assume it does, in a year, PS3 owners have so many exclusive titles to fill in the gap, not to mention awesome multi platforms like Assassins Creed 2 or Final Fantasy XIII, I don't think anyone is going to cry for it, but it would be a nice addition to the PS3 game library if it would indeed come.

[xb0x_trashie]

uncharted 2 DESTROYS splinter cell

splinter cell just wish it could be on the same level but it can't

because its made on xbox

[poindat]

I mean sure, you can ASSUME what the value will be based on the info you have, but until you ACTUALLY PLAY IT, you won't know what it actually is.

This is a bit of a far-fetched analogy, but it's like comparing an unannounced Sony exclusive with an unannounced 360 exclusive. Of course we know so much more about these games, but how many people have played through "Unannounced Exclusive 32" and how many people have played through Uncharted 2 and Splinter Cell? The answer is the same for all of them: Nobody.

What's with all the stupid comparisons over the past few months?

[GiantEnemyCrab]

Agreed %100. We just don't even have a full picture yet of what SC:C is going to offer, let alone even playing either of these games beyond the beta some enjoyed.

[ElementX]

Stupid article. They're different games on different systems. Quit with the dumb comparisons.

[Raf1k1]

It doesn't really matter if they're on different systems but I agree that these two aren't similar enough to be compared.

[jack who]

Splinter Cell multiplayer >>>>> your lifes sony fans nut

[FlipMode]

Because you've played the multiplayer in a closed beta and found out how good it is.

[jack who]

cause i have played it since the 1st one on xbox 1 and i was a beta tested for SC:DA

now go away

[mirroredderorrim]

*flies to the moon*

[Snatcher]

My vote goes to SplinterCell: C.

Uncharted is a hell of a game though, but SC is just better.

[Saaking]

What a dumb bot. Uncharted 2 is better in every way which is why it won most E3 awards. I don't remember Alan Wake or SCC getting any awards.

[Cajun Chicken]

Uncharted does it for me, never really cared for Splinter Cell.

[Raf1k1]

I used to love SC. Last one I played was Chaos Theory but after having played Uncharted that's the one I'm getting ASAP. I'll get a used copy of SC.

[Shadow017]

We'll ill be playing Uncharted 2 while bots wait for delayed splinter cell next year.

[OmarJA]

Exactly, ROFL!

[PS3 Eternal 3rd]

Spinter Cell is a huge franchise.

Uncharted is another Sony no namer.

rofl

[Kazunori Yamauchi]

Splinter cell is from last gen, uncharted isn't even 3 years old i believe. If you want to compare which is more popular compare it to a franchise such as metal gear solid.

CEO of Polyphony Digital and creator and producer of the Gran Turismo series, Kazunori Yamauchi

[redsquad]

First it's the 'sales', now it's the 'longevity equals quality' argument. You must think the new WOLFENSTEIN game is the best FPS ever then.

Although you do strike me as the sort who'd resort to a "mine's bigger than yours" argument...

[gersh]

So because Uncharted 2 isn't from a milked franchise it's going to lose?

[The Master Chief]

Splinter Cell = one of the bigger franchises in gaming

Uncharted = Another Sony off brander like Killzone, Warhawk, Resistance and Motorstorm. Generic Sony wannabes that aren't taken serious by hardcore gamers.

They are played by asians and the kind of douche's that would play shooters on a Playstation. AKA noobs/people living the past. Looking at sales, not many.

Splinter Cell > Sony no-namer Uncharter

[Envy27]

What the H3ll are they doing?
Trying to pick 1 exclusive from each console and trying to start a flame war?
This will never end. Buy whatever is available to you. If you have both consoles get both. Other then that lets not even get into whats the better game is until they both release.

[foxtheory]

Seriously, Uncharted 2 and Conviction are two totally different concepts! And what makes it worse is that they're not even out yet! How can you even make a comparison and come to a conclusion without playing the games?

[Unicron]

Cuz the media sucks and fanboys only read flamebait. Welcome to gaming journalism circa 2009. =)

[foxtheory]

Fanboys always need to prove that something is better than the other. They can never see that both things are great. I've said it before and I'll say it again: fanboys do not equal gamers, because gamers enjoy games for what they are and don't bicker about them instead.

[Obama]

* Splinter Cell: Conviction 16%
* Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 84%

[militant07]

who says, ps3fanboys?? do you remember the Gears2 VS R2?

R2 won but it sold 250% less than gears

[cereal_killa]

Which tells you that Quantity =/= Quality thanks for proving what real gamers have been saying all along.

[jetlian]

xbox players speak in dollars sony players get online and vote =)

[Aloren]

@cereal_killa Yeah, quality =/= quantity ! And a higher metacritic average as well as 250% more sales means jack compared to fanboy polls which are the ultimate way to judge quality ! And obviously a game that sells a lot CAN'T be good, cause, you know, quantity....

Anyway, Uncharted 2 will be better technically, but gameplay wise, that's too early to tell, and that's also stupid, considering these have nothing to do with each other... let's compare GT5 and L4D 2 next, or Heavy Rain and Crackdown 2.

[lordkemp007]

coryweb
If brains were dynamite, you wouldn't have enough to blow your hat off.

[2FootYard]

Why the hell was there even a round one? This is like when people compare Alan Wake and Heavy Rain. There not even the same type of games.

[Serg]

Yeah it's silly, check out this new comparison! World of Warcraft vs. Super Mario Galaxy!

Sarcasm off.

[frnkyl]

Why do they keep using screenshots from Uncharted 1?

[Gaurav42]

the comparison is stupid in thew first place, but ill let them get away with that. no, whats stupid is they are talking baout REPLAY VALUE. and they havent played either of them, and SC doesnt come out till 2010. im pumped for U2, and i might buy a 360 to play SC.

[lagoonalight]

GOOD GOD Uncharted 2 will tear this game apart story wise and with its varied locations and superb acting there is just no way I don't care if this is running on the best PC.

[Cherchez La Ghost]

These sites just want to get hits. All this PS3 vs. 360 comparisons are just getting very tired. I enjoy both consoles. Only fanboys keep this crap going. And jackass websites like this one enjoy every minute of it. And here in N4G all fanboys want to start sheit every chance is open.

I rest my case.

[cereal_killa]

Couldn't have said it any better +Bubbles

[00]

can you compare a games Replay Factors to another game when neither of them are out.

[Deios]

These comparisons means nothing to me. I'll be buying both of them.

[MetalGearBear]

Uncharted 2> Splinter Cell: Conviction
Uncharted 2 has better graphics than Splinter Cell: Conviction.

FACT

[-Mezzo-]

Both game looks great, But Uncharted owns hands down.

Agree, Then Click That Bubble ++++++ thank you. lol.

[Ateeq]

You deserve bubbles, lol. matching avatars sucka.

[HDgamer]

I got a great idea, lets compare Heavy Rain and Alan Wake. This makes sense in bizzarro land.

[super x]

Splinter Cell: Conviction win WTF

[shad0w70]

Fanboys suck!!! I'll have the joy of owning & playing both!

[rukia_chan]

UNCHARTHED2>>>>> ;>> SPLINTERCRAPCELL

[Raoh]

???????????????

I'm confused... what?

[Gue1]

Neither game is out yet. Let the fanboys and trolls compare now and then let the professionals compare them when they are actually out.

But with all the fuss around both games how would cinemablend let this opportunity go away? This will create lots of hits for them.

[JonnyBigBoss]

Uncharted will undoubtedly have an epic story-mode, and we know the following:

- The game has a 3-player co-operative mode
- The game has a very diverse and engaging online experience

The same can't be said about Splinter-Cell: Conviction. I'll definitely be getting SC:C, but the chances of it having more replay value are nill.

[DevastationEve]

Eh, not really. Splinter Cell games actually do have excellent replay value. I don't know about Uncharted though, a linear environment with cues on how to get around and then story progression segments. Ubisoft said that there wouldn't be any cinemas in SC Conviction, so it actually has a lot going for it in the way of action and gameplay.

The mark and execute further sky rockets Conviction's replay value, I mean imagine the possibilities of going through the environments and carefully laying out your plans in any order of events you chose.

[PS360PCROCKS]

Gamers win. Secondly SC conviction was NOT unveiled in 2005 before the 360, that had to of been double agent. I believe it was 2007 Microsoft announced it as an exclusive at E3

[Ripyealip]

look at the votes and you will know which ones better

[BreakNeckSpeed]

The voting means nothing.

[bjornbear]

Still SC:C will be a fantastic game =D

[STRAIGHTASL]

i believe SC:C will coming to Ps3 after they release it on 360 and PC.

trust me.

[gamerzBEreal17]

when are thay going to learn this VS thing isnt going to work this site has way to many ps3 fanboys we all know how great of a game splinter cell is going to be i mean its possible that uncharted2 is better but 80% better?? i dont think so

[tudors]

there two totally different looks, but to be fair on a technical level UC2 does a lot of new stuff I really like but I think these are two games you cannot judge until you have played.

[iSynysteRx-]

"Splinter Cell multiplayer >>>>> your lifes sony fans nut"

That sentence alone sums up the 360 userbase with no intelligence whatsoever. Splinter Cell has nothing on us, That my friend is a fact.

[Belasco]

I have this CRAZY idea of playing BOTH! Wow, the logic of judgiing each game on its own merits rather than turning it into a pissing contest.

[solidworm]

with a buttered turd,...................UC2 wins for being WOWOWOWOW.

[Niske]

U2>SC FACT

You can not compare Spliter cell to Uncharted if you do then you are stupid bot with a poor mans ps3.

[Belasco]

And be like everyone else here dude. Poor mans Ps3? The slim is $299 now, hardly expensive.

[kraze07]

Comparisons like this are always dumb, but the fact that neither games are out yet just make it all the more stupid.

[Nate Tolar]

hmmm...i have reserved uncharted 2

and yet I feel no desire to do so for splinter cell.........

uncharted wins for me.