840°

PC World: Xbox 360 with Price Drop Still Generally More Expensive than PS3

PC World writes "Assuming the [upcoming price cut] rumor is true, and it looks likely to be, how do the new numbers affect the bottom line when you plug them into an accessory and services lineup?"
prackspoor - contributor
Published: 491 days 1 hour ago | Rumors | Xbox 360 | Gaming
 
 

123Next »
Showing: 1 - 50 of 126 Comments
Shut this user up Let user speak
SpaZaA - 491 days 2 hours ago
1 - Very good comparison
It's to be noted they are comparing the lower end PS3 to the 3 models of xbox360, not the 80GB PS3 (soon to be 160GB) that has emulated backwards compatibility with most PS2 games as well as all PSone games, 4 USB ports and ships with a game as well currently MGS4 ($59.99).
Shut this user up Let user speak
fermcr - 491 days 1 hour ago
1.1 -
Does the 80GB PS3 come with the chip for backwards compatibility with PS2 games? Here in Europe i think the 80gb and the 160gb are the same as the 40gb, only diference beeing biger HDD space. So i don't think here in Europe the new PS3 will come with backwards compatibility.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Parapraxis - 491 days ago
1.2 - @ fermcr
No, not a chip, it is emulated.
New 80GB & 160GB models replaces current 40GB (no BC for PS2 games) , the current 80GB has BC for PS2 games.

The only PS3 SKUs that have BC with a chip were the 20GB & 60GB models.

EDIT: fixed my error after diggin up info. my bad.
Shut this user up Let user speak
mindedone - 491 days ago
1.3 -
I was under the impression that not even the 160GB would have BC
Shut this user up Let user speak
marinelife9 - 491 days ago
1.4 -
Even the premium is only a good deal for one year. Once that next year of xbox live kicks in you have to pay another $50 dollars.
Shut this user up Let user speak
xhairs9 - 491 days ago
1.5 -
I think the 160gb has no BC from what I've read in the past, but that could very well change.

The only thing I disagree with as far as the charts go is that he put a $50 charge for a microphone on the PS3. I've gone through 3 headsets (in which I broke from frustration of my internet) totaling less than $50. Any standard USB Microphone Headset will work with the PS3, just because it's labeled "For PS3" doesn't mean it wont work. Also, you forgot to dial in Bluetooth capabilities. PS3 features Bluetooth compatibility with keyboard/mouse/headset. Add one more the PS3 plus side.
Shut this user up Let user speak
MNicholas - 491 days ago
1.6 - Their "bottom-line" prices only include first year costs
After yr 2:

PS3: $470
Arcade: $620
Premium: $500
Elite: $600

After yr 3:

PS3: $470
Arcade: $670
Premium: $550
Elite: $650

After yr 4:

PS3: $470
Arcade: $720
Premium: $600
Elite: $700

After yr 5:

PS3: $470
Arcade: $770
Premium: $650
Elite: $750

The Xbox360 lacks in-game keyboard and mouse support, a web-browser, motion control (for games such as the revolutionary Mirror's Edge), has an inferior HDMI specification, and, most importantly, the 360 doesnt have the world's best performing Blu-Ray player.
Shut this user up Let user speak
SpaZaA - 490 days 23 hours ago
1.7 - COULDN'T EDIT MY ORIGINAL COMMENT!
However I sure hope the disagrees are for the 1 bit "(soon to be 160GB)" which I now see was an error.
The rest of my comment is 100% accurate.

They are comparing the lower end PS3 to the 3 models of xbox360, not the 80GB PS3 that has emulated backwards compatibility with most PS2 games as well as all PSone games, 4 USB ports and ships with a game as well currently MGS4 ($59.99).
Shut this user up Let user speak
nickfr - 490 days 23 hours ago
1.8 - But you get a new X360 every year for free
That's the nice thing about the RROD, they'll ship you a new one every year. If you add the cost for a new PS3 every year the comparison looks totally different.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Dyingduck - 490 days 21 hours ago
1.9 - Are you retarded like the other Xbots???
THEY DON'T GIVE you a NEW Xbox, moron, they fix the hardware of the OLD
Shut this user up Let user speak
wallace1000 - 490 days 21 hours ago
1.10 - @ Dyingduck
Incorrect, depending on where you live they do not repair the xbox. Here in Canada they replace a faulty 360 with a brand new one.
Shut this user up Let user speak
wallace1000 - 490 days 19 hours ago
1.11 -
Maybe instead of clicking disagree lets see if you have ever returned an xbox 360 under warranty in Canada, or maybe even own a 360?
Shut this user up Let user speak
kevnb - 490 days 17 hours ago
1.12 - Its true
however alot of people only see the price tag on the box.
Shut this user up Let user speak
BWS1982 - 490 days 15 hours ago
1.13 - @ Nickfr
the point is that PS3's don't fault to the point where you should be needing a new one each year....I'm no fanboy, I want to own both, but each has some drawbacks, depending on how you look at it though, maybe one has more than another.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Willio - 490 days 14 hours ago
1.14 - Plagarising much?
@SpaZaA :

"Very good comparison
It's to be noted they are comparing the lower end PS3 to the 3 models of xbox360, not the 80GB PS3 (soon to be 160GB) that has emulated backwards compatibility with most PS2 games as well as all PSone games, 4 USB ports and ships with a game as well currently MGS4 ($59.99).
Parapraxis August 28, 2008 10:33 AM PT"

-Taken from the 1st comment on original source.

@MNicholas:

"The Xbox360 lacks in-game keyboard and mouse support, a web-browser, motion control (for games such as the revolutionary Mirror's Edge), has an inferior HDMI specification, and, most importantly, the 360 doesnt have the world's best performing Blu-Ray player.
Mark02138 August 28, 2008 11:48 AM PT"

-Taken from the 3rd comment on original source.

At least freaking re-word it... fail at writing english papers i presume?
Shut this user up Let user speak
TheExecutive - 490 days 4 hours ago
1.15 -
ok, so if you are really strapped for cash the 360 is a good way to get into HD gaming. If you want the best VALUE for your money buy a PS3.

OR you could buy the system that most of your friends have OR the gaming system that has the games you want.

Hmm, it seems like a personal decision.

Everyone knows that for the money you get a lot more in the PS3, straight out of the box.

PERSONALLY, I prefer the PS3 for the reliability of the hardware, the diversity of exclusive games, most of my friends have the PS3, the bluray player, free online, the PSN games (they are the best!), and I know the console will be supported for a long time.

But those are PERSONAL preferences and I dont presume to tell others theirs.
Shut this user up Let user speak
wallace1000 - 490 days 4 hours ago
1.16 - I give up
"Wise men never argue with fools, because people from a distance can't tell who is who"
Shut this user up Let user speak
SpaZaA - 490 days 2 hours ago
1.17 - @ Willio
I made the comment on PC world as well. Bet you feel clever now huh.
Shut this user up Let user speak
AclayPS3 - 491 days 1 hour ago
2 -
The Xbox 360 has always been more expensive than the PS3 because by the time you buy everything for the 360 to equal what the PS3 already has, you would have spent more money.

Even though the PS3 is the most expensive system, you get the most value for the money.

I think that Microsoft should at LEAST bundle the Wifi Adapter with the Xbox 360 Pro and/or Xbox 360 Elite model because even the Wii has built in Wifi and it makes no sense for the 360 not to have it, and it's ridiculous to have to spend $90 bucks for a overpriced Wifi Add-on for the 360. A lot of people still bash Sony for not bundling a HDMI cable with the PS3, but I think that I would rather get Wifi built in and buy a cheap HDMI cable on Ebay than to get No Built in Wifi at all with my system.
Shut this user up Let user speak
ruibing - 491 days ago
2.1 -
I agree with you. If it wasn't for the built-in wifi on my PS3, I wouldn't have been able to remote play so many games during the olympics (at least for the events I didn't care much for).

I also love the fact how open the PS3 is by using so many established protocols. Streaming music, hooking up any bluetooth headset, and working with one of my webcams. There are many of these features that are just a bit hard to justify into a comparison table, but they made the PS3 worth the purchase.
Shut this user up Let user speak
tplarkin7 - 490 days 22 hours ago
2.2 - Nonsense
When price is an issue, the 360 is much cheaper. For $199 plus $60 for a game, you can own a current console. It's the entry point that matters.
Shut this user up Let user speak
majorsuave - 490 days 18 hours ago
2.3 -
What's the use for wifi?
This is a game console, I'm not going to bring it in the garden or on the kitchen table, and yes the cable modem is near the cable tv.

And that same tv has a media center pc connected to it for everything that requires a hard drive, and keyboard/mouse gaming as well.
Shut this user up Let user speak
iceman2885 - 490 days 17 hours ago
2.4 - @2.3
Sure, you have you're cable modem near your cable TV so you can wire your 360 to the internet. But there are many many people that have their cable modem at their main computer which is in a computer room or away from their gaming console.

I know when I lived with my parents that's how it was, and I only had wireless internet in my room, which is where my ps3 and 360 where. So yeah, it doesn't matter for you, but I bet there are a bunch of people who wish their 360 had wireless so they didn't have to spend 90 bucks for a 360 only wireless adapter or go through the trouble and cost of getting an ethernet cable to their 360.

Just b/c its one way for you doesn't mean its the same for everyone.
Shut this user up Let user speak
kevnb - 490 days 17 hours ago
2.5 - i agree but...
the wii has built in nothing, no wifi, no ethernet, no recharbable battery pack, no dvd playback, and no component cables.
Shut this user up Let user speak
waltercross - 490 days 17 hours ago
2.6 -
The Wii is targetting a Different player.
Shut this user up Let user speak
SaiyanFury - 490 days 13 hours ago
2.7 -
@ 2.4

If you're looking for a cheaper solution to the 100 dollar Microsoft wireless adapter, and this is something that everyone here should read, look into a wireless ethernet bridge. It will make your Xbox 360 think it's hardwired into your router yet it will still be wireless. I did this with a wireless g-band ethernet bridge, and it works perfectly. And it's only half as muh as what Microsoft wants for theirs.
Shut this user up Let user speak
baodeus - 490 days 10 hours ago
2.8 -
Why don't PS3 remove the Wifi (which you also need a wireless router in your house) to make it more affordable? I'm still using the cable by the way (since i don't plan to move the xbox around with me where ever i go.) While it is nice to have but it is not needed.

And Sony really need to charge people for online since people claim PSN is comparable to Xbox live. It doesn't make sense for people to work for hours maintaining, adding contents and other stuff that you might want for free. They work to support themselves and their family. I'm pretty sure they would appreciate it if they get some extra money for their work.

Jeez, so many kids on N4G. Go get a job, but don't get pay for it. Give everyone what they want for free. Don't think about yourself or your family "you don't need money".
2.9 arrrgh | 490 days 4 hours ago - comment has been reported as SPAM -
Shut this user up Let user speak
SaiyanFury - 489 days 23 hours ago
2.10 -
@2.8

Baodeus, are you totally bent? Why doesn't Sony REMOVE the Wi-Fi to make the system affordable? Maybe because wireless internet interfacing is like a 20 dollar technology? Maybe because not everybody has their console right beside their router? Oh and BTW a wireless router costs like 40-50 dollars. And for my own personal interest, why do you start ranting on about supporting your family? These are game consoles, not a mortgage for a house...
Shut this user up Let user speak
Lost_My_600_Dollar - 491 days 1 hour ago
3 -
I don't need Wi-fi adapter or 120GB HDD and luckily there is no mandatory installs for games so 20GB is enough for me

plus, add 50$ for a good quality HDMI cable for the PS3
Shut this user up Let user speak
Tobias123 - 491 days 1 hour ago
3.1 -
That's all well and good(I don't use Wi-fi myself), but for a good HDMI cable you only need to add about $15.
Shut this user up Let user speak
IzKyD1331 - 491 days 1 hour ago
3.2 -
theres no such thing as a "quality" HDMI cable, a $10 HDMI cable works just as good as a $50 one, except the $50 one is longer, but since your console is always going to be like 1-2 feet away from your TV, a $50 cable is unnecesary....and you shouldn't even be talking, the arcade doesnt even come with HDMI....and wi-fi is necessary these days, try connecting your console to your modem from different rooms in the house and then talk.....and a large HDD is necessary too, an HD movie takes up ALOT of space....and SD movies take up considerable space too, but I dont have to worry because my PS3 has about 200 GB HDD, and I have more than 20 movies on it
Shut this user up Let user speak
morganfell - 491 days ago
3.3 -
http://www.walmart.com/cata...

Better yet:

http://www.newegg.com/Produ...

I have a 320GB drive in my PS3 and that space is needed. MS claims it isn't but I look at my 360 and by the time I get a few demos, some HALO 3 maps, and download 1 movie I am out of space. But my alternative is to buy a worthless 120Gb drive. Proprietary. I can get better than twice as much space on the PS3 for half the price.

MS should be glad they have been successfully lying to people about their HD movies. Anyone with at least 20/400 vision can see those HD movies aren't HD. Otherwise that 20GB...er...I mean 13 GB drive would really be worthless.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Mr Bun - 491 days ago
3.4 - @Morgan
Well put! Also I am noting that you have both consoles so you would know more about the pros and cons of each than most fanboys.

Nice jab with the formatted size at the end.

Bubbles.
Shut this user up Let user speak
kinggeoff - 491 days ago
3.5 - morganfell
@ izky

so because wifi is necessary for YOU, we should ALL have to pay for it? I like how MS gives you options so I don't need to buy the sht that i...well DON'T need.

I'm glad the PS3 comes with the bells and whistles. That's what it's for. Top of the line tech in a sleek box. It's an amazing machine. that's why people buy it

@ morganfell

the MS movie downloads ARE in HD. The codec they used for encoding them is just lousy. They're still 720p in resolution, which is HD no matter how you slice it. Do they look as good as HDDVDs or Blu Ray movies? nope not by a long shot. But they are still in HD.
Shut this user up Let user speak
mindedone - 491 days ago
3.6 - well make sure you add another 50
for a (good quality) hdmi cable for xbox. I work at an electronics retailer and not even I would buy the garbage with my 65% discount.
Shut this user up Let user speak
plain rice - 491 days ago
3.7 -
The HDMI cable the 360 come with is no different than the HDMI cables you buy at monoprice or Amazon for $5. I've tested Monster cables and cheap no brand HDMI cables and I can tell you there is NO difference at all. Tested on two of my high end tv sets. A Pioneer PDP Kuro Elite and my recently purchased Samsung 750 LCD. Both are 50" sets and are both professionally calibrated with the best possible configuration.
Shut this user up Let user speak
kinggeoff - 491 days ago
3.8 - people are fcking retarded
a digital signal is either INTACT or NOT.

If your HDMI cable fails to work, return it.

The reason for the long assed monster cables is that as you extend the length of an HDMI cable, you require much better shielding materials and techniques in order for the signal to remain intact at the longer lengths.

for anything 3ft and under, a $5 or $10 is perfectly fine. If you pay more than that for a short cable, I feel sorry for your wallet
Shut this user up Let user speak
morganfell - 491 days ago
3.9 -
Thanks for backing me up that 360 movies are not HD. True HD = 1080P

EDIT: It isn't a marketing term for my eyes nor for the eyes of many of the people in the general public. You can whimper all you want about the 360 but that is the sad fact. You can keep living in denial and that is your right. 1080p doesn't matter to most 360 owners except those that bought into the Microsoft Betamax HD DVD. Well I hate it for you.

You comments also do zero, ZERO, to negate the fact that the 20GB(13GB) version, you know the most prolific version, has little to no space available for anything once a few files and downloads are on the drive and a single sub-HD movie is downloaded.
Shut this user up Let user speak
kinggeoff - 491 days ago
3.10 - wtf
kind of crack?

now we're talking about "TRUE HD" (or FULLHD) which is just a marketing term pulled out of the air. I bet you think more Megapixels always means a better picture too... hahah soccer moms these days

please note: The term HD (high definition) is used for ANYTHING above SD and ED resolutions. 720p is HD

please do some research and pull your head from between your legs
Shut this user up Let user speak
Too_Hyped - 490 days 23 hours ago
3.11 -
@kinggeoff : no, sorry, true HD is 1080p, in this planet. Go read on every site you find.
3.12 arrrgh | 490 days 23 hours ago - comment has been reported as SPAM -
Shut this user up Let user speak
mindedone - 490 days 22 hours ago
3.13 -
I don't get the disagrees. Either they BOTH need an expensive HDMI or neither do. Xbox doesn't include a "high quality" one.
Shut this user up Let user speak
wallace1000 - 490 days 20 hours ago
3.14 - @ Too_Hyped
The term "True HD" is a marketing term and nothing else. 720p and 1080i are also high definition resolutions.
Shut this user up Let user speak
ruiner4482 - 490 days 20 hours ago
3.15 -
Or better yet how about $9.00 shipped priority mail.

http://www.monoprice.com/pr...
Shut this user up Let user speak
rofldings - 490 days 7 hours ago
3.16 -
+1 on monoprice cables. People at AVS forum swear by them...
Shut this user up Let user speak
kinggeoff - 491 days 1 hour ago
4 - I think you guys are missing the point of OPTIONS
the 360 CAN be MUCH cheaper than the PS3

OF COURSE it will be more expensive if you add on all the external upgrades...but if you wanted a system like that...why wouldnt you just buy a PS3?

I don't need wifi, I don't need an HDD upgrade. Everything that came WITH the 360 is fine by me. I was pretty shocked to open my ps3 and find no headset or HD cables of any kind, nor any accompanying games...but I got a sweet deal by bundling it with a TV so the ps3 price was $50 all told for the 40gb model.

My 360 came with forza2/marvel UA disc and guitar hero2 with a guitar... it was a good deal so I bought it.

Both systems tend to fetch a pretty penny if you want to use them to their full capabilities, but this article assumes you are buying a cheaper console with the intent on adding to it the features of a more expensive console...

that doesn't generally make too much sense...but i guess there are some morons out there
Shut this user up Let user speak
Alvadr - 491 days ago
4.1 -
By default, the 360 doesnt come with any games either. Only with special bundle packages (as with the 360).

One thing you deffinatly do need for the 360 that you dont get is a battery charging pack.. WTF, i was utterly gobsmacked when found this out..
Shut this user up Let user speak
The Lazy One - 491 days ago
4.2 - Though I agree about the battery pack...
It doesn't come with rechargeable batteries, so why would they put in the battery charger?

It would be a good choice to plop a play and charge kit in with the higher end systems though.
Shut this user up Let user speak
MNicholas - 491 days ago
4.3 - The only way the 360 is cheaper is
if you never do the following:

Play online with your friends
Download game demos
Want wireless online
Want to save new game data without having to delete your old saved games
Have music on your xbox360
Download movies

Even if you skip the hard-drive upgrade and wifi, you still spend an additional $250 over 5 years to play online with your friends.

Minimum bottom-line cost:

Arcade: $450
Premium: $550
Elite: $650

Owners of premium and the elite can download and play low-grade "HD" movies but are stuck with an outdated DVD drive, no access to a cheap and useful hard-drive upgrade (like a 500GB), and no wifi among other things.
Add Comment (Gamer Zone)
Gamer Zone Posting Guidelines
The Gamer Zone is for members who want a more friendly and civilized discussion. This section is heavily moderated by the N4G staff, so leave your fanboyism at the door please. Members who are unable to behave in a mature and respectful manner will be temporarily or permanently restricted from posting in the Gamer Zone. Using words such as Xbots and Sony droids, or other words from the console war vocabulary, is strictly prohibited in this Zone.
Read More...
 
 
You must log in to post comments.
Username:  
Password:  
 
 
About N4G
N4G is a social game news site that covers the game industry 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
More Info... | Submit News