130°

Why do videogame movies nearly always fail?

TVGB: "Videogame movies go back a long time. It kind of started out with the movie Cloak & Dagger, which was released simultaneously with the Atari arcade game back in 1984, and have come a long way since then in terms of budgets, qualities and advertising, but somehow they always seem to flunk out. Why is this, really?"
wohoo - contributor
Published: 551 days 19 hours ago | Article | PlayStation 3 | Xbox 360 | Gaming | PC
 
 

Showing: 1 - 31 of 31 Comments
Shut this user up Let user speak
ENNO - 551 days 20 hours ago
1 - Because..
There is so much detail and care that fits into 50 hours of gameplay, that can NOT be squeezed into 1hr.45 mins...[cough]final fantasy[cough]
Shut this user up Let user speak
player911 - 551 days 15 hours ago
1.1 - True
That plus the experience is off.

In games you spend time on your characters and care for them. You become more emotionally attached then just some random person in a movie.

Also it is the environment. Walking through a dreary house knowing something is gonna jump out at you creates a more intense sensation then watching a movie saying, "Don't open that door stupid the killer is back there".

Plus games don't need as big of a story to be fun or popular. You can play through a game that is fun without a story. Doom had a stupid story. La la la demons la la our last hope la la la save the world.

And for the record I thought Final Fantasy the movie was pretty cool. I wish they did more with it but a cool movie non-the-less.
Shut this user up Let user speak
SCFreelancer - 551 days 19 hours ago
2 -
The question is pretty obvious, its the same reason that keeps most companies from reaching a decent quality level with their games: lack of time.

These days developers have to release the game almost simultaneous with the movie no matter what the current state is. This makes it very hard to keep the level high and finish in time.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Nitrowolf2 - 551 days 19 hours ago
3 -
probaly because we exspect the movie to be as good as the video game
i think its because most think that the movie games will feel the same as the game, you know get that same feeling as if you were playing it and see something awsome. But eventually it comes to a part in the movie where you couldnt even do that in the game. It like WTF.
I mean wat if in MG movie snake shot energy through his hand at the end to kill the boss, im not saying that would happen but it would make the movie some wat cr@ppy, caus epeople be like "you cant do that in the game"
Shut this user up Let user speak
Sangria - 551 days 19 hours ago
4 -
If i remember well, some weeks ago in a TV show in France, there were a Hitman The Movie producer (or someone who worked for that movie) that was saying something clever: a game rarely reaches 2 millions units sold, but movie producers want a movie that make 20 millions of entries.

So because of that, video game-based movies always try to touch the widest audience, meaning more special effects, not complicated scenarios, etc... respecting less and less the video game.

In my opinion, the only movies that respected well video games were Mortal Kombat (sadly yes, technically it's a crappy movie but it's exactly as kitsch as the game, and it's the only movie where Christophe Lambert plays good enough) and Silent Hill.

But i'm pretty sure Hideo Kojima would be a great movie producer, he has a cinematographic sense that no one else has in video game industry. If one can do an epic movie, it's him.
Shut this user up Let user speak
player911 - 551 days 15 hours ago
4.1 -
Yea Silent Hill was a neat movie too.
Shut this user up Let user speak
KobeT24 - 551 days 19 hours ago
5 - -
Probably because the problem is that producers believe that they will have a built-in audience based on name recognition, and thus don't push writers to develop a good script, or push directors to keep the seams tight, lots of the actors sort of 'phone in' their performances, etc.

The problem is that everybody involved seems to just see the film as a moneymaker - tie in, and don't really give their heart and soul. Nobody's shooting for an oscar with these films.

They also dont seem to stick with the story. Example Resident Evil. The first one was similar enough but the second fell off track and the third had nothing to do with the games. Same with Doom. Just Hype.
Shut this user up Let user speak
The gaming GOD - 551 days 19 hours ago
6 - I think
They fail partially because movie videogames aren't true to their roots.

They add extra characters, extra story aspects, and sometimes even unknown protagonists. In other words, they normally fail because they aren't canonical.

For the average movie goer, that's ok because they aren't aware that the story is wrong. However, for the gamer that KNOWS how to stories are meant to be told, that doesn't go over so well because it's not true to its roots.

But that's my opinion. Not fact.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Gun_Senshi - 551 days 19 hours ago
7 - 2 words
Uwe Boll
Shut this user up Let user speak
cmrbe - 551 days 18 hours ago
8 - I doubt
Any game has scripts as polish as most A grade movies. This is something that most people don't think off. MGS4.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Asurastrike - 551 days 18 hours ago
9 -
Because games are meant to be played.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Bubble Buddy - 551 days 18 hours ago
10 -
Maybe because they care more about selling the game, then even triyng on making a decent game.
Shut this user up Let user speak
name - 551 days 18 hours ago
11 -
Silent hill and advent children were great movies
Shut this user up Let user speak
daydream - 551 days 15 hours ago
11.1 -
I might be alone, but I enjoyed Spirit Within more than Advent Children. I loved that whole space environment not to mention the cgi graphics which were incredible at the time.
Shut this user up Let user speak
player911 - 551 days 15 hours ago
11.2 -
Advent children could only be appreciated by lovers of the FF7 game. Without playing or really knowing the game, you can't watch the movie and expect to understand any of it.

I enjoyed both movies, but Spirit Within was created as a lone movie that required no background knowledge.
Shut this user up Let user speak
daydream - 551 days 12 hours ago
11.3 -
Well that makes sense. Yeah, never played Final Fantasy VII. Thanks for clearing that up for me.
Shut this user up Let user speak
IzKyD1331 - 551 days 18 hours ago
12 -
The Prince of Persia movie looks bleak (sure, Disney covering the movie will no doubt mean the special effects, actors and production values are spot on, but i doubt they'll capture the magic the videogame(s) had.
But im actually really excited about the upcoming Bioshock movie, mainly because i feel that more people should have the pleasure of experiencing this incredible story (assuming they stay true to the story that is)
Max Payne will either be done right or wrong, just have to wait and see (not alot of waiting though, its coming out this year)
Shut this user up Let user speak
iamtehpwn - 551 days 17 hours ago
13 - Spirits Within
failed because it had NOTHING to do with final fantasy.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Panthers - 551 days 17 hours ago
13.1 -
The problem with most Video Game movie is they deviate from the story of the game. When they base a movie off of a book, they follow it to a T. Why not with games?
Shut this user up Let user speak
player911 - 551 days 15 hours ago
13.2 -
Each final fantasy is separate from another final fantasy.

So your comment is retarded. Final Fantasy games aren't linked together in any way aside from always having a character named Cid.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Baba1906 - 551 days 14 hours ago
13.3 -
i must agree with iamthepwn. the game did not ahve ff in it at all. sure ff are allways different.. but they still need the ff thing. some things just cant be missing. like magic, summoning and so on. spirit within was just an action movie. the comment is not retardet at all.
the storys are not linked but it has allways a ff feeling going on, and sspirit within doesnt have that.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Fanboi - 551 days 9 hours ago
13.4 - It was too Japanese
Spirit Within failed because it was a Japanese movie marketed toward the American audience, thats an autofail. Americans do not understand nor do they care about crap like "Gaia" or alien spirts. Most people who walked out of theater have no idea WTF they just saw. Plus the action totally blows, it lack the dynamic action sequences that the FF series is know for.
Shut this user up Let user speak
LostChild - 551 days 17 hours ago
14 - Simply put...
game based movies fail because they aren't taken seriously. They are only made to make a quick buck off the hype/popularity of a given game. Until game movies are taken seriously just like today's comicbook movies, they will continue to fail.
Shut this user up Let user speak
AclayPS3 - 551 days 17 hours ago
15 -
Well, the Hitman movie based off of the Hitman video game series was a pretty good movie and is really one of the few video game based movies that I've seen.

Personally I think that Video Game movies end up failing a lot because there really isn't a lot of well known actors in video game based movies. If Gerard Butler played as Kratos in a God of War movie or if Tom Cruise played as someone in a video game based movie, it would be an instant hit. The majority of big, hot selling movies have well known A-list actors in them, and without big name actors in a movie, the movie wont be as much of a hit... however, there are a few exceptions because there are times when a movie may be released with actors you aren't familiar with (like 300) and it ends up being a hit.

Basically, if more A-list actors start getting Video Game Movie roles, more Video Game Movies will be hits.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Fanboy Slaughter - 551 days 17 hours ago
16 - Castlevania
Is going to be the latest casuality in bad VG movies. Becuase Sylvain White is directing it and Paul "game raper" Anderson wrote it. For those of you wondering about Sylvain White, he's the cinematic mastermind behind the smash hits "Stomp the Yard", and who could forget the straight-to-DVD "I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer"

Castlevania is doomed, to say the least.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Zeevious - 551 days 7 hours ago
16.1 - I almost had...
with millions and millions in therapy and a few sharks with frikkin' laserbeams on their heads, and now you've brought it all back!

I hope Castlevania isn't doomed, but sure sounds like the wrong people are in charge. If not it means much more work for me...

If only I hadn't had my therapy group liquidated for their insolence...
Shut this user up Let user speak
Baba1906 - 551 days 15 hours ago
17 -
well a game is for the most part good or bad depending on its gameplay, story and graphics. story and graphics can be done on a movie. but the gameplay just cant be brought alive. and i dont know it just gets me a bit mad if i see a ff movie without summonings, magic and big swords. spirit within could have been named different couse it just didnt have the ff feeling. i did enjoy it.

probably the movie series i enjoy although its not 1:1 to the games are, resident evil. i kinda liked it.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Mitchell - 551 days 14 hours ago
18 - Movies aren't games, that's why
Movies lack the depth of immersion that games provide. The crew tries to pack a storyline on average between 5-20 hours into an hour and a half. That's already a setup for an epic fail.

Then there's fan-service, which usually sucks firstly because the actors chosen rarely ever look like the game characters, because the game characters are made from scratch, based only off of the generic human template.

And many times it seems that the crew aren't big gamers themselves.

I say 10-15 of us save up some cash and form a studio. Let's nab Metal Gear Solid before it officially gets caught by money-hungry morons who know nothing of the source material except that kids will like it and a sex scene could fit.
Shut this user up Let user speak
longbug - 551 days 11 hours ago
19 - Book syndrome
Good comment from Mitchell. I would also say that changing from one medium to another has always lessened the experience. How many times have I heard the book was better than the film. Same applies to games. A film should only use a game as inspiration and not try to emulate its content so obsessively. However, I'm one of the few who enjoyed Doom, if I wasn't a gamer, my perspective would have been different, for better or worse I don't know.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Alcohog - 551 days 6 hours ago
20 -
Cloak and Dagger was an awesome flick for me when I was a little kid.
Shut this user up Let user speak
gumgum99 - 551 days 1 hour ago
21 - It all depends on "the gift"
Either you got it for game based movies or not. Apparently their isnt a whole lot of the former. I'm sure someone will come along, take a game franchice that no one thought would ever translate so well(think toy based transformer's success) and totally blow our minds.

And i dont mean a franchice that can be done(like Halo) I mean a game that you wouldn't think twice about

Just hope it isnt pac-man. There is no hope for that movie.
Add Comment (Gamer Zone)
Gamer Zone Posting Guidelines
The Gamer Zone is for members who want a more friendly and civilized discussion. This section is heavily moderated by the N4G staff, so leave your fanboyism at the door please. Members who are unable to behave in a mature and respectful manner will be temporarily or permanently restricted from posting in the Gamer Zone. Using words such as Xbots and Sony droids, or other words from the console war vocabulary, is strictly prohibited in this Zone.
Read More...
 
 
You must log in to post comments.
Username:  
Password:  
 
 
About N4G
N4G is a social game news site that covers the game industry 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
More Info... | Submit News