Next Gen Games: To HD or not to HD?

tplarkin7 - 597 days ago

Frame rate is key and it must be smooth, but a lower res is a disappointment. Halo 3 and COD4 look great but there is some aliasing issues that would be resolved if they ran at 720p natively.

Agree(1) | Disagree(4) | Report

season007 - 596 days 22 hours ago

why not to have a higher res crisper picture...i mean

do the basics then go for the advance, not the other way around

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report

cain141 - 597 days 2 hours ago

I sorta did, thats why I only bought my 720p TV... Helps when you wait on things a bit...

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report

paul_war - 597 days 2 hours ago

That's part of the problem people are having.

There was a lot of talk of 1080p gaming before this generation started & it seems some games are struggling to reach 720p.

There is no denying that some of these games look great, and of course I would sacrifice resolution for a stable frame-rate.

It's just that people's high def TV's are not being used fully, and this ‘gen’ may not be the high-def era it was touted, at least not till the end of this 'gen' or even the next.

Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report

JOLLY1 - 597 days 1 hour ago

I play console games because they are simple and fun. You put in a disk and go. I don't have to worry about checking resolution. I don't need to turn on different color schemes. I don't need to check my white balance to see if the developer produced the game with white balancing. I don't have to install part of the game to my hard drive. I just put my game disk in and go. I love it!

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report

cain141 - 597 days 2 hours ago

How do people like you get in the Gamerzone? It has happened with Halo and other 360 titles as well...

Agree(4) | Disagree(2) | Report

paul_war - 597 days 2 hours ago

It’s happened more recently on the PS3, that’s for sure, but remember the most famous case is till Halo 3.

Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report

Fishy Fingers - 597 days 2 hours ago

Halo 3? COD4?

It has nothing to do with which console, it all comes down to choices made by the developers.
Actually it come more down to "gamers" being fussy enough to care about this sort of rubbish.
The fact remains you had to be TOLD about the res difference in all these games.

Dont remember anyone saying "wow, the resolution seems a little low" do you?

Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report

ravinash - 596 days 22 hours ago

The 360 and PS3 are capable of doing 720 and 1080, although at that resolution I wouldn't expect too much to be happening on the screen at any one moment.
The problem is the companies making the games have time tables and budgets to stick to, and there is no real benefit to upgrading the resolution when it comes to sales.
Imagine buying a house and then investing massive amounts of time and money putting in gold taps and hand rails only to find it has not raised the value of the house at all.
A good game will sell. No one was expecting GTA4 to be running at the highest resolution, and yet its one of the biggest selling games ever.

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report

ban fans - 597 days ago

People jump all over companies when a new technology comes out because they feel it should be used to its fullest potential right out of the gate (I blame this on the "instant gratification syndrome" everyone seems to suffer from in this day and age). Simply put, tech takes time. Anyone who thought every games on PS3 and Xbox360 would be running in full HD should have their head examined. It is not practical or even possible with most games as the space is best used to create a better experience, not just pretty backgrounds.

Another factor I think people don't take into account is that a lot of people don't own 1080p capable televisions yet. If, say, 15-20% of PS3 owners have a 1080p TV, is it really worth the effort on the part of a game developer to focus man power on creating something that only that small percentage of gamers can truly take advantage of? I think they have already answered with a big "No!".

I think you will see more high resolution games as these systems age and more people can make use of that tech, but until the install base of HDTVs becomes the standard, I wouldn't expect to see many that run at that high resolution.

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report

bpmurr - 597 days 1 hour ago

If you've played COD4 on a PC running at 1920x1080 native with full AF and AA it blows the doors off the 360&PS3 versions upscaled to 1080p. Just the texture detail alone makes a big difference. I will admit that COD4 and Halo wouldn't looks that much different at native 720P. However, I think they need to drop the HD crap if they can't even meet the lowest HD spec.

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report

LinuxGuru - 597 days ago

Uncharted BLOWS away GTA IV.

No comparison.

Except for the animation.

They're both using procedural animation, and that's one thing I love about both games.

Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report

digger18 - 597 days 1 hour ago

PS3 = More games 720P and over
360 = More games 720P and under

Agree(3) | Disagree(5) | Report

g3nkie - 597 days 1 hour ago

1. Thats the dumbest comment I've heard so far....

Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report

Varsarus - 597 days ago

You do know the 360 can just lower the resolution to increase framerates and scale it back up to a native 720p using it's hardware scaler?, directly cheating it's way to get better framerates than PS3 in multiplatform games...

Halo 3 is a prime example for doing this...

and if GTA IV was 640p on PS3, then they've used a software scaling technique that just takes power away from running the game and it can also take up an SPU, so why would Rockstar do that?, if they didn't do any software scaling, then PS3 version of GTA IV will be 720p, this also goes out to Dark Sector, COD4 and such games that are lower than 720p except 576i/p on PS3.

Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report

n00bPwner - 596 days 22 hours ago

sony fanboys = just plain DUMB.

Agree(1) | Disagree(3) | Report

meepmoopmeep - 596 days 22 hours ago

umm... i'm pretty sure what they said was that the ps3 was "capable" of 1080p/60fps.

and what they were talking about wasn't just for gaming but movies as well.

Agree(2) | Disagree(3) | Report

ELite_Ghost - 596 days 15 hours ago

wardevil, GT5, NGS, Ridge Racer...

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report