300°

Is the PS3 More Popular than the Nintendo Wii?

From the article: "Critics of the Nintendo Wii suggest that the remote control is just a gimmick, the novelty of which may soon wear off in the face of high performance consoles such as the Playstation 3. The controller also presents problems for 3rd party software vendors, because of its unique design, and Nintendo has tended to highlight its own games and been weak in its support of 3rd party titles.

The Playstation 3, on the other hand, relies on superior technology – a powerful, multicore, Cell processor, an RSX ("Reality Synthesiser") graphics chip from NVIDIA, and a maximum resolution of 1080p (in the 60GB version) – as its unique selling point."
Rowland - contributor
Published: 540 days 11 hours ago | Article | PlayStation 3 | Wii | Industry News
 
 

Showing: 1 - 50 of 50 Comments
Shut this user up Let user speak
Tacki - 540 days 13 hours ago
1 - Man, this is hilarious!
Seriously I just can't wait for the responses here in the comments. This article is even more silly than some of flamebait PS3 vs. 360 ones that pop up every other day.

This seems like it's supposed to be some kind of ego boost for Sony fans. But is that really neccessary? lol The Wii has the casual consumers firmly in its grasp. The PS3 appeals much more to hardcore gamers.

One being more 'popular' depends solely on your perspective and what markets, demograph, etc. are included. In the end people will believe whatever they want to believe.
Shut this user up Let user speak
kr9091 - 540 days 12 hours ago
1.1 - I agree
But I wouldn't say that the author is trying to prove that the PS3 is outselling the Wii. he is simply stating the differences in the two consoles and seems to think that in the long run, the PS3 will come out on top due to the amount of extra features the PS3 has compared to the Wii (since the Wii is on the lower end of the spectrum when it comes to extra features whether you are comparing it to the PS3 OR the 360.)

Im sure the PS3 will EVENTUALLY catch up to the Wii considering the PS3 has approached Wii sales numbers on a few occasions, but not anytime soon. That's my two cents.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Jamie Foxx - 540 days 12 hours ago
1.2 - IN A WORD-HELL NO
but things are turning and the ps3 is starting to make the right steps.

sony should have thought out the ps3 more though-no ingame xmb or rumble controllers at the launch was just the tip of a very big iceberg of mistakes but slowly but surely things are looking up, only good thing sony wont make the same mistakes come ps4 fingers burnt and all that
Shut this user up Let user speak
plenty a tool - 540 days 11 hours ago
1.3 - what is this rubbish lol??
yeah ofcourse it's more popular. sony must be rubbing their hands!

in japan sony average 9k a week sales whilst nintendo average 50k

in europe sony average 50k a week whilst nintendo average over 100k

in NA sony average 50k a week whilst nintendo average over 100k
NA and europe are pretty much the same.

you can just see how much more popular the ps3 is compared to the wii???????

what a ridiculous article. who approved this garbage????????????
Shut this user up Let user speak
harrisk954 - 540 days 8 hours ago
1.4 - This article is completely retarded...
First of all, the title is completely misleading. It is not about the "popularity" of either system... it is comparing the specs and technology... of course the PS3 is a more advanced system, but that has nothing to do with the popularity contest, which (unfortunately) the Wii is winning.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Some_One_Plays - 540 days 7 hours ago
1.5 - Jamie_Foxx
No rumble was due to the law sue they had about the PlayStation 2 and was settled just before the launch of the PlayStation 3. On that part Sony had no choice but to get rid of the technology for a while. With in-game XMB I think Sony just wanted the console out so by the end of 2008 everything should be on par.

With the choices with the PlayStation 3 I think it was genius because who's really ready to buy a new console in 2010? Sony's console is future proof it has the technology with stand the next competition for a while. With the PlayStation 4 they should focus of how we interact with video games rather than features.
Shut this user up Let user speak
iamtehpwn - 540 days 4 hours ago
1.6 - Wii wins popularity because
Older audiences and women are able to access the Wii, and propel them into video games. I personally think it's great that it's doing it.

As an owner of all 3 consoles, I definitely feel that PS3 is the one with the most potential for us in the hardcore, However, I also feel PS3 being able to reach to a casual audience the same way PS2 did.

However, Wii is definitely breaking bounds with the casual, and I enjoy playing Wii myself sometimes. The experience of just "hoping in to the game" is pretty cool. I mean, I can always just hop on for a second, collect a star or two, on Mario Galaxy, and stop playing. =P
1.7 MADGameR | 539 days 22 hours ago - User only got 1 bubble - Show
Shut this user up Let user speak
kr9091 - 540 days 12 hours ago
2 - Good article, however...
Im not sure if they are up to date on the latest PS3 info.

1. They mention the 60gb version which has obviously been discontinued.

Quote: "The Playstation 3, on the other hand, relies on superior technology – a powerful, multicore, Cell processor, an RSX (”Reality Synthesiser”) graphics chip from NVIDIA, and a maximum resolution of 1080p (in the 60GB version) – as its unique selling point."

2. They state that PS3 controllers have no rumble functionality. Which is true to some extent because the sixaxis does not have rumble but if you really wanted rumble then you could just buy a DS3.

Quote: "The Playstation 3 also features a wireless, motion-sensitive, controller – known as the “SixAxis” – but this lacks the force feedback, or “rumble”, feature available on the Nintendo Wii."

EDIT: Thanks for clearing that up tay. I didn't catch that.
Shut this user up Let user speak
TayTayShaniqua - 540 days 12 hours ago
2.1 -
"They state that PS3 controllers have no ruble functionality."

That's because the article is from the UK where the DS3 isn't out yet.
Shut this user up Let user speak
pwnsause - 540 days 12 hours ago
2.2 -
isnt it out now? i thought it came out yesterday?
Shut this user up Let user speak
shadowghost752 - 540 days 10 hours ago
2.3 -
The Dual shock 3 is out and came out yesterday, i know because i bought one yesterday

http://www.game.co.uk/PS3/H...
Shut this user up Let user speak
ash_divine - 540 days 12 hours ago
3 - I wanted to like this article simply because of what the title suggests
but the truth is... it sucked. it just compared the two's specs, without even stating how they came to the conclusion that they did. the worst part is that the writer left the article so open-ended making seem as if the writer was just comparing facts for the heck of it.

PS: i love my PS3 but looking at the sales of the Wii there's no way it Sony's machine could be more popular.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Conan997 - 540 days 11 hours ago
4 - huh?
"and a maximum resolution of 1080p (in the 60GB version)" every ps3 has a maximum resolution of 1080p.
Shut this user up Let user speak
rakgi - 540 days 11 hours ago
5 -
wow I know it's supposedly all pro sony but I stopped reading after this "and introduced the so-called “Playstation Network”"
Shut this user up Let user speak
Isaac - 540 days 4 hours ago
5.1 - Yeah, I mean why would he say that?
Why would he say that Sony introduced the PlayStation Network? Everyone knows Sony did not do that, even though Sony owns the PlayStation brand. Counter-intuitive, but true.
....
...
..
.
.
.
Oh wait.
Shut this user up Let user speak
rakgi - 539 days 19 hours ago
5.2 -
its the fact that he said SO-CALLED playstation network that is what its called so it shouldnt be so-called plus the 60GB only has 1080p HA hes a fool
Shut this user up Let user speak
Bordello1900 - 540 days 11 hours ago
6 -
Is bread more popular than caviar?
Shut this user up Let user speak
TruthbeTold - 539 days 23 hours ago
6.1 - Yep.
Bread is a solid, good tasting staple food, while Caviar is an expensive, fancy, acquired taste that the mainstream may dabble in on occasion, but do not prefer. Nice comparison.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Pedobear - 540 days 10 hours ago
7 - Yes.
Yes it is.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Pedo Bear - 540 days 2 hours ago
7.1 -
You look familiar....
Shut this user up Let user speak
Pedobear - 539 days 22 hours ago
7.2 -
Holy crap. My twin brother!
Shut this user up Let user speak
KeiZka - 539 days 20 hours ago
7.3 -
I lol'd. Bubbles to both.
8 xboxftw | 540 days 10 hours ago - deleted by mod -
Shut this user up Let user speak
Product - 540 days 10 hours ago
9 -
Why do people still compare these two consoles???
Thats like comparing a Prius(Nintendo) to a Ferrari(Sony).Of course the Ferrari is going to be wanted by everyone thats a racing fan or loves power and will excel at every possible catagory but in reality the bulk of america will pick the Prius due to its innovation in todays market(higher gas mileage) in todays slumping economy(we all arent rich)
Shut this user up Let user speak
TheExodus - 540 days 9 hours ago
9.1 -
No, you're actually wrong. MS, Nintendo & Sony are all competing for a share of the same market while Toyota & Ferrari are not.
Shut this user up Let user speak
PMantix - 540 days 8 hours ago
9.2 -
Nintendo isn't outselling the Wii to the ps3 and the 360 by selling to the hardcore or mainstream gamer (i.e. the last generation market)...

Almost all those sales are to people who have never played games or bought a console before (the casual market).. so they are not fighting for the same market share anymore.
Shut this user up Let user speak
green - 540 days 8 hours ago
9.3 - Product
How can you Categorize the PS3 to a Ferrari and a Wii to a Toyota Prius?You know that Ferrari make a maximum of 6,000 cars a year and the cheapest going for 130,000 pounds while Toyota make over 9 million cars and the most expensive at 58,000pounds.

Never in the history of those 2 car manufacturers have they ever fought for the same market share or customers.But the truth is that Sony is trying to capture some market share from Nintendo with titles like Buzz and Singstar and Nintendo the same with titles like Metroid Prime, Zelda and so on.

So in the end Sony,Microsoft and Nintendo are in direct competition weather we like it or not.
Shut this user up Let user speak
TheExodus - 540 days 9 hours ago
10 -
Last week Wii nearly outsold 360 & PS3 combined by a margin of 2:1, worldwide, so PS3 is obviously more popular than Wii as consumers rarely go to Wal-Mart to buy things they actually want.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Blackcanary - 540 days 8 hours ago
11 - People need to get there Facts right!!
People need to get there facts right about Why Sony never had Runmble when the PS3 first came out.
Sony and MS got sued for Not paying the company that made rumble for there controllers i think its called a patent in the end MS payed up but sony didn't they didn't think they did anything wrong and didn't want to pay up so the court case geting going on untill sony payed the company for the Patent. Once they did the company went to work with sony again to make the DS3 SIXAXES.

Please gtet ur facts when it comes to why Sony didn't bring out the DS3 when the PS3 first came out they had no choice.

and if you disagree with Look it up ur self and u'll see that i was telling the truth.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Voiceofreason - 540 days 7 hours ago
11.1 -
Blame Sony not the people. It was Sony after all that made excuses like "Rumble is a last gen feature" or the excuse they used saying motion controls and rumble couldnt work together. Even though the Wii remote had both at the time Sony was using the excuse.. People might actually know the truth if Sony had admitted it from the beginning
Shut this user up Let user speak
Blackcanary - 539 days 19 hours ago
11.2 - @11.1
Being sued is not a good company image to have and if sony had told the world about it it would of looked really bad during the time it happend.

Yes they should had never of made the excuses that they made about not being able to bring out rumble during that time.

But what else could they of said with out people finding out what happend back then and them look like a right bunch of incorpitant people.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Tunerboy8732 - 540 days 8 hours ago
12 - Of course the Wii is more popular
We all know the PS3 is powerful enough to make the Wii commit suicide and has features the Wii could never do but lets be honest.The Wii relates more to the younger audience which is alot larger than the adult audience.I think kids rather kill people with Wii remotes than play MGS 4 and watch movies on a format they cant even spell.
Shut this user up Let user speak
KeiZka - 539 days 20 hours ago
12.1 -
What are you smoking, honestly? AFAIK it seems to be the 1337 kids that want either X0 or PS3, not Wii. True, all consoles have mature audience, but it's not "wise" to go and claim that a specific console has a "certain demographic in their pocket", unless you can validate your claim with reputable sources.

You do, can you?
Shut this user up Let user speak
Sheddi - 540 days 8 hours ago
13 -
i think both ps3 and 360 are more popular!
(i hate the wii thats why i think that)
Shut this user up Let user speak
Product - 540 days 8 hours ago
14 -
Wow splitting hairs here on a game site....

Alright people who know their cars Ferrari is owned by Fiat in which shares the same market as Toyota.Toyota is the number one auto maker in the world(Nintendo) and Fiat(Sony) is desperately trying to chip into their sales even in the european market share.Now since Fiat(Sony) owns Ferrari,Alfa Romeo,and Maserati(Ps3) which can all (besides alfa romeo since its an economy based subsidary) be considered "hardcore" are selling well towards the people who love those cars,but since Fiat also has Alfa(casual games) they are starting to sell better making Fiat(Sony) more profit and a bigger chunk out of the market share.

Now saying this everyone knows that no one will touch Toyota(Nintendo) this generation so yes if you really want to split hairs just to argue yes they are not in the same market share but in the bigger picture they are.

Besides you missed the point the Prius is an innovation in this day of age with its hybrid motor while the Ferrari is brute power just like the console themselves.Nintendo is innovative through the motion sensor tech and the Sony is brute power.
Shut this user up Let user speak
mint royale - 540 days 7 hours ago
14.1 - Sorry to split even more hairs but
the innovations by toyota and nintendo you mention are flawed cos nintendo's innovations (for the most part have worked) whilst that whole hybrid engine doesnt save more fuel or the trees at all and is just marketing bullshit!
Shut this user up Let user speak
Ninja-Sama - 540 days 7 hours ago
15 - Apparently only the now discontinued 60 gb version of the PS3 supports 1080p.
Lawl. Guess those 80gig owners (me) and 40 gig owners pretty much got shafted huh. Seriously nooby article. I dislike the Wii but I'm not delusional enough to deny its overwhelming popularity.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Product - 540 days 6 hours ago
16 -
...sigh...

dude a hybrid electric car shuts the motor down at idle(every red light) reducing emissions as well as saving gas.also regenerative braking recharges the battery and provides stored power for workign electrical devices such as the AC and lights(ever had a dead battery due to lights?)

If its such marketing bs why is GM,VW(aswell as thier Audi subsidary),Renault,Citroen,For d among others are either in developement of a hybrid or looking into.yea real bs........why am i even defending my statement everyones opinion is right here.
Shut this user up Let user speak
KeiZka - 539 days 19 hours ago
16.1 -
Bah, "Let's go hybrid". Why not straight to hydrogen energy, hmm? Would save nature far more... No markets, you say? Make them. With current gasoline prices, I wouldn't be surprised if some entrepreneurs decided to separate Hydrogen from ocean water and then sell it forward (the process is less hazardous than many can think about.)
Shut this user up Let user speak
PimpHandHappy - 540 days 6 hours ago
17 - Toyota
does have a car that does 50MPG

not many car makers have one car that does that. I own 2 cars and one of them is a 1994 Toyota 4runner and the thing runs like champ. I havent been driving it much because it gets 10mpg while my other car gets 21mpg..

just saying the Japs make some good stuff. The average Jap works longer and harder then your average American!

anyway on point

This article is silly
Shut this user up Let user speak
phantomexe - 540 days 6 hours ago
18 -
PS3 sales are down in japan when they should be up do to MGS4.....What happens in japan in time effects us all sadly.PS3 needs another hit title and soon.I'm not sure if the ps3 will ever catch the wii this gent.Nintendo got too maney big games with over 30 in house delopment teams ,but i do think the ps3 will do ok overall.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Isaac - 540 days 3 hours ago
19 -
""The Nintendo Wii, on the other hand, succeeded the Nintendo GameCube and focused on unique, innovative game play "

The Wii is NOT focused on gameplay, the Wii is focused on selling gimmicks. The Wii is a great case of great marketing, not a great case of a great product, unlike the PS3, which is a great product with poor marketing since people do not even know why there is extra cost. That is why the Wii is really popular, not because it is good, but because it makes people think it is good.

Poor Wii owners, they think that the Wiimote actually detects your precise movements when you can simply sit lazily and waggle. But hey, more power to the morons that want something "new" instead of something "good" (and who said good can not be new?). And while that is great for Nintendo, I refuse to buy into something that insults our intelligence.
Shut this user up Let user speak
KeiZka - 539 days 19 hours ago
19.1 -
Why am I suddenly reminded of Sixaxis, hmm... And how much do FPS games insult your intelligence? Play rather Openttd.
Shut this user up Let user speak
scissor_runner - 538 days 19 hours ago
19.2 -
If the Wii is a great case of selling on gimmicks then the PS3 is SONY raping it's fans to stay alive and get a new DVD format going. I'd rather buy a gimmick... this is also what people called gaming period after the atari crash. Thanks to nintendo this gimmick is lasting pretty long and hell we got HD guys with nose bleed tech trying to wow us also. Just imagine what they are going to do next gen because they sure as hell can not make a game every one want to try. MS and SONY don't just become their comp they just try to copy. Call it a gimmick but you must also see the gimmick associated with high end graphics don't you? It's the same one that killed the arcades. Arcades did not die because people did not like them they died because they cost too much, I mean $2-4 for daytona? Bad business.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Iceman100x - 540 days 3 hours ago
20 - hmm let me guess.....
Lol course it's not popular with anyone nobody wants to own a sony system anymore, especially because they have no games....duh.

"The Wii is NOT focused on gameplay"

so why is it no.1, and why is the ds no.1? you really must not like games... go fold with ps3 that should be fun.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Product - 540 days 3 hours ago
21 -
Its alright isaac is always like this...another product comes to mind though.The Ipod which has less features then the zune or a samsung mp3 and less powerful yet has 75% market share.
Shut this user up Let user speak
lynta - 539 days 20 hours ago
22 - nope...
the wii is more popular...

cheers!...
Shut this user up Let user speak
Blackcanary - 539 days 18 hours ago
23 -
Nintendo down fall is to make a NEXT gen Console with last gen graphics that can't even play DVD films or play CDs. I have all 3 consoles but the last game i got for the Wii was super Mario Galaxy. And the last time i played that was when it first came out.
Your never gonna see the games that u get on the 360 and the PS3 and it will come to the point where game companys will stop downgrideing game graphics just so it can come out on the Wii.

Soon the hype will die on the Wii just like all fads and things that are hyped sooner or later that hype dies down.

Sometimes it isn't that great to stay thinking out side the box.

Now with games getting bigger and needing more space how many companys are really gonna waste there time porting games on to the Wii thats why Resident Evil 5 will never see its face on the Wii same goes for the Next DMC game unless Nintendo try to get exclusives on them and even if they did i don't think some companys would do it.

because they wanna beable to do new things and the only new thing u can really do with the Nintendo Wii when it comes to there games is some thing crazy with the controller.

With games like Nintendo dogs and that cooking Mama game on the Wii how much more are people really gonna wanna buy a console with those type of games.

The only good games out on that console are the First party one and not even some of thoes are that great SSBB and MK and legend of Zelda and Mario and Metraled prime sorry about spelling are people the only great games going for it.

The hype on the Wii will die down when thats something only time can tell.
Shut this user up Let user speak
scissor_runner - 538 days 19 hours ago
24 -
What is funny is the author tries to say that tech and games are the things that will beat the Wii out. Well if that's the case then PC gaming would be the right choice for this. You can get PCs just as big as the PS3 with bigger hard drives and even play lots of PS3 games not to mention the true casual games like online poker and the office classic solitaire! Then you can get games like the drug dealer sim LOL. Then you can actually make maps for a PS3 game and some PCs will cost you $400 new! You can watch all the MGS4 cut scenes on you tube! For free! Some how the Wii still survives the onslaught of the PC amazing huh? The game list on the PS3 just isn't doing it for me. Maybe they will show me some good stuff during E3. I'm hoping to be hyped with this true gen talk!
Add Comment (Gamer Zone)
Gamer Zone Posting Guidelines
The Gamer Zone is for members who want a more friendly and civilized discussion. This section is heavily moderated by the N4G staff, so leave your fanboyism at the door please. Members who are unable to behave in a mature and respectful manner will be temporarily or permanently restricted from posting in the Gamer Zone. Using words such as Xbots and Sony droids, or other words from the console war vocabulary, is strictly prohibited in this Zone.
Read More...
 
 
You must log in to post comments.
Username:  
Password:  
 
 
About N4G
N4G is a social game news site that covers the game industry 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
More Info... | Submit News