GameLemon:
"Even though there are definitely some positive aspects to Mario Super Sluggers, the overall experience still falls flat. While the multiplayer is fun for an hour or two and the chemistry system makes team creation more entertaining than it would otherwise be, there's nothing here to keep you entertained for more than a few hours. Rent it for a weekend, play it with your buddies, and then send it back, the only people who will really enjoy this title are the ones who still get milk breaks and recess. Man I miss recess..."
