Brian Szabelski writes:
"With about as much replay value as any other sports title, Super Sluggers is a decent title. The graphics are decent, the game plays decently and there's really nothing remarkable about this title. The fact that the Wii remote's capabilities are not used to their full extent is somewhat of a disappointment, but it doesn't cripple the game entirely. If you didn't play Mario Superstar Baseball, this might be worth a look. If you did, then this is probably something to avoid unless you liked it enough to buy the same game twice."