While it does feel a little uninspired, it's difficult to fault Madden NFL 09 All-Play's attempt to bring the franchise to the masses. It's accessible, the controls work very well, and it still presents a deep and enduring challenge for the long term fan. It's a solid, competent, professional product that is unlikely to disappoint anyone, whether they're a face-painted fanatic or just looking take a step up from Wii Sports.
