I think people need to stop saying "2009 will be the year for ___." As of this minute we have no idea what games are coming out this year besides the few that have actually been announced. Microsoft has stated that they have quite a few games this year that have not been announced yet, and I am sure Sony does too.
As for Nintendo, I say they don't win any year, well the Nintendo gamers at least. My reasoning? Any system that the combined score of the games is 6.0 has problems. Sure there is one in damn near every home, but who honestly plays it more than for parties?
You don't have to agree with me, but at least look at this from a non fanboy perspective. We wont know who "wins" this year until it is over.
View