I personally like the first 6 better than the newer ones. That's not to say the newer ones aren't good, but I really do think that the older ones have prime RPG elements that the newer ones cannot match. The newer games' stories have gotten too long and there are many unnecissary scenes, while the first 6 (5 and 6 especially) have great stories while getting straight to the point at the game time. And the first 6's job system just doesn't seem to work in the new games when they are attempted.
So I'd say my top 3 favorites are, in order, 3/5 (can't chose), 8 and 6.
View