I don't think you can call someone a fanboy if they believe the story of their entire game isn't all that great. Not saying they are not dedicated, but perhaps they are more dedicated to the social aspect?
Those of us who enjoy the story will, no doubt, buy this novel. This really comes down to a numbers game here. You believe that not even ten percent of the game population will buy this book. I believe that at least ten percent will (in some form or another).
Time will tell who is correct.
View