Thank everyone for your time and interest.
Hello there everyone, Horza Gobuchul here.
Thank you to Kalistyles for reading my blog and posting this news, I don't know you and thank you for posting my article, it is much appreciated.
I know that blogs are not news, and this probably should be a comment in a related news article, i have done this before with other posts from my blog. It is here now though.
Firstly I just want to say that I am a 37 year old nurse from the UK who has been playing games all my adult life. My opinion is neither better or more important than anyone else here. I chose to write that piece on my blog because I enjoy writing and enjoy games, when I have an opinion on something I like to express it.
Can I answer some of the comments?
To King Xtreme 81 I don't really think that everyone wants full in game XMB, what I fear is that Sony thinks we do because we keep asking for what we want in that way. The point of the article really was to illustrate that the 360 doesn't have in game dashboard, yet saying i want in game xmb without clear specification of what you want is like saying to microsoft I want in game dashboard. What you say about the pop up on the ps button is exactly my point in the article. That is what the 360 does with it's minidash. I understand what you say about abbreviating, my point is maybe that can be harmful, maybe we need to waste an entire paragraph being specific?
To Lil titan
I think Sony does know what it is doing, maybe they are confused as to exactly what we want however.
lil Bush illustrates my point here in his comment, he says "in game xmb, it would just helping the online service". If i was at sony reading this, and I am sure they probably have someone read forums to see what user mood is. Then I would be confused as to what you actually want here, do you want to play a video from your hard drive or browse with the web browser while playing a game? I don't think that is what you mean here lil bush.
EZCheez
I have seen this GAP poll mentioned before, and it seemed to be referring to exactly what I am talking about, so yes Sony does seem to be aware and are asking what features we would like implemented, what were the other options on the poll list if you can remember?
To Deep
Yes I have read that article a while back, and it was partly the comments on n4g after that article that prompted me to write on my blog. Some people, a large majority dissed that article and the comments were full of "we need in game xmb now".
To THX7168
Thanks for your assessment of my article, please see this comment thread for a few people who are asking for in game xmb and also the confusion surrounding people asking for in game music, in game chat and some want in game web browsing. What do we want, If I am confused about our needs as ps3 gamers then maybe Sony is too.
Mr Potato wants to see how his downloads are doing, I agree, but do we need that feature in game? Maybe, maybe not, just another confusing spanner in this issues works.
Hellbringer
My point may be obscured by my waffle, but i think the point is we don't need all the features of the xmb in game, only a few specific ones. it's just that everyone has differing priorities as to what is needed and that like the xbox does with it's minidash we don't need sony to waste time and resources giving us every feature of the xmb in game, it's just possible that they might be confused as to what we actually want. I personally don't want them to use up ram with things like the web browser, do you?
mccomber
The article isn't directed at sony it's too the community, i am suggesting we ask for specifics rather than just say "i want in game xmb", really that is all. I don't believe that people really want the whole xmb, but when you think about it isn't that what you are asking for when you say I want in game xmb? Should we be careful what we wish for? (and sorry i didn't mean to imply that you personally said you wanted in game xmb).
Xplosneer
I just wanted that out there as well, the xbox 360 has features like cross game voice chat and and in game soundtracks, through the use of it's small footprint minidash, does anyone know what microsoft actually call what i have termed the minidash? It doesn't have in game xmb or dashboard, why should the ps3?
Some people have also commented that in the article there was an error regarding the achievements list. You got me, yes on the 360 you can see the achievement list for a game in game, what threw me when writing the article was that you can't do that from the minidash. You have to press the guide button when an achievement notification pops up to access the list in game. Well spotted and I was wrong. An interesting point for a future update. Maybe the option to browse achievements for the current game should be present on the minidash, maybe it is, and I just haven't spotted it.
View