User Review
 
Uncharted : Drake's Fortune PS3
toughNAME - contributor
  154 days 9 hours ago | View Game Profile
“OWWW! I did NOT see that coming!”
After months of Uncharted bombardment via the same annoying commercial on TV, I figured I’d give this game a shot, at the expense of anyone’s but my own.

The first thing you notice when you pop this game in are the beautiful graphics. Awesome cinematics, impressive in-game graphics, and realistic looking environments make this game one of the best looking games out there. Also it’s worth mentioning that the water effects in Uncharted are clearly the best across all consoles. The characters also look very good and the voice acting is done impeccably.

The sound in Uncharted Drake's Fortune is definitely is one of its weakness’. The actual soundtrack the game is decent enough for your run of the mill action/adventure game, but the some of the sound effect are a real let down. I have never heard a machine gun or a shotgun fired in real life, but I imagine they don’t have the high pitched, peeping sounds like they do in Uncharted. Compared to other shooting games of the day, this one sounds very, dare I say, ‘last gen’.

And since we’re on the topic of last gen, lets move on to gameplay. If you didn’t grow tired of treasure hunting in the ‘80’s, or after National Treasure, you’re sure to after playing through this game. And if the obvious similarities weren’t prevalent enough, the gameplay is eerily similar to games such as Tomb Raider, and Gears of War. The cover system used in Uncharted seems to be a carbon copy of that in the commercially successful Gears of War. While the puzzles and direct gameplay are very alike of that in Tomb Raider.

The visuals of this game are indeed beautiful, but they are hampered by the extreme lack of openness, and very linear style of play.

The story for Uncharted Drakes Fortune I’m sure was very captivating to the younger ones, but for me, is was too much of the same old. There really isn’t much to say here, but you will find similarities to all above mentioned forms of media when it comes to the storyline. From tropical Nazi’s to island-paradise zombie like creatures, for me it seemed like the old rehashed things all over again.

If you have read any of my other reviews - which can only be summed up in one word: super-tough - then you knew this part was coming.

The longevity of this game is perhaps its greatest weakness. Over the course of 3 months, I completed this game in an estimated time of 11 or 12 hours. I will never touch it again.

Uncharted Drakes Fortune is a singleplayer only game. It seems with so much else on their plate, Naughty Dog decided on only releasing their game half finished. Uncharted brought the end of 2007 and strong hope of complete games for 2008. I do not know when, but one day developers will break the lazy habit of singleplayer only games and give us games the complete experience.

And with no achievements comes, ‘treasures’. Treasures are placed throughout the game as a sort of Easter egg in hopes of prolonging the game. They’re an added plus, but not enough to risk the late fee.
Rating Comments
9.0 Graphics
6.0 Sound
7.0 Gameplay
7.0 Fun Factor
- Online
7.0
Overall
(out of 10 / not an average)
 


Comments (43)
 
| Info | Report
 
Comments(43)
Comment Settings
Showing: 1 - 43 of 43 Comments
Shut this user up Let user speak
PS360WII - 154 days 9 hours ago
1 -
Nice write up. The presentation is top notch for sure. I'm not to sure why everyone says Gears created cover and shoot. I remember being able to take cover and shoot in Bond: From Russia With Love on the GameCube. It is linear but I thought the length of the game was pretty solid for an action adventure game. I don't mind playing again but that's just me ;)
Shut this user up Let user speak
toughNAME - 154 days 9 hours ago
1.1 -
Thanks above and below. It's nice to see mature comments, because I'm sure it won't be long before some individuals come along and try to stifle my opinion.

And I could be wrong, but I don't think I said Gears created cover and shoot.

I just find it odd that Uncharted is very similar to one of the most successful games on 360.

lol and I'm not even a huge fan of the Gears cover system. You know how many times I've got my head blown off because instead of running away, I get pressed against a wall, pactically giving the sniper my life?
Shut this user up Let user speak
sonarus - 154 days 7 hours ago
1.2 -
Since its all opinions here is mine. I think you were a little overly critical. I actually quite enjoyed the score in uncharted i havnt played it in a while so i dnt remember how the guns sound but considering its not intended to be a hard core shooter i can understand why there wouldnt be that much focus on it. You are the first i have heard complain about the sound.
Gears was a great game and outright the best thing about gears was the cover system made the game a lot more realistic. Since the dawn of humanity when someone does something really well you copy it and tweak it to your tastes so i do not find it odd that the cover system is copied cus everything will eventually get copied sooner or later. As long as its successful someone will try to emulate so its not odd to me at all. The fact that ps3 copied an xbox game shouldnt be odd either cus they are all game developers and they arent enemies and they all learn something from each other. Depending on how much the story and the gameplay engaged you will determine how much you enjoyed the game.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Blankman - 154 days 7 hours ago
1.3 -
i noticed you have your xbox360 gamertag on n4g why don't you add the one for your ps3 or do you not have one. Are you ashamed of your ps3 don't want the X360 fan nation to see you with a PS3. I don't believe you have even played this game. You essentially took the little bad parts about the game blew it out of proportion and tossed a 7 in there. You admit the graphics are the best to date but yet you give it a 9. Sure if you reviewed halo you would give it a 9 or probably even a 10.
Shut this user up Let user speak
uxo22 - 153 days 14 hours ago
1.4 - @blankman
So, what did this guy eat for dinner last night, you seem to know everthing else about him. I don't see why you are so torn apart over this guys opinion. Also, if he was ashamed of owning a PS3 I doubt he would have posted a review on a PS3 game. Not everyone thinks like you do.
Shut this user up Let user speak
i Shank u - 154 days 9 hours ago
2 -
word. i like your superTough reviews man, keep it goin.

ps360wii - yea man i remember that game too, best Bond game of last gen imo. there was also one Killswitch i think it was, it featured cover heavily and if anything, Gears took ideas from killswitch. I guess huge marketing campaigns really can make people believe something.
Shut this user up Let user speak
ER1X - 154 days 9 hours ago
3 -
Try it on crushing mode...you won't beat it in 12 hours w/o a walkthrough.
Shut this user up Let user speak
paul_war - 144 days 18 hours ago
3.1 -
Did it on crushing in 8 hours. Though that was my 3rd paly through.
4 Da360sucks | 154 days 9 hours ago - User only got 1 bubble - Show
Shut this user up Let user speak
chester - 154 days 9 hours ago
5 -
agree with your review. the game is absolutely gorgeous, no doubt about it. personally, i just didn't find it all that fun. i did enjoy the platforming portions, but then felt like the gun fights just held things up. it's a good game, but beyond the visuals i didn't think it was all that memorable.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Stagerman - 154 days 7 hours ago
6 -
i don't mean any disrespect but in all the posts you have written, you seem like you own an xbox exclusivley, and i could write a similiar review of gears of war, because i didnt enjoy it all that much either, but the truth is, everything is opinion. i have full surround sound and uncharted did not sound like a 6, more like an 8, the gameplay wasnt a rehash of tombraider meets gears. so this sounds pretty biased to me.
Shut this user up Let user speak
toughNAME - 154 days 7 hours ago
6.1 -
I do not own this game and I do not own a PS3

I think after all this time on the site I've made my Games-first, Purchase second, philosophy pretty clear

This was one of the first reviews I've wanted to write and I have been adding bits and pieces to it over the last few weeks. It took this long to review the game because I wanted to wait until I played the entire thing through before I gave my opinion on it.

And this is a User Review, of course there's a personal bias.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Big Jim - 154 days 6 hours ago
7 - .
I'm glad someone finally mentioned how terrible the sound effects are in Uncharted. They really are bad. I also agree that Uncharted has very little replay value. The problem I had with your review, toughname, is that you make countless grammer and spelling errors. You might want to think about an english class.
Shut this user up Let user speak
toughNAME - 154 days 6 hours ago
7.1 -
You mind pointing out where these mistakes are?

I'm sure there are a couple missing letters here and there, and I use comma's waaaay too much but thats just me./ And some sentences Word didn't like, but word also tells me colour is spelt color...so yeah.

I proof rread it a couple of times. I'm sure there are some small mistakes, but I think it's readable. I also like to write MY way so that my reviews seem personalized, there's no spell check on N4G so I really don't think it matters.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Big Jim - 154 days 6 hours ago
8 - .
That comment of mine was rude. Never mind. I apologize.
9 Da360sucks | 154 days 5 hours ago - User only got 1 bubble - Show
Shut this user up Let user speak
ag101 - 154 days 5 hours ago
10 -
i agree with most parts of your review but i think the sound is much more better than you said it's a great game but it definitaly lacks replay value n the zombie part of the story really messed my appreciation on the game but i still think u could have given it a higer score arounf 8. somethin
Shut this user up Let user speak
DrPirate - 154 days 4 hours ago
11 -
Good review, I'd give the sound an 8 because I thought the music and the voice acting were top quality. I agree with you about the guns, I didn't like the way they sounded either.

I'm not trying to tell you what to write of course, it felt like it was left out since the voice acting is pretty unique in how natural it sounds.

To each their own opinion.
Shut this user up Let user speak
FirstknighT - 154 days 2 hours ago
12 -
My cousin has a ps3 and we switch consoles every so often to play other games. So far I have played and beaten Resistance, Motorstorm, Warhawk, and Uncharted. Your review is spot on. Great graphics but everything else is been there done that. Basic gameplay and basic story. I was dissapointed at the last level when the monsters showed up.

I'm sure the Sony fanboys are going to give you some crap but I think this review was fair.
Shut this user up Let user speak
PopEmUp - 153 days 23 hours ago
12.1 - I bet You can't beat warhawk
In a million year cause you always got cream especially on Air
Shut this user up Let user speak
Anego Montoya FTMFW - 153 days 20 hours ago
12.2 - Liar
you can beat WARHAWK, it`s ONLINE only.
Shut this user up Let user speak
BlazeXXL - 153 days 20 hours ago
12.3 - jebus
did u ever heard of giving credit where credit is due? I mean comon, this review was way too harsh. This is definatly a quality title that deserves at least an 8.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Fr0ZzZeN - 153 days 23 hours ago
13 - Decent review
Good review, I agree with the most of it as I didnt think it was a fantastic game. It was good, no doubt about it but not great. On the sound, spot on. I have also seen that no-one has noticed that the M16/AK have the exact same firing and reloading sounds. Sure, they may sound similar but its just laziness on the dev's part.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Anego Montoya FTMFW - 153 days 20 hours ago
14 - Tough Name
it`s fine if that`s your opinion.

but in my opinion that`s just wrong.
Shut this user up Let user speak
fenderputty - 153 days 18 hours ago
14.1 - Ditto
The sound in the game is amazing. My surround sound system has bullets whizzing at me from all corners and as the camera angle swings around, so do the origon of the bullets. The track that plays is perfect for the environment. The animations were top notch. The gameplay takes one of the cooler aspects of a great game (gears) and adds to it some platforming. Simply because its a mix of done before styles doesn't make this a poor gameplay experience. Playing the game in difficult makes the title last much longer. The story line and cinimatics blended well and kept me interested the whole time. It's only real lacking is that it doesn't have online and as such lacks some replayability. I've still beat the game twice though.

Quote:"And this is a User Review, of course there's a personal bias. "

The reviewer has already admitted to Bias and as such might as well have thrown away all his work on this review. A review is suppoed to come from a stanpoint that lacks bias. If that isn't a dead giveaway of why the final score is a 7, then the fact that Firstknight agrees with him should also be a dead giveaway. I don't even understand the point of the review if it's know that the source if Biased. This is like the Sony Defence Force reviewing ME and saying it's garabge at best.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Daver - 153 days 19 hours ago
15 -
You only like your 360 so why bother reviewing a ps3 game?
The sound was good, the ambiance in his whole was perfect
The longevity of the game was standard like every other games, its around 10-12 hours
Please dont tell me about the originality of the game... Most of the games on Xbox are the same... so thats not a good point for you
and finally... why a game would need multiplayer for the "full experience" personnaly i dont care of multiplayer i can live wihtout it for most games... i prefer by far a good singleplayer
oh and btw it dosnt meant to be a sandbox so yes its linear... like every games who is not a sandbox

You could have kept your review for yourself...
Shut this user up Let user speak
toughNAME - 153 days 18 hours ago
15.1 - Wrong. I only like games.
Your comment is ripping into my User Review with your personal opinion?

You can have an opinion but I can't?

Maybe you should keep your comments to yourself.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Daver - 153 days 18 hours ago
15.2 -
You can have your opinion as everyone here... but thats not an opinion... you start with "annoying commercial" so we all know from the start that it wont be objective.. you review a game you dont even own on a system you dont even own as well...
I dont know really what was the goal of your "review" but it was certainly not to say positve things as you are an "Xbot" and its alright i dont mind.. its just if you dont want to enjoy all games and give what is due.. then stay on your side
Shut this user up Let user speak
timmyp53 - 153 days 18 hours ago
16 - hmm.
Don't see why the game deserves that low of a score even after reading your review of a game you don't own on a system you don't own.
Shut this user up Let user speak
PS360WII - 153 days 18 hours ago
17 -
It doesn't matter that he doesn't have a PS3 or owns a copy of Uncharted. What matters is he played and beat Uncharted and wrote a review about it that you guys didn't. So what if the score is still above average but not your holy grail of 10. This game is good but standard and he makes good points on it. Besides the great graphics and CS it's your standard game which is what he is pointing out. Stop you silly banter on a fun game that got a critical review like all games do. I don't see you yelling at Rowland about his 6 on Bioshock.
Shut this user up Let user speak
fenderputty - 153 days 18 hours ago
17.1 - Actually I thought
his review of Bioshock was absolute trash as well. A review is supposed to come from a source that is as unbiased as they can be. He's already admitted personal bias and preference for one thing over an other, making anything he says worth squatt. Tell me how this is any different then a Sony Defence Force guy reviewing a 360 game.
Shut this user up Let user speak
PS360WII - 153 days 18 hours ago
17.2 -
well most likely that the Sony Denfense Force didn't play the game they reviewed...?

Even top notch reviewers have biased opinions. It's part of the review and view point. It's like giving fans of FF a job to review Lost Odyssey (which they did) and then saying this is a standard RPG that brings nothing to the table like a FF game. Bias is and will always be part of reviews in here or in well know gaming sites/mags
Shut this user up Let user speak
toughNAME - 153 days 18 hours ago
18 -
Everyone has a bias, whether they admit it or not it's always there.

I review a game because of the quality of the game, not because of what console it's on.

I love the comments, and I strongly urge those who have different opinions to write their own reviews. Just don't tell me I don't deserve to write a review.

And thanks PS360WII I appreciate it. I wrote the review knowing there would be a strong response, but in the end it comes down to this being a User Review and a personal opinion, if anyone doesn't like it theres nothing stopping you to write your own

I'm out of bubbles, but I appreciate all the comments and I apologize to some I couldn't reply to. Keep the comments coming just don't expect a reply :(
Shut this user up Let user speak
DeZimatoR - 153 days 16 hours ago
19 - I checked his other reviews...
...and he gave Call of Duty 4 a 6/10.

I think I really don't care anymore about his opinion.

Haha

Even funnier is the fact that he gave 9 to Halo 3's graphics, the same score he awarded to Uncharted's graphics. LMAO!

As to the review itself. The sound is weak?! That's a new one for me...I would advise you to get a surround sound system and then reappreciate the score you awarded to the sound. 6? Gimme a break.

So its a knockoff of Gears of War? Then GeoW is a clone of Killsitch (PS2). The cover system I mean. Its funny you say Uncharted is just a mesh of a couple of games...I guess all FPS's after Wolfenstein 3D are just knock offs of that game, right?

And the story is perfectly fine.

The only thing I agree with you on is the length of the game. But you said it took you 11/12hrs to complete? It took a bit less then 8h on Normal and I'm 50% through on Hard and I've not even hit the 3hrs mark.

BTW, you said you played it during 3 months? Did you even remember the first stages of the game when you actually finished it?

BTW, wtf is up with you wanting multiplayer is every damn game? You know, not all games are supposed to have an online component...I guess if ND had just strapped in a cheap online mode you would be happy? Sad...

Oh, and there's not only 'treasures' to discover. You actually get awarded points for getting 100 headshots, 50 kills with a particular gun, killing 50 enemies without dying, etc., and that unlocks things as extra characters for you to play with, concept art, etc.

So what if you don't get a little thing popping up saying Achievement? You get a little thing popping up saying 50 kills with AK-47. Whats the difference? That you can't show it off to your friends? lol...

Anywyas, I wouldn't expect a different review from you when judging a PS3 exclusive.
Shut this user up Let user speak
CRIMS0N_W0LF - 153 days 15 hours ago
19.1 -
you said it.

a lot of people said it.

everyone knows he is biased
Shut this user up Let user speak
mintaro - 153 days 15 hours ago
20 -
i have to agree with his review, although id give it maybe a 7.9

while the graphics are top notch, the game brings things that we have already seen, and for those of you who say we've never seen graphics like tha