600°

LittleBigPlanet getting moderated without warning: So much for creative freedom

If you're a big fan of user levels in LittleBigPlanet, the advice of the day seems to be this -- don't get too attached to them. Reports have been coming in of levels being "moderated" without warning. That's a polite way of saying they're getting deleted, and users are not being given the courtesy of an explanation.
Alternative Sources:
LittleBigPlanet creativity ... - dailyjoystick.com | By: Scotracer
Little Big Planet: Play. Cr... - digitalsomething.com | By: madk
Omega4 - contributor
Published: 424 days 8 hours ago | News | PlayStation 3
 
 

12Next »
Showing: 1 - 50 of 85 Comments
Shut this user up Let user speak
PirateThom - 424 days 9 hours ago
1 -
Funny, because I just played both Sonic and MGS levels.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Fishy Fingers - 424 days 8 hours ago
1.1 -
Yep, I've got loads of hearted levels based on other IPs and they're still here, and these are levels I found in the beta.
Shut this user up Let user speak
vhero - 424 days 8 hours ago
1.2 -
some levels like levels with genitals etc need moderating and I agree they bloody well should be my kids play this game there should be minimum moderation as for making a level dedicated to another game there really is no law against that as you are creating stuff yourself from scratch. You are not actually taking anything from the IP and porting over so its allowed e.g. music which is why picture upload is disabled right now...
Shut this user up Let user speak
ChampIDC - 424 days 7 hours ago
1.3 -
I don't get it. To me, this is on the same lines as amateurly remixing a game's music.. As long as you're not making a profit off of it, there's really no big deal. I really don't see where the copyright issues come into play in creating levels.

Nobody is making a profit off of these levels yet. As they said, maybe good user levels will be eligible for profit sometime down the line, but they could easily just make the levels with copyright material ineligible for that program.

This is pretty epic fail IMO. It's a shame creative freedom is being hindered by this crap.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Robondacob - 424 days 7 hours ago
1.4 -
There's an explanation why.

It's the Grief Report. Some random jack@ss just goes around and reports anything vaguely illegal in LBP. They see a great copyright infringed level? They report it for just that. The mods have to do something because someone complained about it, allowing the possibility of a lawsuit by some angry soccer mom who is mad that her children are playing "bad" things.
Shut this user up Let user speak
v1c1ous - 424 days 6 hours ago
1.5 - HOW DARE THEY!
remove my phallic playground!
Shut this user up Let user speak
Johnny Rotten - 424 days 6 hours ago
1.6 -
I just did a search for God of War levels and found like 20 of them.
1.7 vickers500 | 424 days 5 hours ago - User only got 1 bubble - Show
Shut this user up Let user speak
Rapture333 - 423 days 23 hours ago
1.8 - Same with mine....
I know a fair share of people including myself who have had their levels moderated for no reason, no offensive materials of any kind and no mention of any Copyrighted-Material WHATSOEVER. It seems completely ridiculous that we are getting our levels deleted for no reason with no warning even after I checked the EULA I couldn't find anything that I have broken.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Cliff_BleSHITski - 423 days 21 hours ago
1.9 -
It's not like if I make a cool Mirrors Edge level that EA/Dice are gonna lose sales! If anything it will help promote the game and get the name out there.

No one's going "Hey I don't need Mirrors Edge, I got Mirrors Edge right here for free so why pay $60!"
Shut this user up Let user speak
plain rice - 423 days 12 hours ago
1.10 -
Vickers you're right and wrong. Picture upload was already implemented but it was cut from the final game. Although, the feature will be come soon.
Shut this user up Let user speak
SL1M DADDY - 423 days 12 hours ago
1.11 - Sorry but to the author of this article...
If you feel that expressions of creative freedom include people posting up levels of penises and vaginas on the LBP level servers then sorry sir, you are mistaken. Even levels that have copyrighted materials need to be taken down so if you love that penis level so much, download it and play it on your own time before it gets taken down. Keep the pervert crap off my LBP.
Shut this user up Let user speak
SonyOwnsNextYear - 423 days 10 hours ago
1.12 -
i really think is the xbox fans that make the profane and sexually explicit levels.

viral campaigning, much like the metacritic crap and the fanboys at gamestops.....its all hate and whining on their behalf.

I remember when lbp came out and they went on a rampage on how a nonviolent game cant be good.....then banjotooie comes out and thats a AAA title. LOL.

seriously when it was nintendo/sega/sony in competition, none of this immature bullsh1t happened. Introduce a whole bunch of "console shooter" fans, and herein lies our problem.

to make it perfectly clear, there are douchebags online everywhere, but never have i seen such a concentrated form of immaturity as that which can be found within the above criteria.

to those in denial, think of this: shooters were the selling point on the 360. guns, guns, guns, guns, guns, kill,kill, kill, kill,kill.
Shut this user up Let user speak
kevnb - 423 days 9 hours ago
1.13 - @ SonyOwnsNextYear
what are you talking about? Xbox fans are making levels on a ps3? What does this even have to do with the article?
Shut this user up Let user speak
HowarthsNJ - 424 days 9 hours ago
2 - The LBP community will learn about Copyrights, Trademarks and IP's soon enough
I've been a member of several digital art communities over the last 15 years or so and have been through this process many times.

It's funny how the same lame arguments come up every single time (See Open Zone for an example).

Learn and get over it.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Raz - 424 days 1 hour ago
2.1 - I'll Google your Yahoo if Youtube Myspace...
Same deal anywhere else. It's called moderation, not censorship. I fully expected it - we were certainly warned about it. It's part of the tutorial when they explain about what's acceptable. At no point was there any indication that you had completely free reign to do as you pleased...there were and are limits. If offenders still remain it's because there's a huge backlog of submissions, and it takes time to deal with them. Use the grief button if you've an issue.

Just keep your fan-levels on your Moon and submit the ones that don't violate international copyright laws. Have fun and quit whining.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Sarick - 423 days 20 hours ago
2.2 - Trade marks and copyrights?
I can understand trademarks but copyrights are for content that are copied from the original. There is no code being copied the levels aren't being replicas. If I design movie about space that has laser swords in it I'm not stealing Star Wars copyrights.

It's simple if the content being produced is 100% user generated not using original content it's not stealing someones work. If I drew an image to look like an PS3 or picture of Ronald McDonald as long as that image was my original artwork, not a modified original from copyrighted content there is no patent on that image.

As for themed content, If the level design isn't a copycat of existing levels then I don't see it as infringing.

I Think MM just decided to avoid legal issues to just delete anything and everything so no disputes could be taken to court. This way instead of a big companies filing lawsuits MM would remove content entirely avoiding the problem. It's not that the content is truly illegal it's just an easy solution avoid any cases being brought up.
Shut this user up Let user speak
HowarthsNJ - 422 days 23 hours ago
2.3 - @Sarick
I can tell you've never had to deal with any of these concepts much.

Copyright is what you have over your own work; for example, a drawing.

If someone takes your drawing and stickers it all over their LBP level without your permission it's a violation of that copyright.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Coke-a-Cola - 424 days 8 hours ago
3 - The Sky is the LIMIT .............BE ORIGINAL .
It is really so difficult not to use a PS3 , or an Ipod or Mario in Your Level .

MEDIA MOLECULE .......... did not create this game by copying Mario .......
One is free to create ......... Strength is in originally.
Shut this user up Let user speak
perils - 424 days ago
3.1 -
haha you gotta love the irony! this comin from a guy called "coke-a-cola"....... unless you meant it to be ironic, in that case well done on the irony. but yeah i agree......even tho i cant really stop thinkin about how i can create some of my fave games, tv shows etc....sorry i cant help it! but im trying to be original in the way i go about creating stuff......honest i am!
Shut this user up Let user speak
Wiimaniac - 424 days 8 hours ago
4 -
okay, this is bad. 0_0
Shut this user up Let user speak
cyclindk - 424 days 8 hours ago
5 -
All I have to say is...you can create whatever you want, but don't publish something you think might be deemed offensive. It's just common sense.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Mr Fancy Pants - 424 days 7 hours ago
5.1 -
but they are not simply removing what is inappropriate they are removing everything that has even the most subtle detail about anything related to something commercial. example: they are removing the mario levels, the MGS levels and even levels that have something related to the playstation brand! this is plain ridiculous.

you didn't read the article right?
Shut this user up Let user speak
DaTruth - 423 days 22 hours ago
5.2 -
I just played the Mirror's Edge level and it's called "Mirror's Edge level".
Shut this user up Let user speak
Vip3r - 424 days 8 hours ago
6 -
Good. I hope LBP keeps its high level of moderation. It'd be a shame if this was ruined by sick and perverted levels.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Mr Fancy Pants - 424 days 7 hours ago
6.1 -
you should read the article...
Shut this user up Let user speak
Vip3r - 424 days 6 hours ago
6.2 - @6.1
I did. What's your point?
Shut this user up Let user speak
FantasyStar - 424 days 6 hours ago
6.3 - Did you really read(comprehend) the article?
The point is that the scope of the "high level of moderation" also affects games on Sony's own platform. What's the point of buying LBP if you can't recreate your favorite things like MGS, GoW, Fable, Mirror's Edge, R2 and other stuff? It's practically cutting half of the reasons to buy LBP. Sure people can be original, but I know I would've loved to remake MGS4 for LBP however I don't want my work to be deleted just because some hornball's gonna pop a vein. Then you have the addition of idiots who report blatantly without giving much of a reason. Spamming the report system is clearly a flaw in LBP that must be addressed.

For starters, for users that abuse their reporting powers will have their privileges completely revoked.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Vip3r - 422 days 6 hours ago
6.4 -
Again, I did read the article. I just voiced my opinion anyway.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Sangria - 424 days 8 hours ago
7 -
It's the beginning of LittleBigPlanet, i guess moderators and players will slowly learn what can be permitted and what cannot.
Shut this user up Let user speak
PimpHandHappy - 424 days 8 hours ago
8 - its good
if they are deleting pen!s levels and levels that are offensive

always remember

free speech is free

but when you start to ensite hate and violence you can be put in jail
Shut this user up Let user speak
Nikkelz - 424 days 8 hours ago
9 - damn
i think thats a lil disappointing because some of the videos i seen that were really cool looking were based off of an i.p,
does anyone remember the shadow of colossus stage?
or the super mario brother's one?
too bad too....im still gonna buy it but just not before the other games i have on my list
Shut this user up Let user speak
darkride66 - 424 days 7 hours ago
10 - Why is this news?
Did anyone have any doubt that Sony would start deleting levels that infringed on copyright? How else are they supposed to stop from getting themselves, or their users for that matter, sued?
Shut this user up Let user speak
lunaticpanda101 - 424 days 7 hours ago
11 - i wish
they would sort out the flippin lag
Shut this user up Let user speak
DrWan - 424 days 7 hours ago
12 - This title of the article is stupid.
Creative Freedom is something u came up with yourself, not by copying Mario. So just make your own level.
Shut this user up Let user speak
devilhunterx - 424 days 7 hours ago
13 -
Freedom Of Speech(tm) doesnt give you Freedom From Responsibility(tm)
Shut this user up Let user speak
ocalot2k5 - 424 days 7 hours ago
14 - So destructionoid didn't get enough att. by giving lbp 85?
Hmm....
Even youtube has copyright infringment
Shut this user up Let user speak
ocalot2k5 - 424 days 7 hours ago
15 - ohh
and an 80 to mgs4 and resistance 2 and everyother ps3 exclusive
Shut this user up Let user speak
Blitzed - 424 days 7 hours ago
16 - Looks to see who submitted...
Is it Bloodmask or Omeg..its Omega4...figures.
Shut this user up Let user speak
strotee - 424 days 6 hours ago
16.1 -
Stay on N4G long enough and you'll recognize who submits what and from where before clicking on Info. Sad huh?
Shut this user up Let user speak
Captain Tuttle - 424 days 6 hours ago
16.2 -
Is the news any less legitimate because of who submitted it?
Shut this user up Let user speak
divideby0 - 424 days 7 hours ago
17 -
Good..happy to hear...
They have to set the bar now, so content will be developed with this in mind.
The user just have to use common sense in their creations and it wont be a problem
Shut this user up Let user speak
OuterHaven - 424 days 7 hours ago
18 - -
Kotaku just posted this, and they are getting a kick out of it. Everyone, even if they dont own a PS3 says the game sucks now and how Sony sucks.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Scotracer - 424 days 7 hours ago
19 -
Booooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ooooooooooooooooo

:(
Shut this user up Let user speak
darkpower - 424 days 6 hours ago
20 -
There could actually be TWO possibilities to this whole thing:

1. What Destructoid said, which is very possible, and sad to see happen.
2. Some person (or group of people) are flagging these levels and MM isn't even checking into the actual reasons for it before pulling the trigger. This is similar to what was going on on YouTube for the same thing: Someone flagged a video for copyrights or whatever, and YT didn't even TRY to investigate and took whoever was flagging it as the truth and just pulling the video based on heresay alone.

Either way, people should be notified as to what is going on here, but I'm wondering if it's MM's decision based on their morals and fears, or just a bunch of people who have an ax to grind and flagging all of these to moderate all of these levels.

By the way, I've seen many levels that COULD be modded for this reason stay on for all this time without any incident. This makes me think this is more of the second thing happening.

@TheExodus: There is also fair use and how much of a fine line there is between what you can and can't do with that kind of content. You CAN make a spoof or a parody of a part of something that is copyrighted without getting permission (even though there is that moral high-ground that you SHOULD ask, by law, you don't HAVE to. Weird Al could never have any permission to do any of his parodies and still not break any laws at all under the fair-use doctrine). This could be akin to THAT, which makes the copyright thing a non-issue to begin with.
Shut this user up Let user speak
PureGamer - 424 days 6 hours ago
21 -
mine got deleted without warning it was titled my frist level and was just a mess about.
Shut this user up Let user speak
TheExodus - 424 days 6 hours ago
22 -
It's LittleBigPlanet! User created content should be rated E for EVERYONE & copyright infringement isn't flattery it's ILLEGAL! Don't really understand why we're even discussing the complaints of handful of thieves & pervs.
Shut this user up Let user speak
thor - 424 days 5 hours ago
22.1 -
http://en.wikipedia.org/wik...

Actually I think simply theming a level around something qualifies as fair use. The issue may be that the levels are available globally, however, if the copyright is a US one for example then I think it falls under US law and thus constitutes fair use.

The amount of content in a themed level is often minimal, with only a picture or an attempt at recreation of something. Furthermore, the effect the level in question will have is very small for most levels which will not be played my many people. Also, the level itself is transformative, rather than derivative as described in the Wikipedia article.

It's possible something could be taken to court, and MM don't want to risk this. But I severlely doubt anything would become of it and they are playing it too safe.
Shut this user up Let user speak
NipGrip - 424 days 6 hours ago
23 - Ooohhh SONY YOU SUCK!!
Or do they? Seems Activision is doing the same with Guitar Hero World Tour:
http://multiplayerblog.mtv....

But no, it's too much fun to blame Sony now isn't it? Kids not understanding copyright infringement is all there is complaining. Anyone with half a brain fully understands why this stuff isn't allowed and you shouldn't even waste your time making it unless you don't mind it being deleted at any given time.

If I wasted my time recording an episode of some TV show and uploaded it to YouTube, they would delete it despite my time spent and without warning. Welcome to real life!
Shut this user up Let user speak
etownone - 424 days 6 hours ago
24 -
does that mean that cool azz Batman level I saw the other day is going to be removed also?
Add Comment (Gamer Zone)
Gamer Zone Posting Guidelines
The Gamer Zone is for members who want a more friendly and civilized discussion. This section is heavily moderated by the N4G staff, so leave your fanboyism at the door please. Members who are unable to behave in a mature and respectful manner will be temporarily or permanently restricted from posting in the Gamer Zone. Using words such as Xbots and Sony droids, or other words from the console war vocabulary, is strictly prohibited in this Zone.
Read More...
 
 
You must log in to post comments.
Username:  
Password:  
 
 
About N4G
N4G is a social game news site that covers the game industry 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
More Info... | Submit News