RPGFan: Top 10 RPGs of the 6th Generation of Consoles

Homicide - 297 days 9 hours ago

Great list. Even though Persona 4 is better than 3, I understand why they put it there. I would add Nocturne in the top 10 and remove FFXII.

Agree(4) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply

siren - 297 days 7 hours ago

One of the best lists around. Only change I would make is dropping FF XII and putting in Shadow Hearts II instead at roughly the same ranking.

SH2 has redefined what my expectations are regarding characters in a JRPG. The only game to hold a candle to it so far in the current generation in Tales of Vesperia.

Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply

kewlkat007 - 297 days 7 hours ago

Handhelds have had some good ones to...

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Guy169 - 297 days 7 hours ago

Shadow Hearts not being there is a joke. any Xenosaga being in the top is a joke. DDS and no Nocturne is a joke.

Fail.

oh and FFX (let alone XII) being before SO3 is a joke as well.

Agree(2) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply

Lucreto - 297 days 7 hours ago

10. Don't Agree
9. Agree
8. Agree
7. Don't Agree
6. Don't agree
5. Agree
4. Agree
3. Agree
2. Agree
1. Don't Agree

Where is Grandia 2? Where is Suikoden 5? Where is Dark Cloud 1 and 2?

I didn't like xenosaga, Persona games or SO3 and I have been vocal about them and there are better RPG's.

Agree(1) | Disagree(7) | Report | Reply

Figboy - 297 days 6 hours ago

the Playstation 2 absolutely KILLED with the awesome RPGs.

i still have to get many that are on that list.

sadly, i just don't have the time to invest in RPGs at the moment (i'm currently working 6 day weeks, 10 hour days).

ah well, it's a rather great list, although i would have liked to have seen Dark Cloud 2 and Rogue Galaxy on there. Shadow Hearts is missing also, but what can you do?

if anything, the omissions on this list aren't being slighted, it just illustrates to me that last generation absolutely ROCKED for RPGs, while this current generation has been terribly medicore so far (here's hoping that White Knight Chronicles is as fun as the other Level 5 RPGs) on consoles.

the handhelds have been rocking for RPGs however. i wish devs would share some of that love for the consoles though.

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

George Sears - 297 days 6 hours ago

I disagree with Persona 3 being #1. Nocturne is THE best RPG that have ever graced my PS2 and till this day it is my all time favorite RPG. No other RPG compares to it. A pinnacle and marvel of its craft.

Persona is to quirky and the story is pretty lame. I bought 4 and I haven't passed it because of it. The battle system is still on par with Nocturne but you feel more bad@$$ in Nocturne than in Persona. (Even though Dante can be on your team, you are more bad@$$ than him! lol)

Nocturne FTW. If you haven't heard about this RPG and you love RPG's, you are not a true gamer.

EDIT* Funny that i got all those RPG's (except KOTOR)

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Guy169 - 297 days 5 hours ago

and FFXII (and X) and no Valkyrie Profile Silmeria is bs too.

Persona 2 was way better than 3&4, anyone who says Persona 3(or 4) is that good just haven't played previous games. and Nocturne was like 10 times better as well.

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Critical_Hit - 297 days 5 hours ago

Great list. Good to see Xenosaga Episode III getting some recognition.

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Steven Colbert - 297 days 4 hours ago

I'm amazed at how much PS2 owners disagreed on which RPGs were good.Lets face it the PS2 was a kingdom for the JRPG just like the PS1,Genesis,and SNES were during their time.

I would add Dark Cloud 2 on there

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Enate - 297 days 4 hours ago

I'll take Xenogsaga III hands down for me mainly because its feel got the closest yet to Xenogears. My GOTY 4 life

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Tony P - 297 days 4 hours ago

I disagree with mostly everything on this list. No wonder I don't often agree with RPGfan's views. (Be mindful that I'm not calling any of these games 'bad')

The big one is DDS over Lucifer's Call/Nocturne. DDS is a nice game. But Nocturne obliterates it on nearly all fronts. It set a much higher precedent with multiple endings, deeper character customisation, and contained plain more content. DDS is such a limited game when compared to Nocturne; who could ever choose it over a clearly better game?

Anyway, I'd like to avoid the standard wall of text cos they're all pretty good games regardless. If I had one to add it would be Morrowind. Not strictly a console affair, but I first played it on Xbox and it pretty much blew everything else out of the water.

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Kamikaze135 - 297 days 4 hours ago

I find it really hard to consider Persona 3 an RPG. It's more of a dating sim if anything.

Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

shadowfox6 - 297 days 3 hours ago

FF 12 shouldn't be on the list & Shadow Hearts 2 shouldn't be missing, its one of the best RPG's :3

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

kevnb - 297 days 2 hours ago

but persona 3 isnt as good as most those other games, its a good game but random samey dungeons and only so-so gameplay hold it back.

Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Wiimaniac - 297 days 6 hours ago

FFX, Persona3-4, are so overrated and Star Ocean 3 does not even deserve to be on that list... . Where's Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne? That game is like..... mmmmm.... The best of the entire series? Yeah, the best!

Where' Grandia II (best battle system evar!), Suikoden III and Shadow Hearts the Covenant?

-Star Ocean 3 and Digital Devil Saga 2 should be replaced by Nocturne and one of the 3 I just mentioned below.

Agree(1) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply

Wakka_ - 297 days 6 hours ago

This is bullsh!t. FFX deserves the top spot ya?

Agree(1) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply

DNAgent - 297 days 2 hours ago

Not only that but you had to put up with some emo kid that loved to play underwater soccer.

Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply