IGN will refrain from saying that Sinking Island has sunk. That's just too lame, and probably too harsh. Instead, they will look on the bright side, as it can function well as a trainer for someone who wants to learn to interrogate 10 people on the same topics, take fingerprints, and put two and three, four, five, and six together. The frustrating part, as in most adventure games, is that even if you've been a good detective and have read this plot like a book, you still have to slot the evidence exactly how the designers intended, which in this case is definitely not as satisfying as just taking in a good mystery novel.
Presentation - 7.0
Graphics - 5.5
Sound - 7.0
Gameplay - 6.5
Lasting Appeal - 6.5
Overall -
