290°
5.0

IGN: Atelier Rorona: The Alchemist of Arland Review

IGN writes: "I love an inappropriate, flirtatious RPG starring underage girls with huge racks as much as the next guy. Generally, though, I want them to have a solid game to entertain me between the weirdness. NISA's newest RPG, Atelier Rorona: The Alchemist of Arland has all the bouncy physics, red zone comments, and "shy" girls that wear bras for shirts, but is missing that part where the game is compelling and fun."

despair4958d ago (Edited 4958d ago )

one of the worst written reviews I've ever seen, read it and still I only a small idea how the game plays and features. I mean 1 page review from what seems to be a 12 year old idiot.

Oh I have no idea if the game deserves that score or not but this review does not help.

visualb4958d ago (Edited 4958d ago )

"I love an inappropriate, flirtatious RPG starring underage girls with huge racks as much as the next guy."

I agree and stopped reading after that sentence. this is meant to be a professional gaming website, and that one sentence doesn't spell professional. *smh* thought it'd be an interesting review as to WHY its 5/10.

guess must wait for other reviews to be more concise and consistent than this..."reviewer"

Kareshi_X4958d ago

I dont want to be a nutcracker but I'm pretty sure other reviews will match this one. This is from the same guys that did Cross edge , Last rebellion and such games right?

Lovable4958d ago

@Kareshi_X

Far from it. NISA published this game. Gust developed it.

TOO PAWNED4958d ago

actually it is great review. This guy knows whats wrong with JRPGs.As for those stuck in PS1 and PS2 era (like these two above) i hope someday you open your eyes. There is a reason people don't buy JRPGs any more.

Stealth20k4958d ago

^You are an idiot. The games been getting reviewed 8's and 9's everywhere else

Lovable4958d ago

@TOO PAWNED

Yeah because you played it right? Kinda funny that people who REALLY do play it don't agree with the score.

Blaster_Master4958d ago (Edited 4958d ago )

I have to disagree Too Pawned. I think the reason why rpgs dont sell anymore is because devs are turning rpgs into action adventure games with rpg elements. Your right, we are stuck in the NES to Ps2 era for rpgs cause thats when rpgs were actually good. I loved Atelier Iris, if this game is anything like it im sure Im gonna love this just as much. Its a shame that rpgs dont have the magic that they used to have.

Stealth20k4958d ago

RPGS have plenty of magic. They dont sell but they are consistently the highest quality genre still

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 4958d ago
Blaster_Master4958d ago (Edited 4958d ago )

thats funny how i get all these disagrees when sales speak for themselves. Even till this day, old school rpgs on the DS sell more then supposed AAA titles on consoles. Why? Because the market for good old school rpgs is bigger than these action rpgs that run rampant this gen. The proof is in the pudding. Thats why when games like Dragon Warrior come out, whole school systems shut down because people are just so addicted to them. But what do I know? I've just been playing since the Atari days and seen how every genre has evolved, and how true gamers (people who speak with their wallets instead of on comment threads) react to each and every rpg that has ever been out. Rpgs so damn good that they are on multiple platforms and sell even decades later (chrono trigger, FF4, Dragon warrior 4). Yeah, you noobs on here are about as clueless as the publishers that put these garbage action adventure rpg wannabe's out.

B-Real2064957d ago

Amen. I can't for the life of me figure out why we continue to get half assed rpgs this gen.

pwnd_of_lol4957d ago (Edited 4957d ago )

So I've been thinking a lot the past days and being that my mind wandered to JPRG's and why most of them suck in PS3 compared to the glory days of PS2 JPRG's .

So where does sony leave JRPG's in this gen?

During the PS2 days, JRPG's didn't have to worry about gameplay and graphics gameplay...

I would say for people go back a generation and pick up one of the fantastic jRPGs the PS2 has to offer instead of PS3 JRPG's .

Natsu X FairyTail4958d ago (Edited 4958d ago )

NISA is a small japanese group they dont have the same ressources as the bigger guys but they should really start making games with better engines because this really looks like a PS2 game in terms of graphics. In terms of story I understand why the reviwer did not like the game. Some of these JRPGS are filled with Moe, kiddy cute stuff that the japanese find attractive and fun while Most of us find it weird. I'm a big JRPG fan and games like Atelier arent really my CUP of TEA when it comes to selecting games. Atlus on the other hand is a really small group aswell and never pushed any limits in terms of tech but their games always offers a good story , Animation and gameplay like in the persona Titles(currently playing Devil survivor on NDS).

Folklore(PS3) and blue dragon(xbox) which were some of the very 1st next gen rpgs back in 06 still look better than this.

http://ps3media.ign.com/ps3...

http://img.jeuxvideo.fr/003...

Neckbear4958d ago (Edited 4958d ago )

NISA didn't even made this, it was GUST.

Also, for the graphic improvement over the first on the sequel, you should see: http://www.ps3attitude.com/...

That image.

Editan @Kareshi_X

Perhaps. Although I wouldn't say VC looked better. VC lacked AA, wich somewhat killed the Cel-shading.

Demon's Souls was pretty good to look at, but had framerrate drops here and there.

Star Ocean IV? It actually looks pretty close to that.

And about ToV, perhaps ToV looked better, although it missed detailed character models.

Anyways, here's another screenshot (and a bigger res. one):

http://i657.photobucket.com...

And since still images don't say much, I'll also leave a video: http://www.youtube.com/watc...

Not really defending the game, but I think it actually looks pretty good.

Kareshi_X4958d ago

still not close to the most recent rpgs imo. Demon soul , Valkyria chronicles , Star Ocean IV , tales of Vesperia all looked better.

Stealth20k4958d ago

Who cares how they look. They play better than most and the story is truely unique unlike star ocean, demon souls

callahan094958d ago

IGN continues to be irrelevant. What a pathetic review.

callahan094958d ago

At all my disagrees... really? You're going to take this review seriously when it doesn't hardly even mention the gameplay and mostly just complains about acting and humor? Whatever.

Ravage274958d ago (Edited 4958d ago )

This is IGN we are talking about. Every single point on the review scale has to be paid for with advertising money and shady deals.

These retards define the very meaning of the word 'irrelevant'. The scores of every single high-profile game are rated above 8.5 while the 'unlucky' reviewers stuck with low-profile games will pretend to have completed the game and subsequently write a completely useless piece of 0.1% facts,90% opinion and 9.9% fabricated nonsense.

For anyone looking to disagree, go read any other review of AR and compare it with IGN's 'review' (if you don't mind losing half your brain cells). You'll be surprised by just how shallow and uninformative these IGN's 'reviews' really are.

Redempteur4958d ago

i hate how this review spoil some moments of the game and don't even bother to explain the battle system ( it's a rpg come on !! ) or synthesis system properly ..it's a atelier game based on alchemy there is over 9000 items to create yet this guy didn't even bother to write about it ..
and no there isn't 15 endings in this game .. there is however 15 people who you have to help in order to reach the good or true ending ..

It just feel like this guys played the first hour and compled teh spots with some info badly translated from teh japanese foroms of the game ..

such misinformation is trully IGNorant

Wakka_4957d ago

I'm sure you loved them when IGN gave MGS4 a perfect score.

Omega44958d ago

Guys just remember its only one persons opinion.

BlackBusterCritic4958d ago

I've seen many reviews on this game already, and they all enjoyed the title. Even the ones that gave it around 70's still enjoyed the title immensely.
Ign has their off days...nearly everyday.

TOO PAWNED4958d ago

guy with one bubble tries to be rational (roll my eyes)

baodeus4958d ago

exactly. You might have different opinion so try out the game for yourself and make a decision. Go rent it first or something.

The overall rating for Lost Odyssey for example is 78/100. To me that is the best traditional JRPG this gen so far. Do I give a shitz about 78 score? NO.

Neckbear4958d ago (Edited 4958d ago )

Liam O' Brien as motherfucking Sterk, and the VA is bad? Not to mention, Rorona's VA is of the few female loli VAs that sound good in english.

Music is even worse, even when the music is actually good and fits every part of the game?

With the battle system I agree- except I feel like the reviewer missed out the part where you ACTUALLY collect items and recipes for synthesis... And he bitches that there's "no skill required" in making items, I mean, the fuck? Seems like he missed the part where every item gets quality and stats thanks to the materials you use- wich means you sometimes have to collect certain materials for better quality items.

If this is an opinion, this is the worse opinion piece I've ever read.

Even so, it's like the reviewer didn't even felt like completing the game, NO- ehm, like he didn't felt playing the game for a few hours.

...Seriously. I like this game mainly 'cause it's you know, FUN.

Show all comments (56)
80°
9.5

Atelier Arland Trilogy DX PS4 review - Demon Gaming

Lyam writes: - Atelier Arland Trilogy DX is another collection release, but this time, on PlayStation 4. The games with it are Atelier Rorona: The Alchemist of Arland, Atelier Totori: The Adventurer of Arland, and Atelier Meruru: The Apprentice of Arland, which have all appeared on PlayStation 3, as well as the PlayStation Vita. It’s quite an ongoing franchise with Atelier Rorona is the 11th game in the series and there are more plenty more to come.

Read Full Story >>
demonvideogame.com
Teflon021943d ago

It's probably my favourite 3 (well didn't like meruru much) But the price is trash. Should have been normal retail price for all 3 imo.

LG_Fox_Brazil1942d ago

I haven't played the Atelier series for quite a while now. Last game I finished was Iris 3, although I didn't really liked it. I love the first one, Eternal Mana. I think I finished Atelier Iris 1 at least three times. I bought Atelier Sophie and played less than 10 hours before I dropped it. Would love to see another game with the Iris level of story telling.

Servbot411942d ago

Surprised this wasn't censored.

120°

This Week In Gaming – Assassin’s Creed, Legend Of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds, Oculus Rift, & More

Things get exciting on this episode of This Week in Gaming! From John Carmack joining the team working on the Oculus Rift, to new gameplay footage of The Legend Of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds. Also, tons of weird Japanese games. I hope you brought napkins because things are about to get saucy!

Read Full Story >>
twinfinite.net
Kevlar0093913d ago

Don't forget WInderful101. A lot of things happened for it this week

Canary3913d ago

Cripes, I keep seeing this guy posting his videos.

And they're awful. Please stop.

I don't mind that you're a prepubescent. I do mind the constant mumbling and inability to properly pronounce every other word.

30°

Gust Says There Won’t Be An Atelier Rorona Plus

There won’t be an Atelier Rorona Plus, but that doesn’t mean gamers won’t be seeing more of Rorona in the future.

Read Full Story >>
siliconera.com
zerocrossing4052d ago

Kinda disappointed by this news :/

illtornworld4052d ago

me too! i was looking forward to more of these games

Hicken4052d ago

Well that's a shame. Gotta grab Totori Plus soon, though, to get the bonus stuff.

Wait, I don't even really care about that stuff. Still want it, though.