GameSpot writes: "The Trials of St. Lucia does an admirable job of turning the worst idea from the original adventure into something entertaining, but it's still hampered by the same problems that made those initial trials such a drag. It's only entertaining to swing your blood-soaked scythe for so long because the combat is shallow and the objectives only offer a slight change to the core experience. However, the in-depth editor, extra playable character, and cooperative mode are different enough to lure back anyone anxious to be wrapped up in hell's clutches for a few more hours".
Tech-Gaming writes: "Critics who chastised Visceral Games for their lenient adaption of Dante’s Inferno will undoubtedly be incensed by the latest downloadable content designed to augment the action game. Veering even further from Alighieri’s prose, The Trials of St. Lucia has players controlling the patron saint of the sightless in an effort to slaughter demonic foes. While pithy purists might balk at such poetic license, most of us will be too busy hectically butchering hellspawn to even care."
Multiplayer.it: Electronic Arts continues to support its flagship title by releasing more or less constant for additional downloadable extra content from the Internet or inside of special editions of its products.
Hexus writes: "Dante’s Inferno is out and selling, so why am I sitting on this nice leather sofa playing this? Because EA/Visceral Games has given you the POWER! The power to edit, to create, to manipulate this Hack and Slash fest into our own.. our own.. our own… IDIOM! (fairwell, sweet Concorde) And then to share the experience with others. The thing is though, it’s not in the Caribbean at all. St. Lucia is “Patron Saint of the Blind”. Apparently. I’ll tell you what she really is: Double Hard. With wing’s. Flying hard. Don’t mess. She is of course also, a second character to play, in Co-Op. That gets our vote. Saturday night hack and slash fest with your mates. Bring it on St Lucia, and bring your mates. Even the one with the gammy leg."
God damn...Everything about this game screams mediocrity...