180°

NoobTalk Editorial: Are reviewers too nice?

Anybody who hangs out on GameTrailers or visits Metacritic.com every once in a while knows this – some websites give out perfect scores in reviews more frequently than Gordon Ramsey makes people cry on national television. But why does this happen? Are the reviewers playing their first game ever, ejaculating over the magical fact that a man on the televisional doo-hickey is talkin' to them? I believe that it's detrimental to the progress of games development and their individual achievements to give them a perfect score. Why?

Read Full Story >>
noobtalk.com
CrippleH5298d ago

They need to take a look at PS1-N64 metacritics. Now that's too nice. A lot of games in that era got 96-99 easily.

Saaking5298d ago

Yes they are. There's way too many 9+ games when there shouldn't be as many. I think it just the thought that an less than an 9= fail. That's NOT true. A game rated 7 is a pretty good game, an 8 is a very good game with some minor mistakes, a 9 is an amazing almost perfect game and a 10 is a game above all games. This notion that a game HAS to get at least a 9 to be "good" is just dumb.

5298d ago
Blaze9295298d ago (Edited 5298d ago )

It depends on what kind of reviewers we want to talk about. If we want to talk about Corporate reviews like IGN, Gamespot etc who get bribes and swag bags for big games, then yes...they are "too nice".

If we want to talk about honest reviewers that actually play the game and know what the hell they are talking about and spent money on the game so the sense of "value" is there - then no, they are usually correct.

http://n4g.com/NewsCom-4243...

I liked that review so much becuase it was honest and most important of all it came from a FANS perspective who actually know what the hell he was talking about. It's funny how IGN, Gamespot, 1up, and all of the bigger corporate outlets failed to mention how utterly retarded Forza 3's multiplayer mode is in comparison to Forza 2's.

I feel all the corporate outlets are "too nice" for big games because they don't want to upset fanboys and most importantly, publishers/developers. IGN gave ODST...a 9? Are you freakin kidding me? I own that game, loved it, had a great time but I would never give it even an 8. IGN was just "too nice" becuase its a Halo game.

Compared to someone who spent hard earned money ($60) on ODST - their opinion is very different.

So we got real reviewers who are usually correct on reviews becuase they have no one to upset nor do they have anything to gain vs Corporate reviewers who get bribed, like to hand out good scores for just being a (insert title) game here, and not to upset fanboys and publishers but when it's a game no one cares about (like a dragonball game) they just rip it to shreds.

KiRBY30005298d ago

GTA4 is at 98 and its not even the best GTA in the serie.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5298d ago
StrboyM5298d ago

Most reviewers are scared....the label of fanboy is being thrown around like bras in a whorehouse so much that..its safer to

1.Have a disclaimer stating that you aren't a fanboy
2.Point out that you have all consoles ever created, so you cant be biased.
3. change(reviews articles...not scores) and answer to any fans that disagree to something your mis-spelled, mis-quoted, ect ect right in your forum.
4. give all the "supposed good games" 90 and above, even if its a 85 or below, or be cast into fanboy damnation hell, and have your site boycotted.

reintype5298d ago

Halo 3 has a better story than MGS4? Only if you're 12 or have a brain of one.

No other game this gen have made me feel happy to be a gamer today, and at the same time sad that it has to end, than the Epic Story that is called MGS4.

The only games that could possibly rival the story of Metal Gear games are:
1. Suikoden 1
2. Suikoden 2
3. Xenogears
4. Final Fantasy Tactics
and those are still subject for debate.

Darkfocus5298d ago

you've never played any PC games have you? :/

Nike5298d ago (Edited 5298d ago )

Yeah. No offense reintype, but there are some pretty awesome stories to be had on the PC as well.

The Longest Journey and it's sequel, Dreamfall; Grim Fandango; Planescape Torment - even more recent games like Half Life 2 and Portal (though they're also on consoles).

One game whose story is currently on my mind is Star Wars: Republic Commando. On the outset, it didn't seem to have a very deep story, but when you actually got through an entire campaign (that is, finishing up every single mission on one single planet or ship), you realized how complex and weaving the circumstances became. You're investigating why a Republic capital ship has suddenly resurfaced - and an hour later, when you're rigging the ship's turbo lasers to stop the Separatists from scuttling the hull while desperately fending off Droids, you'll find it hard to believe you got there.

Many other points to consider, but as for revisiting more current classics, Republic Commando is a great option.

Edit: If you can get DOSBox, you HAVE to experience "I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream". Effing brilliant exemplar of story telling.

Edit 2 @Sub4Dis: Deus Ex. No One Lives Forever. Baldur's Gate 2. System Shock 2. The list is so long and so beautiful. :)

Bodyboarder_VGamer5298d ago (Edited 5298d ago )

Console gaming > PC

Xenogears > Everything

edit: Dreamfall looks cool, after I beat Uncharted 2 maybe I'll try that one. The others seem too complicated, with so many menus and things on screen, that's why PC gaming sucks.

RROD Service_Rep5298d ago (Edited 5298d ago )

they're only too easy on 360 games so they dont upset the average 12 year old age group for the 360.

BooHooBot5298d ago

WHAT DO YOU MEAN??? WAHHHHHHHH WAHHHHHHHHHHH

patterson5298d ago

Game developers got clever, not only are they developing games but relationships with popular reviewers and review sites. They got smart with the PR aspect essentially. This friendly relationship helps ensure over inflated review scores and the cause for a lot of head scratching when reading most of them.

Show all comments (27)
90°

Two Decades Later, the Original Splinter Cell is Still a Masterpiece

They don't make games like this anymore.

Read Full Story >>
gamingbolt.com
vgvill1d 18h ago

Too dated in my book. The AI is way too unpredictable to be acceptable today. It's definitely a game of its time.

Jingsing1d 15h ago (Edited 1d 15h ago )

Agreed with those sentiments. The quality of the CPU controlled characters make or break a stealth game and they are pretty poor in all the Splinter Cell games by today's standard. This is what led me to playing Spies vs Mercs all the time in later games just to get a better stealth experience from a real person. Arguably Sony are making better stealth games albeit not Tom Clancy stuff.

TheProfessional1d 10h ago (Edited 1d 10h ago )

You should stick with fortnite or one of the countless bloodborne style games then. What a joke.

rlow11d 11h ago

I had a good time with the game. It is a product of its time. But when it came out it was a must have game for a lot of people. I wish Ubisoft would make another game in the series or at least a reboot.

vgvill1d 9h ago

They are making a remake, I think. I loved the original game when it was released, but I tried to play it again in recent years and just couldn't get on with it. The same with the older Hitman games.

PrecursorOrb1d 9h ago

Yeah chaos theory still holds up though I gotta say. If you’re a fan of the series I highly suggest you go back to that one. Ubi has said they are remaking sc for “modern audiences”. I don’t have a lot of faith for the future of that company

Chocoburger1d 2h ago (Edited 1d 2h ago )

Due to the lack of modern stealth games, and me constantly playing the MGS series, I've been looking for alternative stealth games to play, and went back and re-played the SC series recently. I wouldn't call SC1 or SC:PT masterpieces, there are AI issues, they're very much trial-and-error games, and that can lead to a lot of frustration. I also found the stories in this series to be boring, uninteresting, and just sloppily told. Cinematics are also of poor quality for both in-game scenes and CG cut-scenes, the soundtrack didn't leave any impression on me either.

Chaos Theory is better, but there was still a lot of room for improvement, and Double Agent (old gen ver.) was a sloppy mess that ended up a regression from CT. But still, at least they tried back then, these days Ubi-junk doesn't even try to make good games!

70°

A Matter Of Trust: What The Game Industry Should Do To Win Gamers Back

Skewed and Reviewed have written an Opinion Piece covering issues in the gaming industry, how current issues were issues years ago, and what can be done to help restore consumer trust.

anast7d ago

Nothing. It's up to the gamers to stop consuming content from companies that they don't agree with.

Garethvk6d ago

How do you know if you agree with it or not unless you play it? Which without conventions forces gamers to rely on trailers. Perhaps Demos should be made more frequently. But companies need to do better as well.

anast6d ago

Wait until release. Watch Gameplay. Exercise patience.

Garethvk6d ago

But is that not what they have now? Tons of gameplay or are you talking about watching actual gamers play it versus the trailers and streams? The big issue is that some companies pay streamers and influencers and they create content but for me; that is hardly a fair, unbiased, and factual look at a game.

1nsomniac6d ago

Get rid of the suits in the industry and job done!!

Garethvk6d ago

They usually are attached to the money sadly. It would be nice to have gamers in charge but you have so much money invested that business people are needed. Hence the issue; you need people who know business but are also gamers who know have an eye to the community. It sounds simple in theory that if you give gamers quality games that they want to play; money will be made. But that is not always so.

60°

From The Last of Us to Baldur's Gate 3: The success of the Game Music Festival

Marie Dealessandri speaks to Borislav Slavov and Gustavo Santaolalla about “the new golden age of games music”.

Read Full Story >>
gamesindustry.biz