230°

Slightly Mad: GT5's damage isn't "quite so realistic"

Slightly Mad Studios' Andy Tudor has suggested that Gran Turismo 5's damage modelling isn't "quite so realistic" as Need For Speed: Shift's.

Read Full Story >>
gamerzines.com
Wiitactics5352d ago (Edited 5352d ago )

They don't even mention Forza 3 once. LoL

Why? Because Forza it's irrelevant when compared with Gran Turismo and the NFS:S Devs wanted to be compared with the best. =)

BTW
This is just EA trying to draw a little bit of attention to their game. You know how tough will be for them to release that piece of crap with Forza and Gran Turismo coming this year too...

If racing sims are for nerds then NFS:S is for n00bs!!!

WildArmed5352d ago

'NFS Shift developers'

Ofc they wont talk about Forza. NFS shift just wants to take a shot at the top dog of racing (GT-series).

Forza is good, but no other Racing franchise is acclaimed as the GT series. So whenever people talk about racing, they compare to GT.

Its like how people compare FPS to halo all the time. (its the most acclaimed FPS franchise)

siyrobbo5352d ago

maybe they didnt mention forza because the damage modelling is better than theres? GT's damage modelling is a joke (well it os right now anyway)

callahan095352d ago

@siyrobbo:

I don't understand why everybody thinks GT5's damage is a joke. I thought it looked very nice when I first saw it in motion. I'm looking at a video from PAX on Friday of Forza 3, and I don't see how this game's damage is any more impactful than GT5's.

http://pax.gamespot.com/vid...

If there's a better video out there that shows how Forza 3's damage is more impactful and realistic than GT5's, please point me in that direction.

I mean, that Bugatti barely got damaged at all, and he flew into that wall, head-on, at 150 mph. If damage modeling were realistic at all, that car would have been completely destroyed. The hood would have crumpled, the doors would have buckled, the thing wouldn't look anything like it did in this game after such a collision.

So I honestly just don't see where GT5's damage is getting all this flak for being unrealistic and weak, where Forza's is getting praised to the heavens, and I'm not seeing how Forza's is any better or more realistic.

El Botto5352d ago

GT is for real racing fans and pro racers.

NFS is for the gamer who cant get enough of GT5.

siyrobbo5352d ago

ill reserve final judgement when the game hits, and i get to play it, but as it stands - from what i've seen of it, i'd rather they didnt bother at all with damage. It just seems like its been tacked on at the last minute. But for all i know they have a newer build set to blow every one away at TGS

Like i say i'll reserve judgement for the full retail release

Same goes for forza (which i never mentioned, i havent seen anything of Forza 3's damage modeling, forza 2's was pretty good- tho not a patch on grid/dirt)

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 5352d ago
adriano9995352d ago

probably because nfs:shift have like 20 cars?

wxer5352d ago (Edited 5352d ago )

so now Slightly Mad acting like a big boys huh ??

and this is their first game

we'll see what they'll say when the reviews/sales charts comes out

there is gona be a lot of ownage

but you know what Slightly Mad
compare your game to game at the same level
what about super car challenge ?
super car challenge is going to kick NFS:S ass too

so bottom line is Slightly Mad needs to shut their mouths and do a good game cus this is their first game after all

LiL T5352d ago

"We do as much as the manufacturers allow us to do, which is anything up to the point of encroaching the driver's safety zone, which means we can't tear the doors off.

GT5 also has (or plans to have) interior damage as well, how do Slightly dumb explain that. I guess when your car models look like plastic with custom stickers or in shifts case not true to life representation of manufactures vehicles, they don't care that much. Seem's like GT5 is the only one having issues with manufactures because thier vehicles actually don't look like plastic or get blured out when racing.

sorry about the rambling its 5:30am so the sentences maybe incomprehensible.

MNicholas5352d ago

that putting roll-cages in all the cars isn't realistic.

Still, gives us some insight into why damage modeling in these games is so bad ... manufacturer restrictinos. Damage modeling isn't technically demanding. Some old PS2 and Xbox games that didn't use actual car models had great damage modeling.

phosphor1125352d ago

That quote is one of the major reasons why GT has never done damage. Forza is the only one pretty much "breaking the rules" unless they are putting money down on those features. Both PD and SMS have said that manufacturers didn't like their cars busted up. EVEN GREENWALT HAS SAID FERRARI HATED THE IDEA OF THEIR CARS GETTING SMASHED.

"No, PD is just lazy." Yep. Lazy.

stevenhiggster5352d ago

Forgive me if I'm wrong here (which I'm not) but since when was having roll cages in racing cars 'not realistic'!? I would say NOT having a roll cage in a racing car is 'not realistic'!

sunil5352d ago

Updated from article

"UPDATE: Andy has since been in touch with GamerZines to clarify this story.
By stating that Polyphony Digital's method of implementing damage was 'not quite so realistic', he simply meant that adding rollcages to the car was "a good workaround but one we haven't had to do on Need For Speed: Shift", rather than stating that GT5's damage modelling was less realistic than that of Need For Speed: Shift's."

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 5352d ago
morkendo5352d ago

slightly mad give it up will ya shift no where near compatible with GT5 realistic damages. not even with GRID an u guys trying match them.

1nOnly5352d ago

i haven't seen one single car damaged in Shift. Its highly unlikely to not have car damage but I have to see to believe

Sarcasm5352d ago

Here we go again.

Any minute now, Forza 3 trolls are gonna come barging in.

JOLLY where are you brotha?

Montrealien5352d ago

not unlike the GT trolls I presume. How about the console racing fans? You know, like the ones that don`t feel the need to be douches and just appreciates good competition. Even I know GT5 is no holy grails of racing, its just a very good game, you kids need to simmer down a little and enjoy games cause with Forza 3, Shift, Dirt 2 and even maybe the top dog GT 5 all coming out this holiday season there si something for everyone. Its a great time to be a console racing fan. And its never a great time to be a marginal (enthusiasts).

Show all comments (53)
90°

PlayStation 3: chasing the 1080p dream, part three - Gran Turismo 5 and the indie explosion

From Digital Foundry: "Welcome to the third part in the biggest DF Retro episode we've ever produced - a year-by-year look at how 1080p gaming fared on the PlayStation 3. Launched in 2007 touting its then-exclusive HDMI digital interface, Sony layered full HD gaming on top of its Cell processor and RSX 'Reality Synthesizer' as key selling points for its third generation console. Of course, we all know how that turned out - both Sony and Microsoft machines routinely ran the most advanced titles at sub-720p resolutions, often with questionable performance, so what happened to the 1080p dream?

In the first two parts of John Linneman's investigation, we've covered off the first four years of the Triple's lifecycle and moving into 2010, the overall fortunes of the PlayStation 3 continued to improve. The platform holder released - what was then - the most advanced motion controller in the console space, backed up by experiments with stereoscopic 3D, which turned out to be a short-lived but still formidable pairing. Combined with a strong E3 showing, PS3 was looking good.

However, it's fair to say that it was a fallow year for 1080p gaming on the system, with only Scott Pilgrim Saves The World's razor-sharp pixel art upscaling, Castle Crashers and Soldner X2's 3D/FMV stylings accommodating full HD output - alongside a wonderful Monkey Island remaster."

Read Full Story >>
eurogamer.net
ApocalypseShadow647d ago (Edited 647d ago )

Just remember ladies and gentlemen, Sony never said all games would be 1080p. Only that the system would support games up to 1080p in a survey before the system was released.
https://spong.com/article/9...
And as we saw, some games did support it, some games tried their best to support it and some games didn't or never reached it.

Is a higher resolution great to have if you can do it? Sure. Is it necessary for a fun game? No

But what I find interesting is Eurogamer. Are they really talking about HD and PS3 in their article or are they really pushing their 4.50 Euros 4K video download subscription? Seems one is being used to sell the other. Just look at the bottom of the article.

Michiel1989647d ago

thats what every company tries to do, push for people to buy their products. Are you really gonna blame them for that?

ApocalypseShadow647d ago

Not all articles are about selling. They're about informing or entertaining.

Maybe I'm supposed to watch the video instead of reading. But I shouldn't have to click. But the article lazily tells us some games did hit 1080p and some didn't. I didn't learn anything new as I own the console. Then, they push a Patreon subscription.

Are you saying every opinion, preview, review and rant article requires a push to buy something now? Tell me which sites are prone to do so so that I can avoid them in the future.

Michiel1989647d ago

not everyone played during the ps3 era. I started during snes era but loved seeing articles/videos about how gaming evolved before that.

i dont think this article is trying to push you to get that patreon sub, it doesnt for me at least. I dont think theres anything wrong putting an ad at the bottom of the article. all the regular DF videos are free already.

SonyStyled647d ago

Wipeout HD on PS3, a remake of the PS1 game was 1080p 60fps. And that released in 2007-08

Christopher647d ago

This really feels like a filler article. I don't feel like I learned anything notable or substantial from this. I feel they could have reduced the unnecessary intro and over-explanation of things and put the whole series in one article for a more substantial and possibly informative piece rather than piece-mealing it out as they have.

dumahim647d ago

It's more about the video. DF Retro videos are for Patreon members first, and I think the whole thing was one big video. For the youtube channel, it gets chopped up and released weekly.

ApocalypseShadow647d ago

Chris is actually right on this one. Something known already was just kind of washed over in the article. Unless you're supposed to get more in the video. If more is in the video, then more could have been said in the article.

Only thing I learned new was that they are selling a subscription. My point though is that you gain more viewers by having better articles and content.

645d ago
190°

Need for Speed: Carbon, Undercover, and More to Be Removed from Digital Storefronts

EA has announced that Need for Speed Carbon, Need for Speed Undercover, Need for Speed Shift, Need for Speed Shift 2: Unleashed, and Need for Speed The Run will be removed from digital storefronts beginning today, May 31.

Kombatologist1067d ago

From a preservation standpoint, this is the one thing I hate about digital games. And things will get much worse if game streaming becomes the norm.

darthv721067d ago

The games are already preserved. Hence their existence on the digital stores to begin with. This is no different than when Disney put movies in the vault, only to bring them back years later.

spwittbold1067d ago

Not true. Mass Effect re-release trilogy did not have some of the DLC content specifically because the contractor that played a major role in it's development did not preserve it, nor did Bioware.

thejigisup1067d ago

Any idea of when marvel vs capcom 2 is coming back? That's my favorite game of all time and I can't use it on my ps3 as the file is corrupt and can't find an official dualshock or sixaxis to rebuild the database in safe mode. It's really frustrating that I can't use something I paid for that I expected to have forever.

DOMination-1067d ago

At least it is available digitally. They give you a warning, and if you purchase it, then you will still always have access to it. They will also make it available again one day when it makes sense, but right now I imagine that <100 a day play these games.

Good luck buying Need for Speed: Carbon brand new from a store.

All games have a shelf life. These games are three generations old and had massive circulation. I don't think it is EAs problem if you haven't picked them up by now.

Sgt_Slaughter1066d ago

Why defend EA's bad business practice? There's no way to spin this, it's just bad.

Retroman1067d ago (Edited 1067d ago )

NFS Undercover, Carbon,Prostreets, Rivals, 2015 Reboot, Payback , 2012 Mostwanted was no good, far as I'm concerned they can remove Heat too . it doesn't matter anymore if Ea remove them they "All" crap.
Ea went down hill after Blackbox studio left.
Ghost did not improved NFS , Criterion did nothing better and here they are back to screw NFS again. 2022 will be another flop as the first title they made (Burnout for Speed)

DarXyde1067d ago

Not a fan of those games either, but I think you miss the point: even if someone—for whatever reason—wants to buy those games digitally, they can't. And the transition toward digital platforms makes the issue that much worse. Nevermind buying physical at outrageous prices from online sellers, you literally can't play them if you have an all-digital device.

Kombatologist is exactly right: it is an issue from the perspective of preservation that is likely to get worse with the rise of streaming.

Retroman1066d ago

Ah, no. I did Not missed the point. I spoke my personal opinion on those craptastic titles.
Why would anyone in there right mind but those title's Digitally??.......there is a website you can still buy those games around 19.99 I bought the Ratchet and Clank Trilogy PS3 for 19.99 Amazon and EBay price 79.99 wish I remember the name of the site.

strayanalog1067d ago

I wonder what Need for Speed said a decade ago on twitter.

1067d ago
Profchaos1067d ago

I own some of these games does that mean I can no longer download them? Or just purchase?

boing11067d ago

Removed from storefronts so my guess is it's only about digital purchase.

Show all comments (16)
280°

What Happened To Gran Turismo?

When thinking about simulation racing games in this console generation, it’s not unreasonable for your first thought to be “Forza”. Microsoft’s first-party sim-racer series has been wildly successful, and for many of us, it’s been the go-to franchise for quite some time. But simulation racing games weren’t always synonymous with Forza; there was a time when Polyphony Digital’s hardcore series, Gran Turismo, reigned supreme. While the long-time franchise continues to sell exceptionally well, there’s no doubt that it isn’t the young, spry series it used to be.

Read Full Story >>
gamingbolt.com
darthv721714d ago

It doesnt suck but I would love to see a return to form with GT7. Sport is such a departure that it can turn some people off. It has gotten better over time but it's still no match for a proper GT7.

Rude-ro1714d ago

Sport is awesome for what it is...
However, polygon built a whole new engine and the tech is still being worked on...
I understand it is easy to praise a cookie cutter because it release the same game over and over with rotations of maps and cars...
But this engine polygon has designed does more for things other than gaming.

Repetitive old engines with new makeup does not make anyone king.

Gt7 will be most likely in two years with 120fps and ray tracing because their new engines are ready now.

LordStig1714d ago

It decided to focus on racing rather than cars and in the gaming world, racing = gameplay.

Imalwaysright1714d ago

What complete and utter BS. GT has always focused on racing and gameplay.

1714d ago
neutralgamer19921714d ago

Good I guess selling millions of copies and have OFFICIAL FIA license races and Esports means it sucks

We just don't get it every year which is why ms also delayed next forza. You can't keep making yearly sequels. Quality and innovation takes time

GT sports at launch to now it's a different game and support has been free

Imalwaysright1714d ago

GT games have always sold millions of copies and what's so innovative about GT sport? It's a racing game FFS.

IRetrouk1713d ago

The online championships and tournaments alone offer more innovation than any racer this gen🤷‍♂️ then you also get the live ones in New York etc with proper race like commentary, something else no other sim has done before. It sells millions because it's the best, simple really.

Imalwaysright1713d ago (Edited 1713d ago )

IRetrouk

I'm not even sure why think that having proper like race commentary or championships and tournements is innovative but I'll play along... GT Sport was released in 2017 so how do explain that this video https://www.youtube.com/wat... from 2016 exists?

Dark_Knightmare21714d ago

Spoken like someone who hasn’t played sport

Imortus_san1713d ago

And those Paid demos, that fans try to hide and not talk about it.

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 1713d ago
SCW19821714d ago

It became the best online racing community for console players and its an amazing achievment.

Keltech1714d ago

"Forza?" HaHaHaHaHaHaHa!! good joke!

kayoss1714d ago

Too early for an Aprils fool joke.

1714d ago
ElementX1714d ago

@solidgamerX That's really not very impressive. Somebody with an interest in cars plays racing games and becomes a race car driver. That's like saying "look at this guy, he played COD and now he's in the military"

Imalwaysright1714d ago

SolidGamerX

You must think that we're all stupid enough to believe that a game will turn anyone into a professional racing driver.

Prince-Ali1714d ago

FORZA!!! AAHAHHAHA !! Haven't i schooled you on this already before! You're still spewing nonsense on this threaddd looool

mcstorm1714d ago

Forza has always been better online than. GT and still is. Great to see PD try something different with GTS but let's face it this gen sonys racing games have been poor this then compaired to what Microsoft has had to offer. Forza 7 is one of the best racing games on xbox and pc but for me Horizon 3 and 4 have set the bar this gen. Of all the things microsoft got wrong this gen 2 of its racing games got a lot right and others are now playing catchup.

DarXyde1714d ago

It's debatable which is the better game. To me, Forza has the upper hand.

But in terms of online community and events? Ha. Don't lie to yourself just because you don't like Playstation.

1714d ago
1714d ago
Dark_Knightmare21714d ago

Lol not even close have you even played gt sport online?

Imalwaysright1714d ago (Edited 1714d ago )

SolidGamerX

You didn't need to confirm what I already knew: if you didn't think that we're all stupid you wouldn't make such stupid comments that only those that are dead from the neck up will agree with.

IRetrouk1713d ago (Edited 1713d ago )

Did he say gt could turn anyone into a racer? No he didnt, he asked what game has done it like gt has, which is true, gt academy done it throughout gt5 for a start. You need to do some research fella, cause your wrong.. again.

And lmao at element and the downplay, not even similar you crazy man, not even similar🤣 you realise gt has turned gamers into drivers from gt5? Go look at gt academy and tell me how that would be anything like someone playing cod and then joining the army, the downplay in gt articles is funny.

ElementX1713d ago

So you think he learned the required skills playing video games? I remember when people claimed children were learning how to operate guns because of video games, do you think that's also true?

IRetrouk1713d ago (Edited 1713d ago )

Two completely different things and you know it, it is a fact that gt has helped real gamers become real race drivers, the proof is easily available online and I'm not going round searching for links that has been posted many, many times before on this subject, Go and look at gt academy like I mentioned and you can see for yourself, they start out on gt and go from there, so yes the game gran turismo teaches you some driving techniques, now if you can find me a link where someone has been playing cod and went on to become a war hero, please let me know because I couldnt find anything, also do you have a link to where cod has a program to train soldiers? Like cod academy or something?, I couldnt find one of those either, maybe when you do then your comparison will actually make sense.

Imalwaysright1713d ago

IRetrouk

You mean the GT academy that provides training and licenses for a person to become a professional racing driver? The GT academy is how you go from being an average driving joe to become a professional racing driver not GT the game.

1713d ago
+ Show (14) more repliesLast reply 1713d ago
1713d ago
xRacer74x1714d ago

Forza owns the racing game scene in my area as far as video games go.

dekke1714d ago

Forza = Arcade
GT= Sim

why u ppl keep comparing those 2 games every time..

Keltech1714d ago (Edited 1714d ago )

GT owns the console sim racing scene in my area and around the world. Just ask a real race car drivers

https://youtu.be/2pC3-eCAdv...

LordStig1714d ago

Forza isn't a racing game. It's a car game.

1714d ago
+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 1714d ago
Hungryalpaca1714d ago

I’ll stick to sims. You keep playing with your hot wheels.

King_Noctis1714d ago

You forget that there are two Forzas, Forza Motorsport and Forza Horizon, which aims at different audiences.

King Nezz1714d ago

The usual response from someone insecure that feels their favorite racing game is nowhere near as good as it once was. I really liked Gran and played them all. Loved the Vector from part 2. But the franchise is not the same.

Gaming4Life19811714d ago

Yea Forza took over and is now the best sim racer with motorsport and the best arcade racer with horizon. GT was the best but it has been falling short for a long time and I'm not saying gt games are bad but no where near king like it used to be. I'd say forza motorsport 3 was the forza that really upped the franchise and forza 4 was when forza became #1.

I remember the glory days of gt but those days are long gone but it's still a good game just not the best. Of course ps fans will never admit it because they will die before giving MS credit.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 1714d ago
Nacho_Z1714d ago

I do think they need some new creative heads in to give them some new perspectives, they seem stuck in a rut. It's a very high quality rut but they're still stuck in it.

LordStig1714d ago

The USA leg of the Gran Turismo World Tour is going on in New York right now. Go watch it guys, there's some damn good racing and crazy updates to come.

Nacho_Z1714d ago

I've seen some of it before and to be fair it's not much different to watching real motorsport so credit to them for that.

Heavenly King1714d ago

the MACH 5 :) GO SPEED rACEr!!

Show all comments (108)