Why Everyone Needs to Stop Whining About OnLive

CGN Writes...

"But if OnLive works as well as I hope, will I get rid of my PS3, 360 and Wii? I'm not gonna lie, I thought about it. But then I thought, 'What would I do when Resistance 3 comes out? What will I do when the next Zelda comes out? What will I do when the next Gears comes out?'"

[SL1M DADDY]

Wait and see mode right now. If they can truly pull this one off and have it work, I will be one of the first to plunk down my cash, especially if it is a reasonable price. The idea of this makes me a happy camper, now I just wait for the results.

[Tempist]

Only Lazy / non-enthusiast PC gamers are going to switch to OnLive. I don't think there are many PC gamers who are really into their boxes that want to discard their high performance machines to play games at 1920x1080 or less when most of them are playing their games at 1920x1200 or more.

I know that seems whorish in terms graphics and such, but it's the truth and I don't think the OnLive people acknowledge this.

[UnasFortuna]

I am in a wait and see mode for now. I personally don't believe they will be able to pull it off as well as they say they will; however, for now, I will give them the benefit of the doubt. Anyways, it will not affect me one way or the other since I doubt I will subscribe to the service. I like my consoles and the benefits each has.

[Silver360]

How many gamers will be able to play on one server with 1080p graphics and how much bandwidth would it take. Service may look good as a demo with the servers a few feet away from the set top box, but how will it perform with millions of users and miles of cable? This is not ready to happen yet. The United States doesn't have the high speed internet capability quite yet. There are download caps in other countries. This service has many obstacles to overcome before it works in the real world. Including making people feel ok about giving away their money for a license to play, not a copy of the game. Money gone, no trade in value.

[DeadlyFire]

The power is there for one server to run thousands of games. The bandwidth I am not so sure about. I say the bandwidth needs another 4-5 years before the US can have it work right.

[militant07]

is really live require internet connection to play it ? and its all about streaming ??

if it is then its sucks

no internet = no games?

[Redempteur]

no internet = no games
also you have to pay for the service AND to pay for the games afterwards

but onlive is destined to fail ..it's not ready and 20 years too early .. you need a freaking huge internet connexion to enjoy the game at full speed and there is no support from third party publishers as of now ( except EA , but EA is a going on everything new )

[DOOMZ]

....

[-x.Red.x-]

http://www.youtube.com/watc...

[DNAgent]

Those hitler rants videos aren't funny anymore (especially since they have been ran into the ground after hundreds of different arguments/rants).

Anyways, I think OnLive will be pretty nice. I won't get rid of my PS3 or anything because it still has great 1st party games but I will get rid of the 360 because most of their "exclusives" are also on the PC and I can just get OnLive to play those.

[John HX]

It's just never going to work on a large scale, at an acceptable latency and with decent quality on todays connections. It's just not possible.

As people have said, in 5-10 years, just maybe. But proboably not even then.

[STONEY4]

If you think about it, OnLive = no mods.

[somekindofmike]

I think onlive has potential, but got to let it get past it's early toothing stage before I will be convinced to part with my cash :)

E. & for apple mac users who don't have a windows rig as well it could be very interesting.

[Tyre]

No Internet No Games=i'm beginning to hate it...plz let be 20 years until this sort of service is going to work. i just dig Hardware and beautiful CoverArt and playing games online and offline. and all the interface and communications features they have shown are just stolen ideas from Xboxlive.

[Quadrix]

If it does work as planned, I'll just use OnLive and the Wii. The Wii is in a high enough class of its own to survive OnLine if it does actually succeed.