200°
3.0

Redfall Review - Not Even on Game Pass | MMORPG

Redfall is a bad video game. It's one that feels both underbaked and unfinished, releasing in a visually poor state, loaded with bugs, lackluster gameplay and a boring, empty world.

I cannot recommend anyone spend time with Redfall, especially with Microsoft charging $70 for the title on Xbox or PC, and even on Game Pass I'd recommend simply playing Arkane's other titles instead.

anast385d ago

These are getting good. The all time peak for this game is 1.5k. This is brutal stuff.

Aloymetal385d ago (Edited 385d ago )

They went from a few 5's to a bunch of 4's and now to even 3's. Amazing achievement from a trillion$ company.

S2Killinit385d ago

Unfortunately they even mislead people into thinking this was going to be a big hit. People were excited about it and they did everything to make sure that no one caught onto the mediocrity prior to release. Its a bait and switch strategy to keep them signed up to gamepass for as long as many months as possible.

SullysCigar385d ago

^ Yeah agreed, they did mislead people. Especially through letting people believe things that suited them, like everyone expecting it in Unreal Engine 5 for years, everyone expecting 60fps, because that's what they advertised. How many sales did they get on false promises? Where is the recall/refund commitment?

What's crazy, to me, is that some of these more recent review scores might have been avoidable if they'd only addressed at least SOME of the bugs and glitches. It'll never be a good game, but they could have got it up towards 'mediocre' instead of just downing tools, throwing their hands up and taking the "well, we're screwed" attitude, which is how it feels right now.

anast385d ago

Yeah, it's astonishing. I thought it would be bad, but this is next level jank.

potatoseal385d ago

"Not even on Gamepass". That's true. If I got a free invite to gamepass, there's no way in hell I would even bother downloading this game let alone play the thing. Can't even fathom what the people who paid $70 for this so called 'game' are thinking deep down.

jznrpg385d ago

The AAA version of Superman/E.T

SullysCigar385d ago

Check out this one. They went with the subtitle: "The Bloody Shame of Phil Spencer"

https://n4g.com/news/254999...

darkrider385d ago

It's nail after nail on the box. The room for the next is shrinking.

Chevalier385d ago

More like Stake after Stake in Xboxs heart

Elda385d ago (Edited 385d ago )

I may be the vocal minority on this site when it comes to Redfall but the game is definitely not a 3. The game is not broken it's definitely playable. I'm about 3/4 through the game & yes it has some concept flaws but I'm playing through the game just fine with 5 more missions to go. I've experienced a couple of hiccups/glitches. For me the game is a 6.5 Gamepass game. I will say..it's not worth $70 as a retail stand-alone title.

TheEnigma313385d ago (Edited 385d ago )

Honestly there is no difference between 3-5 rating. Anything under a 7 as a consensus, isn't really worth wasting time on.

Traecy385d ago (Edited 385d ago )

Not true at all. I played some games that were rated between 6 to 7 & had a decent experience playing. Gaming reviews are opinions including subjective. I'm playing Redfall too & it's not a 3, it's a close 7.

LabRat385d ago (Edited 385d ago )

@Traecy - I guess it all comes down to personal preference and how much time someone has. I personally do not have a ton of time to play anymore, so why would I waste that that time on a 6 when I can play an 8 or 9 even.

Obviously who likes what is just personal taste, but it seems the overarching consensus for this game is that it truly is an insult to xbox fans that this is what MS thinks this is what is acceptable to release to its customers.

SullysCigar385d ago

^ @Traecy, the thing is, the aggregate score right here on N4G is 4.9/10 from 54 reviews. Now, we all know reviewers are just people with opinions, but the chances are they play more games than you or I, so they're probably closer to what most people's experience and opinion would be.

I'm sorry you've nothing better to spend your gaming time on, but if you think it's close to a 7 - and you're happy enough to spend your time that way - fair enough, nobody can be the judge but you.

Christopher385d ago

This is a truly sad look on games in general. This is why sites rate games so highly because people have too high of expectations. I've played way worse games than Redfall which were rated much higher.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 385d ago
rippermcrip385d ago

A "6.5 Gamepass game" is what for a $70 game? 3, 4, 5?

Sgt_Slaughter385d ago

"The game is not broken"

Factually inaccurate, the AI is completely broken and the game crashes repeatedly. Like what you like, but ignoring problems isn't helping anyone. There's multiple videos where the AI ignores what's going on and doesn't attack the player, or simply jumping on a car or a higher up object breaks them. Not to mention the ghost town that it is, running for over half the map without seeing a single person.

The game was released in a broken state. A 3 is warranted.

badz149385d ago

@Elda

"The game is not broken it's definitely playable"

same case with CP2077, ME Andromeda, Anthem, FO76...playable, sure but broken nonetheless!

one thing I have to agree on is the very low scores are definitely coming out of frustration due to high expectations for the game because another similarity between these games is the devs who were (are) highly regarded and held at a very high status among gamers.

Elda385d ago

If I can play a game & go to mission to mission getting further within the game, then to me the game is not broken. I have experienced some glitches but there are good games with glitches like the new Jedi Fallen Survivor but I'm enjoying it as well as I'm enjoying Redfall. Again..Redfall is not the best game & it has its flaws including the concept being flawed but out of curiosity I started playing & to me it's not that bad as most are making it out to be. That's just my experience as well as my opinion. To each their own.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 385d ago
Show all comments (30)
180°

Would It Have Even Mattered If Redfall Were Good?

Even if Redfall were a good game, the closure of Hi-Fi Rush proves even that doesn't matter in the industry.

Read Full Story >>
thegamer.com
Profchaos17d ago

Yeah it would have mattered especially since their huge game that year wasn't all that it was cracked up to be remember redfail was almost heavily promoted and hyped not to the level of starfield but still more promoted than the average game.

There was still a decent marketing campaign behind the game I'm sure millions were spent advertising it on websites and I saw a few billboards and bus stop signs in real life

darthv7216d ago

their biggest mistake was showcasing it as being a 60fps game only to release it at 30. That really soured the taste so that when the real 60fps mode was released, many still didnt want to give it a taste. i tierd it at 30... it was okay, but playing it at 60 is a much better experience and a better overall game. Its really not that bad once you get past the drama surrounding its initial release and just play it for what it is. It has some pretty decent aspects but nothing groundbreaking. It feels like a typical fps from the ps360 days... of which there were many.

jwillj2k417d ago

No it wouldn’t matter it wouldn’t bring in enough profit to offset their 100 billion dollar acquisition. It would maybe delay the inevitable by some months.

Profchaos16d ago

Pretty much no game in Bethesda stables makes cod numbers instantly even fallout 4 Bethesda's best selling game sold 12 million at launch and over the next 10 years climbed to over 32 which cod would do rapidly

CrimsonWing6917d ago

I would f*cking think so. Good games are what draws people to your platform. It’s why I adored the 360 era with Gears of War being one of the highlights for me. You make sh*t games and it just makes your platform that much worse and you start gobbling up studios I like and then killing them off it also makes me hate your platform as well… just sayin’

franwex17d ago

Unless the game would’ve been War Zone, or Fortnite level. No. Maybe even Hell divers 2 I doubt would’ve been enough.

Eonjay16d ago

Helldivers 2 realistically has earned about half a billion which is definitely a success considering it probably cost Sony $50 million to make.

However you would still need 140 releases to at least be that successful to break even on a ACT purchase.

This is how you know the goal for Microsoft was to reach those crazy subscribers numbers. Without them the whole plan falls apart.

Exvalos17d ago

No it would not have, the ABK deal was great for Microsoft but horrible for Xbox. Over 100 billion dollars in acquisitions. That money has to be made back. That ABK deal essentially destroyed Xbox as we know it.

Show all comments (38)
60°

A Flawed Game Till The Very End, Redfall Deserved To Die, But Not Arkane Austin

Hanzala from eXputer: "Redfall was a bland, repetitive game with no post-release support; it deserved to die, but why kill Arkane Austin over one mistake?"

z2g20d ago (Edited 20d ago )

What short memories everybody has. According to the internet they became “the worst studio” after redfall… the internet made redfall a bigger deal than redfall just being a shitty game becaus *gasp* Xbox bought them and” just wanted shitty gamepass games so quality wasn’t a priority”.
(The reality was it was just rushed to market to fill a release hole).

Everybody wants Xbox to fail but as soon as closures start happening suddenly that was never the hope at all and Xbox is just evil.

What has happened to humanity. Being so extreme with viewpoints paints everybody into a hypocritical corner where the side of the story your on depends on which side makes Xbox look worse. Read the internet. Your disagrees are lies.

Shame. Gamers never want to accept their role in all the shit.

My heart goes out to those laid off. Not sure why those studios had to close but I suspect they were costing more money to operate than they were brining in revenue. It does cost money to fix games. Cyberpunk’s road to redemption was prob approaching the price of the original game.

That sucks and I’m angry about it but that’s also business and I’m in the same boat myself at my job as we speak… so it’s not like I don’t have sympathy. But I’m tired of the short memories, the lack of true empathy and opinions being driven by branding. Disgusting.

MIDGETonSTILTS1720d ago

People wanted Xbox to succeed, especially after THE biggest media acquisition in history and effectively owning the entire existing Western RPG genre; but we knew they would fail, and they’d drag down an entire genre with them.

Nobody wanted this, but it was foreseen.

100°

Arkane Austin Was Working on a Big Redfall Update for May Before Microsoft Ditched the Game

The now abandoned Redfall had a roadmap of support that was being actively worked on before Microsoft scrapped all development and closed its developer, IGN can reveal.

jznrpg21d ago

But Xbox fans told us MS buying these studios was going to be more games for everyone

Chocoburger20d ago

Couldn't even let them finish the major update that was supposed to come out this month for a game that desperately needed an update? Spencer is such a douche.