190°
9.0

1UP: Mirror's Edge Review

1UP writes: "Innovation is risk, and Mirror's Edge puts everything on the line. In the opening cinematic, lithe protagonist Faith tells us of the Flow, the way that Runners -- information couriers in the game's sterile, totalitarian metropolis -- see the city. "Rooftops become pathways and conduits, possibility, and routes of escape. The Flow is what keeps us running, keeps us alive." While narrative in its delivery, her sentiment echoes the design aspirations of Mirror's Edge, a first-person adventure like no other where the world is viewed as more than a shooting gallery or a tactile means to an end.

It gets things very right very early, distilling its first-person platformer ambitions into a very manageable control scheme. One button stands in for all "up" actions -- jumping, hurtling over obstacles, scuttling up vertical surfaces, and pulling Faith onto ledges -- while another is for all "down" actions: sliding under pipes, ducking into vents, and tucking and rolling out of dangerously high jumps. It's a sublimely simple setup and allows for the level design to take center stage. Once you're familiar with Faith's abilities and their limitations -- imparted through a much-needed tutorial -- it's easy to see potential routes through the world."

tocrazed4you5665d ago

is up with 1up these days... this got an A over resistance 2...

Apocwhen5665d ago

Totally different games perhaps? This game tries to do something new gameplay wise.

CEO OF N4G5665d ago

So just because they got an A over resistance2 dose not mean any thing i will say this again and i know i will say it again in another review topic "REVIEWS ARE JUST SOMEONES OPINION"

Mr_Showtime15665d ago

Maybe it's a better game? I certainly like it alot better than resistance. I sick to death of just your standard shooter now, probably why I not picking a normal one until KZ2

BYE5665d ago

LOL it seems like R2 is everyone's Achilles' heel...

Tomdc5664d ago (Edited 5664d ago )

reviews are not by companies... They are by several different people within companies. There might be those at 1up that hate this game and would have reviewed it differently. There may also be those at 1up who disagree with resistance 2 score, placing it higher or maybe even lower...

When you apply it, common sense explains a lot.

5664d ago
iamtehpwn5664d ago

Then from prisoners on the guy who always drops the soap in the shower.

I'm still buying it because I reallllllly fancied the demo.
Mirror's Edge 2, please get the balls to do real cut scenes. Only request. I think I'll love this game. ;P

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 5664d ago
CEO OF N4G5665d ago

Mr showtime u should pick up resistance2 as well.I have played it and i can tell u that its not your average shooter.I am in the killzone2 beta and i can also tell u it makes resistance2 look average.But resistance2 is the best FPS out this year.

belal5665d ago

i only belive in ign, they gave resistance 2 a 9.5 and thats what i belive ;)they gave gears 2 a 9.5 so i belive that gears 2 is a great game too ;) and mirrors edge is avrage and thats not bad, but its not what i expected.

Ricdeau5664d ago (Edited 5664d ago )

"they gave gears 2 a 9.5 so i belive that gears 2 is a great game too"

That's got to be one of the worst lines I've heard someone say in awhile regarding reviews. So what you're saying can be summarized as "I let IGN do the thinking for me." Forming an idea on what the game is like and about from a review is one thing, but basing your entire opinion on the review? Well, who's the bot now?

And how about the IGN UK review of Mirror's Edge and the 8.3 it got? Does that turn your opinion around? At the end of the day that's all reviews are, opinions. As far as video game reviews go, it's hard to trust anyone to try to give a nonbias opinion these days it seems.

mugoldeneagle035664d ago

It's that they overgrade innovation.

As much as I love 1UP and adore their podcast Mirrors Edge will still be just a renter for me. Everywhere else has been arund the 7.5 range.

And it look's like it would grow repetitve.

Still worth a rental though

BrotherNick5664d ago

Yes, let's not overgrade innovation lol. /sarcasm
Innovation is what makes the industry thrive.

Show all comments (27)
80°

Battlefield 2042 Mirror's Edge Easter Egg Surfaces in Season 4 Map

It seems that in Season 4, DICE has snuck in a Battlefield 2042 Mirror's Edge Easter egg in the new Flashpoint map.

220°

10 Old Games With Outstanding Graphics

GF365: "There are some games with extraordinary visuals that impress us to this day. Here are old games with outstanding graphics."

Read Full Story >>
gamefreaks365.com
ShwaaMan474d ago

Bioshock still looks fantastic, one of my all time favorites.

Yui_Suzumiya474d ago

Beyond: Two Souls on PS3 can compete with modern day graphics.

SonyStyled474d ago (Edited 474d ago )

Same as Killzone 2 and 3, uncharted 2 and 3, Infamous 2, Heavy Rain, Resistance 3

jasonismoney474d ago

I wish this was entirely true, but you might want to load up Killzone 2 and Resistance 3 again.

SonyStyled474d ago

@jason I watched some gameplay videos of KZ2 and R3 on my full screen. They are on par or succeed graphically to the first person shooters mentioned in the article that also launched on the seventh generation of consoles. Try the same and see what you think

cthulhucultist474d ago

Killzone 3 was super impressive! I could not believe the graphics back then as I was regularly pausing the game to stand in awe looking at the surroundings! Resistance however did not impress me that much. Heavy rain is also another amazing graphically speaking game. It almost felt next gen

Fist4achin474d ago

I always thought the first 3 Gears of War games looked great and still hold up for today.

SonyStyled474d ago

They did for their day. I recently played gears judgement with on the 360 and the draw distance was so blurry. The characters up close look great though

JEECE474d ago

Far Cry 2 was awesome. In addition to having demonstrably better physics and AI than later games in the series, it had a lot of design decisions that, criticized at the time, have since been praised in games like BOTW and Dark Souls.

iNcRiMiNaTi474d ago

It might not be super amazing by today's standard but I thought Mgs3 looked really good

JEECE474d ago

In terms of art style it still holds up.

Show all comments (13)
270°

Mirror's Edge achievement designer: "Achievements have been bad for gaming"

Ubisoft Massive lead gameplay designer Fredrik Thylander, previously of DICE where he worked on Battlefield and Mirror's Edge, has spoken out about achievements and trophies, arguing that they "have been bad for gaming."

Machina491d ago (Edited 491d ago )

The achievements in Mirror's Edge opened my eyes to a whole other way of approaching the game. Since some of the toughest and most rewarding ones are basically whole levels turned into time trials with very strict time requirements, they force you to become much better at the game - in a way that difficulty levels just don't - and made me appreciate the mechanics that much more (especially the momentum-based running and platforming).

They actually made the game better for those like me who really enjoyed the game but wanted more of it, basically adding a new level of difficulty that took a long time to master/overcome. It added some extra longevity to a very short game.

He says "it eats resources that could have made the game better". I'm curious what he thinks the time he spent designing the achievements for the game would've been better spent on, because I expect bang for buck-wise achievements are a pretty efficient way of adding value to a game for the people who end up loving it.

shinoff2183491d ago (Edited 491d ago )

I kinda see his point but I also see your point.

I've been trying to remember what games over the years have had their own trophies inside the game before trophies and such were a thing and all I can think of is the star ocean series

Christopher491d ago

I think his point, though not elucidated upon because of Twitter limitations, is not that they can be bad but that they are used improperly to extend gameplay rather than reward actions.

Nebaku490d ago

Harvest Moon: Magical Melody on the GCN did.

In fact it actually built the game around it.

RpgSama491d ago (Edited 491d ago )

I am very OCD about playing games that I can platinum, in that sense I probably avoided playing games that I knew I would be unable to 100% complete.

I do think there are other people like me and also feel there should be an option for you to individually deactivate getting trophies on specific games, just so you play them and they do not go to your account.

-Foxtrot491d ago (Edited 491d ago )

I don't know. I used to think Achievements / Trophies were ruining games at first but then I saw the positive, if you totally love a game then they would offer you replay value by going after the last achievements to 100% the game. It made you explore every last bit of the game to achieve this and sometimes pushed you into areas or scenarios you probably might have missed.

It was a blast to get them on Oblivion / Skyrim, Fallout, Witcher, God of War, Elden Ring etc

Don't get me wrong, I do think there's achievements which are annoying, the ones where you need to find all collectibles which end up being missable AND are like trying to find a needle in a haystack are a kick to the balls, you know the majority of us are just going to use a guide to find them so what's the point.

Kind of a shame Nintendo haven't gotten a full system in place, they are so behind.

jambola491d ago

Nintendo seem to either be ahead of their time by years
or behind by 10 years
no in between

Rimeskeem491d ago

I enjoy having something to go for and feeling accomplished when doing something hard. I just hate it when achievements are based on things you can't really control. Like when something is for MP and the MP is just dead.

MadLad491d ago (Edited 491d ago )

I used to be a hardcore achievement hunter back in the day, but I couldn't care less nowadays. I just want to play games the way I actually want to play them, and don't care to waste my time just to get a little pop-up.

AzubuFrost490d ago

I envy you sir. I just gotta have every single achievement whenever I play a game. On my Steam profile I have an 83% completion rate out of 35 games, and my OCD is telling me to keep upping that percentage higher.

MadLad490d ago

Yeah. Back then, though I'm not sure what my actual completion rate was, I was mainly an Xbox player. I had close to 80k gamer score during the 360 days.

It just doesn't excite me anymore. I have less than 20% completion on my Steam account, though I have a pretty asinine amount of games there at the same time.
But I don't really bother with any of this anymore. If there's an interesting achievement I might aim for it just because I find it fun, but usually I just get that pop-up, say "cool" and continue with the game.

Outlawzz491d ago

Never been a fan of achievements. I just want to play the game however it may present itself to me, there's an overflow of achievements to seek in real life lol

Great for those that enjoy them though, much respect to the platinum hunters, it ain't easy lol

Show all comments (33)