GameVortex writes:
"When I first started up Murder in the Abbey and saw the game's use of cartoon animation for the graphics, I immediately got excited. I was instantly reminiscent of classic games like Monkey Island or the older Broken Sword games, except with 3D cel-shaded models instead of the 2D variety of those older ones. Unfortunately, the similarities as far as the game's general quality pretty much end at the looks, but more on that later."
AVault:
"I didn't know what to expect when I started playing Murder in the Abbey, but I was not anticipating a plot seemingly reworked from a mildly obscure 1986 Sean Connery film. The children's cartoon art style is at odds with the decidedly adult nature of the story, which includes some disturbingly creepy double entendres (parents, be prepared to answer some uncomfortable questions). The interface, although pleasingly simple, is filled with bugs. Any murder-mystery game that has you spending more time reading than you do playing is bound to lose the interest of its players long before the killer's identity is revealed. With so many other choices in the adventure genre out there, Murder in the Abbey is one that can easily be skipped."
Melissa Walther writes:
"If you've seen the movie "In the Name of the Rose," you know the basic premise of this game. Of course, if you've seen "In the Name of the Rose," you'll also be wishing the main character, Brother Leonardo de Toledo, had half the brains of Sean Connery. And his acolyte, Bruno can't hold a candle to Christian Slater, either in looks or wit, or voice, or well, much of anything.
If you haven't seen the movie (which you should go out and rent), the basic premise of the game is that you are a monk in some vague middle ages area in Spain, traveling with your pain-in-the-butt acolyte Bruno to a distant abbey to visit their library. Before you can even get there, you're ambushed on the road and someone tries to kill you by dropping a boulder on your head.
This doesn't really seem to bother you, and as soon as you meet the abbot, you're given the task of solving the murder of the gatekeeper. Simple enough. Only problem is, the game moves at the pace of the monks themselves; ponderously slow."
Murder at The Abbey (or simply The Abbey, as it is known in Europe) is an adventure game and it seems one of the few releases these days which doesn't try a million things at once. If one could peek into the The Book of Game, one would find The Abbey under point-and-click adventure. It follows strictly the tested and tried formula of classics in this genre, and this may or not be a plus, depending on what you want out of a game nowadays.
