240°

Uncharted vs Tomb Raider – which game are you likely to choose?

In the red corner, we have the legend that is Lara Croft: Tomb Raider and in the blue corner sits the young challenger, Nathan ‘Nate’ Drake from Uncharted.

Read Full Story >>
knowtechie.com
Arbormist2802d ago

Likely to choose? Like from the point of view of a consumer that knows nothing about either game?... Isn't that subjective? Cocky boy vs dirty hot girl. Unless people look deeper, they are primarily on the surface the same experience.

Obviously with research very few would choose TR over U4 though, at least imo. And even more so once considering the dirty assed 3rd party gone timed exclusive deal. Greasy. Very greasy.

Majister-Ludi2802d ago

Don't care about exclusivity deals cuz I have everything. Myself and several friends prefer tomb Raiders more open approach but I know no one on this site agrees.

Aloy-Boyfriend2802d ago (Edited 2802d ago )

Considering that U4 got a higher meta than TR, I'm sorry to tell you that not only people in "this site" will disagree, although there are several that choose TR over Uncharted, and that is fine. Still, that's a minority group compared to Uncharted, which has a bigger following.

I hated how TR reboot always tossed me in sandbox to going in circles to grab collecties. I gave up on that mid game and rushed to the end (I also would stop to raid tombs which was pretty cool). It ruined pace and distracted me from the plot. I hope that RoTR fixed that

I myself prefer the action approach on Uncharted and story. Uncharted 4 even got bigger and better. Driving my jeep in Madagascar and stopping to seek some treasure/collectible didn't ruin my pace or distracted me from the plot. I actually liked how ND expanded the levels and still retained the lineality to keep me focused on what is going on and the action.

mikeslemonade2802d ago

Both are meh. Give me TLoU!

marioJP872802d ago

Seeing as Tomb Raider has a movie with a known actress, I'd say non gamers would choose her first (i know lots of older people who arent gamers that have knowledge or TR from the movie) but most gamers would choose Drake without hesitation.

badz1492801d ago

I'd personally choose Uncharted. the New TR though, feels like a reactionary move to the success of Uncharted. nothing wrong with it and people say imitation is a form of compliment but the series kinda lost its roots in the process IMO. there's no more trace of the originals in the reboots and personally I kinda like the TR of old. that's why I like Anniversary, Legends, Underworld and even Temple of Osiris more than the Reboots

No Way2801d ago

XiKurapikaKurta - Meta scores really do not mean that much.. But, the rest of your comment I'm good with. :P

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 2801d ago
littlezizu2802d ago

Playstation owners are the only one who have choice and can choose both, if they wanted. So winner is Playstation.

darthv722802d ago

I don't see why someone can't choose both. i mean UC4 has been out for some time on PS4 and you would think that it would already be picked up by fans of the series. RotTR is new to PS4 so that one will likely sell to the same fans of UC and the exploration type genre.

Master-H2802d ago

Uncharted, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't play a used copy of Tomb Raider when it releases later this year.

FreddyFazbear2802d ago

You can choose both. If your a playstation gamer

Gazondaily2802d ago

True. And if you haven't joined the boycott brigade.

Rhythmattic2802d ago

Im in the "not buying it new" boycott brigade. ;)

Speak_da_Truth2802d ago

I'm boycotting because there's no way i'm paying $60 for a year old game but I'll still play it when it's under $3o so I still have a choice sep.

jb2272802d ago

"The Boycott Brigade" will be the only thing that keeps TR 3 from launching as MS' big annual marquee timed exclusive in 2018. That's good for gamers all around. Good for PS fans that don't want to wait a year & good for MS fans that should be more interested in MS spending their money on true first party games that would've been unavailable otherwise. Sad that TR has to be the sacrificial lamb because I absolutely love the series, but I didn't make the rules I'm just helping to break them because they are pointless & anti-gamer.

I'll be renting the game at release so it doesn't count as a sale, then somewhere down the line I'll pick up a used copy. Really hoping Square makes the right decision for the next title...a lot of promise now that they got rid of Gallagher & the artist from Dead Space (easily one of my favorite franchises of last gen) will be heading it up while hopefully tweaking the formula a bit so it doesn't play like a carbon copy of its predecessors.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 2802d ago
Show all comments (56)
50°

XCOM's Jake Solomon Q&A - Building a Narrative-Driven Life Sim Game at Midsummer Studios

XCOM and Marvel's Midnight Suns director Jake Solomon has founded a new studio to make a life sim game. Here's a new interview with him.

Read Full Story >>
wccftech.com
40°

The Big Inworld AI Q&A - 'Everyone in Gaming Sees the Potential of Generative AI'

Wccftech interviewed Nathan Yu from Inworld AI to discuss the dynamic NPC tech's applications to games as well as potential issues like costs.

Read Full Story >>
wccftech.com
160°

Xbox President Sarah Bond's Bloomberg Interview Is Corporate Fakery At Its Best

Saad from eXputer: "After Arkane Austin & Tango were shutdown, Xbox President Sarah Bond spoke with Bloomberg in what I believe to be utter corporate fakery."

gold_drake1d 12h ago

im not really surprised by that, shes always been more a "let me talk about something else than what u want to know" kinda gal

Cacabunga1d 5h ago

If what they are doing is that good, what’s the point of hiding the true story?

anast1d 9h ago

She's a caricature of the shareholders.

PRIMORDUS1d 7h ago

"Shareholders" I call them cancer, they are already rich to begin with but need more and more. It's like a disease, with no cure.

__y2jb15h ago

If you have a pension then you are likely to be a shareholder in these big tech companies yourself. To demonize them as 'heartless rich people' shows you have no idea what you're talking about.

anast14h ago(Edited 13h ago)

@Y2

Of course, it isn't about that. You are attempting to set up a self-righteous strawman to stir up some kind of ignorant mob mentality.

And by the way, most everyone is a touch heartless or we wouldn't be able to consume the products we do knowing very well how they are made. People have to be this way because of self-preservation and convenience.

__y2jb11h ago

@anast please explain to me how what i said is self righteous or a strawman. I simply pointed out that categorizing all shareholders as cancer is ridiculous.

Leeroyw1d 5h ago

I own shares in game companies. I'm not anything near a major share holder. I just want them to make good games and be successful because of that. I think it's the senior management that's the problem. They are the ones that should be making it clear to the shareholders what creates growth and ensures a future of their business. Not this weasle words garbage that she did on the interview. It was horrific. I don't know a shareholder that would be happy with any of them for this.

Profchaos1d 3h ago (Edited 1d 3h ago )

Same and I'm not rich by any stretch like most people's I'm just trying to keep my head above water these days most company's shareholders are made up of everyday people it's amazing how companies think we want something but the reality is we don't.

Disney are probably the worse at the moment it's shareholders voted on ending a lot of the crap and outing the current execs the execs turned around and said no we disagree with the shareholder vote

PRIMORDUS23h ago

I meant at the rich fucks who have millions in the bank already. They are making so much per year, that if they don't make what they are expecting they go into a panic, when in reality it will not even hurt them at all. Those are greedy assholes.

anast14h ago

"you have a pension then you are likely to be a shareholder"

Pensioners don't make any decisions about anything. Obviously that is not what this is about.

CrimsonWing691d 9h ago

Yea, it was and it’s insulting that they think we’re dumb enough to fall for this. Look, the truth was you took a gamble on these studios and while they released some games to critical praise and great reception they just aren’t bringing in a ROI. Be transparent, you’re not a politician.

Just tell everyone you spend money on projects big and small and when money isn’t being made you go over the potential of revenue a studio can bring in vs those that can’t and make the hard decision to chop them.

She says this whole thing about “success” doesn’t fit one meaning for each studio. Well yea, a small budget production isn’t going to expect to sell the same as a large budget production.

One thing I wish they did though was let Tango be an independent studio.

TheGamingHounds1d 8h ago

disheartening to see no regard for the human cost of business anymore
the bad decisions and judgements of these CEOs severely impact the frontliners
these fake responses are just salt on wounds

RoadRacer1d 8h ago

imagine havin the audacity to say "we need more games like hifi rush" right after closing the studio that made it lol
followin up with this show of "deflecting every question" was in poor taste

Show all comments (28)