Top Spin 3: 360 vs PS3 vs Wii Comparison Video

PS3, Xbox 360 and Wii go head to head in this Top Spin 3 video comparison.

[SUP3R]

LMAO@Wii version.
It's like they don't even TRY to make it look semi-decent.
That's a damn shame.

No comment on the other two on a count of I don't care.

[fox02]

lol at the WII version. It's official now; the Wii is just a cash machine, so if you do own a WII, you're a cash cow.

[BrotherNick]

It does kinda suck that they put no effort into it, I've been looking for a game that will make wii tennis obsolete.

[pharmd]

both have strengths,

360 more color/vibrant
ps3 crisper/more detailed images...

i think i just found a replacement for my virtual tennis :D

[harrisk954]

Pong has sure come a long way since the days of the Odyssey!! (hope I didn't date myself too much!)

[Smacktard]

Oh god you have absolute NO IDEA what the term "cash cow" means, fox02. You just came off sounding like an idiot.

A cash cow is something that makes a company a lot of money. And they can keep milking it for money. Hence the name, cash cow. A cash cow isn't someone who buys a product, doofus.

The Wii version isn't that bad. I mean, it's certainly no 360 or PS3 (PS3 graphics look the best, in my opinion) but isn't this obvious? The main selling point of the Wii wasn't for the ubar-sweet krisp graphix, and anyone that bought it for this reason (if anyone) is an idiot. If they don't take advantage of the Wii's unique control, then it'll be trash. But until we know how it controls...

[SixZeroFour]

that first Wii comparison surprised me...lmao, i dont know about you guys, but the wii version looks pretty bad even for n64 graphics...

and yea, 360 version does look better, but the quality of gameplay looks solid on both versions...i mean ps3 and 360 of course

[fox02]

I translated the french expression, which literally means "milk cow"... and I thought it meant cash cow in English. Any way you got my point so... peace.

[Smacktard]

Wow, judging by all of the disagrees with my earlier post, it seems that many people DID buy the Wii for its ubar-sweet krisp graphix, and think that the Wii version of Top Spin 3 looks the best! Also, they think that the game won't be good if it does take control of the Wii's unique control scheme! Who'da thunk!?

/sarcasm

I hate stupid "logic"

[Heaven_Or_Hell]

Wii Version: No comments...
PS3: Washed color
360: Best picture imo, best color, best contrast and best shadow

360 Wins this time

[nice_cuppa]

still tennis....

woop di de doo !

[Heaven_Or_Hell]

For the phantom disagree...
Let us share your phenomenal opinion...

[Tony240ZT]

Agree that the xbox version looked much better here. I can't help but wonder if the PS3 version would look different if the picture was tuned a bit. All of these captures I see of the PS3 where it's washed out never seem to look that bad on my tv.

[hideo kojima]

@tony

"All of these captures I see of the PS3 where it's washed out never seem to look that bad on my tv. "

maybe cuz u might be having xbox360.

[Ri0tSquad]

Wii looks years behind.

[PoSTedUP]

like why cant devs understand that they have to make the ps3 the lead platform in order to make the games look equal? if they were really skilled they would have gotten used to the ps3 by now. if they dont care, then fu*k em. either do i, they just lost a fan.

LMAO! how many crayons did it take to make the wii version?!?!

[BrotherNick]

Maybe because they're a business, so they will make it best for who will buy the most games. Unfortunately for you it's the 360.

[PoSTedUP]

nah the devs are just lazy. thats where you separate the hardworking devs from the half-assed devs. look at gta4(both consoles), they both look good, and both the sales are excellent. same thing with cod4. there going to have to get use to the ps3 sooner or later. if they never do then they were never skilled.

[edhe]

Jesus, quit pretending that your poor purchasing decision's all the 'developer's fault'. Quit moaning about lazy devs and actually use your head when buying a console.

PS3 gets the poor ports, poorer exclusives, less featured games and you pay more for it.
Wii is just full of shiz, with a few polished diamonds.
The 360 is where all the games are at, and it's cheaper than the competition...If you're a real gamer you'd ensure you had that console as well as or instead of a ps3.

There's a reason that the ps3 has the bad end of the stick and it's got nothing to do with the devs - so just because you have a PS3 does not make you some sort of snob that can complain when companies see the majority of the market is worth more of their time than the minority - who use a product that's just not dev-friendly.

[n4gno]

ps3 lead platform in order to the game look : better !!

it's already equal, with lazy devs.

[badz149]

"PS3 gets the poor ports, poorer exclusives, less featured games and you pay more for it." - LOL at that!!

poor ports? yeah I agree because some devs are just too lazy to optimize the code for PS3. not PS3's fault!

poorer exclusive? I won't go any further on this! 4 words buddy - METAL GEAR SOLID 4!

less festured games? like what? most of the games played exactly the same especially the multiplats! so, achievements? FYI, some PS3 games have their own achievement system! Insomniac have implemented skill points since the 1st Ratchet&Clank and all their games have it! later on, PS3 will have the trophies and In-Game XMB! what are you going to say now?

pay more? most of the games cost the same! but you got DVD, PS3 owners get Bluray! it's scratch-proof you know but whatever! yeah, PS3 cost more but it doesn't break easily! 360 cost less with less feature and you still have to pay to play online! for $50 you only got gold membership, but i can get another game at the same price!

[BrotherNick]

Wii doesn't win based on visuals, but I was reading that the controls are okay, but in need of tweaking.

[specialguest]

Looks like someone forgot to turn on the Full RGB again.

[PoSTedUP]

i was thinking that but its what ever. fu*k em.

[crazy25000]

I wanted a Tennis game and this has good potential to be fun. Maybe with the new PS3 motion controller?

[InMyOpinion]

These video comparisons are pretty useless since the games always look different when you see them in real life and on a HDTV.

Looks like an interesting game. I hope it's better than Top Spin 2.

[Varsarus]

PS3 looks sharper than 360, although colour is better on 360, but who knows whether they have or haven't turn the RGB spectrum on...

[iistuii]

Thank god for MGS4 eh ps3 owners? as per usual all multi-format games are better on the lead platform the 360. Mainly as with GTA and most other titles there will be alot less jaggies on the 360 version. I know you lot dont like to accept it, thats why your so chuffed about the MGS4 reviews, as its the only real reason to actually buy a ps3.

[PoSTedUP]

are all multi plats better on the 360? stop being a fanboy and snap back to reality you meat head. the only plat former thats a big difference is madden, the rest are unnoticeable un less you got them side by side, and even then its hard to tell which one is better. some multi plat games run and look better on the ps3. so what.

@ CHASUK08- where did you here that? that would be awesome yo, hes my favorite player next to Maria Sharapova. but im probably not getting this game due to unskilled devs. Rafiel Nadal's the man though, he keeps beating federa or who ever that one dude is that he keeps beating. its good to see him on at least one of the consoles, whether its 360 or ps3.

[Cheboury]

There's only one angle here... Xbox 360 version looks by far the best!

But that's not saying much because after finishing MGS4 on the PS3 there's not much else out there that makes my care for at the moment.

Well,.. maybe Gears of War 2 and Resident Evil 5.

[chasuk08]

If the 360 version does look the best (which is probably due to ps3 RGB settings, which they dont turn on in comparison videos) who cares as PS3 gets Nadal. Thats a big enough reason to get the PS3 version over the 360 version.

[360 man]

Nadal's from spain so therefore he must be a racist

[Bladestar]

Is this a joke? they actually animated the ball on the wii version... impact shockwave animation and speed animation on the ball... lol! I've seeing better looking tenis game on the PS2 and probably PS1 than that.

[Robearboy]

360 Version edges it for me

[sagapo]

why involve the Wii version in this comparison??? We all know the PS3 and X360 version look alot better.
The real difference is the gameplay here, where the Wii version will be totally different and wich you can't tell just by looking at this video.

Between the PS3 and X360 version, i noticed the most difference in the ground detail, but they both look very good.

[Pornlord]

Tennis games are a guilty pleasure of mine... they are so unpopular for the most part that I can usually just wait a few months (it's a tennis game... I don't really need it at midnight launch :P) and it'll be about 30 bucks.

[LuHawk]

Fix these nutts hoe

[4cough]

Go GO 1080p 120fps.

[OmarJA]

OOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH H

FLOP GAIDEN 2 IS 585P AND 20 FPS EXCLUSIVELY ON THE3FIXME

[4cough]

360 without a shadow.

[Avto]

The PS3 version is not recorded with HDMI, the old Gametrailers sh!t, so X360 version looks a tiny bit better as for Wii it's a tiny bit better than Gamecube version would have been. But the graphics is bad on all versions

[JasonPC360PS3Wii]

Nothing new, the 360 wins 98.9% of the time.

[WiiJunkii]

Wii wins this comparison hands down imho...
I think it is safe to say that neither the XBOX360 or the PS3 will ever sell a single copy of any game ever again... not after seeing that video evidence of the Wii's raw processing horsepower...

Wii pwns again.

[etownone]

another multi-plat game looking better on 360.

wow.... is the ps3 and the "POWER OF THE CELLLL" ever gonna get it's act together?

you gotta feel sorry for the poor saps that paid 600 bucks, but hey, you still got a blu-ray player, so dont complain kiddies.

[karlostomy]

At the start of this console generation, I was sort of keen on getting a ps3. I mean it had the specsheet, duck demo, KZ2 movie and the hype... how could it not completely pwn all in its path from the getgo?

Now, three years later, I am kind of glad I didnt fork out all that extra money. I would have just felt cheated with a ps3. At least MGSIV has redeemed it somewhat.

[etownone]

agreed, but one game that might end up on the 360 later doesn't redeem it for me just yet.

If GT5 and KZ2 are that great with all the years and money invested, then along with blu-ray and a price drop it might be worth a buy..... but then again, i'm sure we'll be hearing wispers of the next xbox by then.

[nintendojunkie28]

Yea I pretty much stick too wii exclusives..cuz there is more time and devotion applied to exclusives.I know there is a lot of haters that just sit and wait for demonstrations like these so they can bash nintendo.You have to realize that multi-platform games for the wii always look and usually play like crap.The developers make AAA titles for ps3 and the 360 and give the wii the leftovers so they can cash in on it.It's well known that the other consoles look better graphically,this is nothing new however when it comes to innovation and new ways to play games (though I appreciate other consoles and own them) both sony and microsoft are seriously lacking ...'course ms has always lacked in that area.This example is just pure laziness on the devs part,sad really ...but all too true..so I think I'll stick to exclusive titles for the wii from now on devs can't make crummy ports like this and expect me to buy it.Luckily the wii is gaining serious momentum in the core gaming department.Seems like every other day I hear of a new title like tenchu,mh3,fatal frame 4 etc....can't wait to see what ninty has in store for e3..mark my words nintendo will be the talk of e3 '08...like it or not.

[JaPo]

Graphics look atrocious, don't even hold a candle to VT3.

360 is clearly more vibrant than PS3, but isn't that always the case? The wii though hahahahaha.

[ItisI]

You cannot expect the Wii version to look as good as the HD versions but if the developers get it right it will play 100% better on the Wii and in the end that is the most important thing isn't it?

[Silogon]

The ps3 just can't hang. Just can't. 600 bucks for what? The shadows and attention to saturation on the xbox 360 really make the ps3 look laughable here. The xbox 360 exploits alot of the PS3's hype for just that. I think we're all at a stage now to where we won't be buying into Sony's lies anymore. I did, believe me. I got me a ps3 on launch day but I'll never buy another product from them again.

[G1TR4P3D]

lmao.

wii version looked better than PS3rd version. no lie.

[Calluk]

what are you guys talkin about, theps3 looks realistic, the 360 looks like the Wii cartooney, The Ps3 is photo realistic, the 360 is colourful, Gametrailers proeberly just mested with the contrast to make th 360 versionlook like that

[n4gno]

"XXX version by far the best"

fanboyz are clowns, really.

judging on a little video, with differents set up..an identical game.

[KnightwinG]

yo, im not goin' to front... im a PS3 fan...the XBOX 360 version looks better. Its like the grass look real, and the characters has more color than the PS3 version. PS3 looks blurry a lil bit, not bad.

I do feel if the DEV make the game on the PS3 first, it would LOOK real GOOD! We all know that. Developers just dont do that... i dont kno why. Oh well, im still gettin this game. MASTER IT ON BOTH CONSOLES!

[bosels11]

never go by comparisons on websites - judge for yourself on your own setup. This comment is not directly at you but anyone who accepts these posts as bond.

[cellfluid]

Ps3 rules these developers skills max out at a 360 level the ps3 is 2 advance for these characters. ps3 is a machine that seperates those who trace games and thoes who makes games need I say more mgs4. matter a fact y don't u guys compare exclusives out of all the exclusives 4 360 the graphics doesn't exceed gears. But evey time an exclusive drops 4 the ps3 the graphics looks way better than the last installment put any 1 of yall ex against a ps3 ex n behold the truth but I already know the flesh won't allow u 2 admitt fault ha ha by the way I left this message with my ps3......

[tudors]

but I actually prefer the look of the PS3 version, I think the colour balance is more realistic than the Xbox-360 version, with games like Assasins Creed the PS3 version did look washed out, but in this case I think it actually looks more realistic with the PS3 version than with the Xbox-360.

[Monteblanco]

I found all versions to be bellow average to their machines. The Wii version is pathetic, as Wii Sports looks actually better. It is hard to compare the PS3 an XBox versions as I am not sure if the settings were the same. I liked the XBox colours a little more, but I expect better from both consoles.

[THUNDERMARE]

I dont know why people commented on wash out colour, but as far as I notice, the colour on characters are the same. only that PS3 version is played on the grass field with heavy uses so death grass is everywhere, while 360 version is play on new grass field. Same way as the Wii is show with paved field. All in all in think PS3 and 360 in the same, but Wii is a joke.

[Sanhlami]

I don't know, the Xbox 360 version has greener, newer grass but the PS3 has the brownish area that makes it look like heavy usage of the grass which I believe would be more realistic. Too green is not always the best when you are refering to realism. The Wii's is another story.

[Product]

wow wii graphics look like you put federer in the mario tennis n64 version obviously no time went into developing that game......i will say though that the xbox looks the best in terms of shadow i mean look at that grass texture...amazing

[Product]

IGN had a hands on with the wii build which looks the way it will really be.this wii version looks liek the screen settings are to bright and without a component cable imo.

[blopid]

Hey all,

I am very surprised at all the comments about how crappy the graphics on the Wii are... From it's inception, it was known that the Wii was NOT about great graphics, but about it's playability... The difference is HUGE... I have a pretty high end PC and there are many amazing games with amazing graphics, I would say comparable to the Xbox & PS3 if not better in some cases... I also have the Wii, and there is NO comparing the two... With the PC, Xbox & PS3, you sit on your ass and push buttons on some controller... With the Wii, you are "in" the game, up and moving as you would playing the real game. Of course it's not the same as the real game, but you are in motion and interacting in a way that is unique and one of a kind. If I want to sit on my butt and push buttons, I'll play PC, Xbox, or PS3 and say "WOW what amazing graphics!!!", but if I want interaction, there is NOTHING like the Wii... In any case, I suppose the graphics will depend a lot on your individual setup... I am looking forward to breaking a sweat... I hope you all enjoy the game in whatever platform you have... :-)

Peace...

[Perverted]

Typing about the grass, the 360 grass looks good,t he ps3 grass needs water and the Wii grass needs to come off the drugs.