260°

Carmack confesses favourite id game, slams modern design

VG247: John Carmack's admitted that his favourite id Software game is Quake III Arena. You know what, John? Same with us.

The code legend gave up his personal shooter preference in a PCGamer interview about the upcoming free-to-play Quake Live, and also took the opportunity to stick a knife into completist "movie" gaming.

Read Full Story >>
videogaming247.com
LinuxGuru5807d ago (Edited 5807d ago )

Maybe it's his favorite because, unlike recent id releases, QIII Arena is the only id game that has been worth a damn.

Bolts5806d ago

I dunno about that. Doom 3 was pretty good too. But Quake Arena was retro gaming back when such a thing doesn't exist, when it was released the critics slamed it for being too simplistic and lacking in features never realizing thats the entire point. This is largely because of Counterstrike craze that was going around back then, Quake Arena deathmatch gameplay just seems old and tired.

Fortunately Quake 3 found new life in the East. The Koreans and Chinese are totally nuts about this game and still play it today. Soon they'll have Quake Live and you'll be able to play it for free in your browser, should be interesting.

LinuxGuru5806d ago

Doom 3 was a shinier version of the older Doom.

It wasn't scary after playing it for 10 minutes. It became more predictable than the changing of the seasons.

LJWooly5806d ago

Yeah, I have to say, Doom 3 was incredibly non-scary, which came as a wee bit of a disappointment to me :(

kwicksandz5806d ago

Doom 3 was nothing like old doom. the fun of old doom came from fighting hordes of monsters and doom 3 was just a fps survival horror with a bad flashlight mechanic and alot of monster closets.

serious sam /painkiller = shiny doom

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5806d ago
whatis5806d ago (Edited 5806d ago )

Few gamers will ever realise the depth that competitive Quake 3 has to it.

When someone says that Quake 3 is their favourite fps, they aren't talking about the vanilla version with ffa on q3dm17. The game that everyone else is picturing is a very different one than what people like Carmac are talking about when they mention Quake 3.

They are talking about proper competition level Quake 3, with the latest version of cpma vq3 (formally osp) in 1vs1, tdm + ctf.

If you don't know who Cooller, Z4muz, Zero4, Fox, Cha0ticz, czm, jibo,
uNkind, leXer, keep3r, evil, Toxic or Fazz are, or if you haven't seen them play, then I recommend you look into it if you want to see what all the fuss is about.

If anyone is interested here are a few links to some memorable match demos (1v1):

http://www.cyberfight.org/s...
http://www.cyberfight.org/s...
http://www.cyberfight.org/s...
http://www.cyberfight.org/s...
http://www.cyberfight.org/s...
http://www.cyberfight.org/s...

Xakep5806d ago

I still hate the hell out of DM17.

MK_Red5806d ago

Quake 3 and 4 are my least fave id games.
Doom 2 and Quake 2 FTW!

LJWooly5806d ago

I actually agree with you, although I felt Doom 1 was better than 2 (at the time, not now of course). Quake 2 was just excellent, I just finsished playing through it again :)

MK_Red5806d ago

Agree my friend.
Doom 1 felt more special and better but Doom 2's crazy level design has kept me replaying more and more til this day.

And Quake 2 was indeed excellent. :)
Doom 1-2 + Quake 2 = id's best :D

LJWooly5806d ago

I just think ID were at their best in the past, and unfortunately they're always going to be. I honestly can't see them matching up to their past endeavours now, gaming seems to have gotten to far ahead of them, and in their efforts to keep up, they're losing the plot, as it were.

I'm not saying they should stop making games, of course, that would be silly. I'm just saying they'll never be as good as they were. Unless, they end up surprising us.

kingme715806d ago

Yup, I totally agree LJW. Id was at their best when they were a small shop where Carmack could code up something new overnight and elevate the title that much more. Those days are gone now with 80+ man teams now the norm.

Carmack is still one of the most brilliant 3d developers out there, but Id hasn't really embraced all these changes to the industry to remain on top.

LJWooly5806d ago

Thanks, kingme, I completely agree, and bubbles to you.

MK_Red5806d ago

Agreed with both of you. id was indeed at it best back then. Now both id and Blizzard have lost it. id's Doom 3 was disappointing and they didn't even make Quake 4 themselves. And Blizzard has become uber lazy and has released nothing but WOW for ages.

LJWooly5806d ago (Edited 5806d ago )

Yup, same deal with Blizzard, just to a far greater extent. I never really thought WoW was even a good game in the first place, it's just easy for some people to get addicted to. But, they're making a killing from it, so, from a business perspective, there really is no reason for them to put in any effort or resources to actually bother to make anything outside of WoW, their lactating cash-cow. It's a shame, but that's how it is.

Wait, how the hell did I just make 2 bubbles in about an hour? :o

+ Show (6) more repliesLast reply 5806d ago
whatis5806d ago (Edited 5806d ago )

If anyone is wondering why Fatal1ty isn't on that list, it is because he wasn't actually one of the top Quake 3 players, at least by todays standards.

The game hadn't been out for very long when Fatality was considered a top level player. I would say that Quake 3 reached it's peak competitively around 2003 - 2007. This was a while after Fat had moved on from the game and the newer standard of dual maps were introduced.

I wanted to point this out because many people automatically think of Fatal1ty as being one of the Quake greats, but he probably shouldn't be considered a top tier player when it comes to Quake 3.

whatis5806d ago (Edited 5806d ago )

can't watch the demos, then check out one of my all time favourite Quake 3 videos.

The file is a bit big but it should definately help to make a believer out of you, or at the very least give you some insight as to why some people (like myself) still talk so highly of the game.

http://www.own-age.com/vids...

Show all comments (21)
170°

What happened to Arena Shooters?

What ever happened to arena shooters? We delve into the rich history of this beloved gaming subgenre, how its survived over the years, and what arena shooters look like in 2022.

Read Full Story >>
thesixthaxis.com
Mr_Writer85838d ago

I'd look at COD before BR.

Locking weapons and perks behind a level system.

BenRC01838d ago

Cod killed them. Tbh when cod came along, especially mw2, its was a game changer. Adding rpg elements and scorestreaks rather than just a scoreboard was very cool at the time.

Mr_Writer85838d ago

@ben

I have and always will dislike COD, they made it about time spent rather than skill.

If you're better than me in at level 1 it's down to skill. But if you don't play and only get to level 3 and I get to (just say 300) chances are my guns and perks etc I will kill you more than you kill me.

Overwatch is a good example of a game that does require skill. I have 800+ hours on that game, but some players in that game are unreal.

And you know it's down to skill as you have pretty much the same characters etc.

isarai838d ago

Also any new ones will instantly get compared to Overwatch. Which sucks cause i miss old school arcade shooters with cool characters to choose from.

fr0sty838d ago (Edited 838d ago )

I miss Unreal Tournament 2004's ultra fast paced action... nothing since has really come close to capturing it. Going on sprees never felt more satisfying. A modern day version of that would be amazing.

DigitalDaniel838d ago

Halo says "Hi".
Arena shooters are not dead.

ChubbyBlade838d ago

Infinites player base is dropping like flies because of a lack of content.

Sonyslave3838d ago

Key word lack of content not because it a arena shooter .

And it doing just fine on Xbox

Mr_Writer85838d ago

"lack of content"

Maybe if gamers didn't have the attention span of a small child.

The game hasn't even been out long. And they need new maps and weapons already?

No wonder games as a service is a thing.

ChubbyBlade838d ago

Seems both people below me don’t know how to read.

Never said the lack of content was because it’s an arena shooter nor did I say new maps or weapons.

The game has less than 1/2 of the game modes from past titles the previous ones would launch with.

There’s very little vehicle centric options and the way they spawn in makes them appear less often.

The unlocks are abysmal compared to previous titles leaving nothing to earn or work towards for those who care about that sort of thing.

Been playing since CE in 2001. Not one of these “attention span” problem gamers you’re speaking of. The game literally lacks legacy game modes and vehicle play isn’t very good.

spicelicka838d ago

lmao it's barely been out for a month, it has more than enough content for release. Far more than most games these days.

MadLad838d ago

I'll let you know when I have a hard time finding a match.

The game is as far from dead as dead can be. Not sure why you're trying to make it out to be anything other than that.

LucasRuinedChildhood838d ago (Edited 838d ago )

@Mr_Writer85

"Maybe if gamers didn't have the attention span of a small child."
Mate, you're the one who needs to pay attention. It's missing loads of modes (although they did add a few back in), no Forge, and barely has a progression system,

"No wonder games as a service is a thing."
You're actually defending a big issue with games as a service (less content for more money) and thinking you're clever.

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 838d ago
Mr_cheese838d ago

Wouldn't mind a new Unreal Tournament to go with UE5

RaidenBlack838d ago

^^ this + competing with it, a new Quake to go with future idTech 8

LordoftheCritics838d ago (Edited 838d ago )

Devs stopped innovating on them.

Overwatch is the last innovation that has some of that vibe.

PapaBop832d ago

Agreed, you can tell Kaplan and co loved playing shooters back in the arena golden days and Overwatch is a much better game because of it. Still my go to shooter and only other shooters I've put this much time in are Quake 3 and CS.

838d ago Replies(1)
Show all comments (28)
220°

Editorial: I Am Sick of First-Person Shooters

The Outerhaven writes: First-person shooters (or FPS for you grandchildren of boomers) is one of my favorite genres in gaming. I grew up playing games such as Doom, Quake III Arena, Unreal Tournament 2004, and others. But then something happened.

Read Full Story >>
theouterhaven.net
0rbital71953d ago

FPS games are only good when theyre good atm.

Inverno953d ago

I just wish they'd do more with the actual perspective and movement. First person view in games are so unrealistic and the lack of movement is what keeps me away from most fps.

Atticus_finch952d ago

Yea but that kind of movement would just make for a dizzying experience.

Inverno952d ago

Getting dizzy was half the fun of playing Mirror's Edge. Was fun having vertigo for a week after

RaidenBlack953d ago

Sony : FPS? Yea we forgot about that ...

Nitrowolf2953d ago

that's not Sony though, they just have a timed deal. Regardless, that game was going to probably happen. Plus Arkane makes FPS

953d ago Replies(7)
953d ago
LordoftheCritics953d ago (Edited 953d ago )

I love FPS games, I'll take more.

If you actually count, there's wayyyy more 3rd person games. Possibly 3x or more

Also this should be in a new section called 'Rant'

TheDoomedGuy953d ago

Yeah. the majority of games now are 3rd person. Very few good fps out there

Profchaos953d ago (Edited 953d ago )

Yeah unfortunately soany people like to post their opinions as news and the best way to get as many eyes over it is using a site like n4g to attract clicks you wouldn't normally get.

It's been years since I found any of these pay attention to me I'm so important whinging articles relevant more often they are written by outliers that just don't like the current gaming trend such as I hate open world's, battle royales, new game in popular franchise is bad because it's more accessible and popular or I liked it before it was cool

13sentinel952d ago (Edited 952d ago )

"Yeah unfortunately soany people like to post their opinions as news and the best way to get as many eyes over it is using a site like n4g to attract clicks you wouldn't normally get."

Yea unfortunately your comment is a useless strawman fallacy. Worthless comment.

Show all comments (43)
60°

Hunter's Moon brings Quake 3's characters & weapons to the classic Doom Engine

Modder ‘Zanieon’ has released a brand new version of his Quake III On Doom mod, Hunter’s Moon. Hunter’s Moon is a mod for Zandronum and GZDoom that consists in bringing the single-player/cooperative campaign that Quake III Arena never had.

Read Full Story >>
dsogaming.com