EuroGamer: "It's fair to say the single-player side of Artorias of the Abyss may not offer quite as much mileage as other RPG add-ons. However, that's more than made up for in its intensity of focus, with difficulty that scales according to which New Game+ mode you might be undertaking. All in all, it's a tightly wound adventure well worth setting aside time for, backed up by a multiplayer angle that will have greater staying power."
OXM: "Artorias is for hardcore players only, but anyone still playing Dark Souls at this point easily meets that requirement. It’s a fantastic addition to an already great game, and a no-brainer purchase for anyone still under Dark Souls’ spell."
Dark Souls has enough content to fill two very long games, but thanks to a fan petition From Software has released the Artorias of the Abyss DLC, adding several new areas, bosses, and lots of new loot to the game.
Gamer Limit: "If you’re a Dark Souls fan, you need to buy this right away. If you’re a casual fan who sounds like they’re frustrated by the mere premise of accessing this content, you should probably back away now."
The PvP sukcs balls, ive had no luck anyway, i keep gettin shafted in the back, respawn, stabbed in the back and repeat
Any complaints about this DLC are unwarranted. More Dark Souls, which in my opinion is the best RPG this generation along with Demon's Souls, is such a treat for any true fan of the series. I could care less about trophies, just give me amazing battles against huge monsters like Sanctuary Guardian or epic duels against dark knights like Artorias, new areas to explore, and more loot to discover and I'm good. It's also very commendable how From Software built this DLC due to success of the game and fan demand rather than pre planning what to omit from the game in order to milk money out of their fans. I still think any other dev/publisher would have made Painted World of Ariamis DLC rather than an optional area for the player to randomnly find. From Software are THE BEST ACTION RPG Devs in the business right now, they also appreciate and care about their fans more than any other Dev.
I loved the dlc, my only problem with it is it just reminded me how much I love exploring new souls content. And I hope they start making a new one. Dark and demon are my fav two rpg's this gen, maybe ever.
i love the souls games they are the best rpg's 4 me this gen, sure some new trophies would've been gr8 but im jus happy 2 get dlc 4 it...the backstab suxs in pvp tho it jus kills the fun in pvp battles especially how it happens due 2 lag at times, also building up a physically strong character 2 use the heavy weapons seems pointless in pvp because ppl run in & backstab u almost all the time