490°
5.0

Lost Odyssey gets 2.5/5 from GameSpy

Finding depth and coherence in Mistwalker's anticipated 360 RPG proves to be something of an odyssey in itself.

The latest project from Final Fantasy creator Sakaguchi's Mistwalker studio, Lost Odyssey aims to ape the style of classic RPGs. While it's certainly playable, it feels like more of a relic than perhaps its creators intended. Basic features and dungeon design are handled with the graceful hand of a master designer, but that doesn't compensate for numerous gameplay, storytelling and technical issues. Fans of old-fashioned Japanese-style RPGs will doubtlessly find aspects to enjoy, but this is not the title that will vault Mistwalker to the triple-A status the studio's hype might suggest.

Read Full Story >>
xbox360.gamespy.com
zambrota5930d ago

I am 100% sure LO is meeting LAIR's fate.

Theres just no way it could get as low a SCORE as that.

I am a SONY fan too but This LO review is simply unjust

I reviewed LO at my BABELGAME store and i gave it 8/10

The cumulative review of all LO reviewers at our Branch is 7.78

5930d ago
ruibing5930d ago

The best JRPG on the 360 is stll Eternal Sonata I guess, which thankfully is coming to the PS3 as well.

5930d ago
sheng long5930d ago

sexius maximus:
Folklore was not trash. It's certainly not the greatest RPG of all time, but to say it's trash is ignorance.

Skerj5930d ago

Hah first off Folklore wasn't a full fledged RPG, it's an Action Adventure game. From what I know of LO and what I know by owning Folklore, for an Action Adventure game the storyline is still better. I'm not a review score whore but we'll see in a few weeks how it pans out between the two.

sonarus5930d ago

white knight story will absolutely own this game. I was looking forward to this title as my 360 rpg but i aint touchin it now. wonder when white knight is coming out. havnt heard much from it in a while

games4fun5930d ago (Edited 5930d ago )

you beat me to it, white knight story is coming out in 2008 its made by factor 5 the people who made dark cloud also folklore is a good game its just not mindblowing also there are a lot of loading between one doorway to another imo but its still good with all the folklores/gameplay and dlc i am waiting for white knight to tide me over till ffXIII and we are getting Eternal sonata anyway so 360 has blue dragon and lost oddyssey i'd trade both to play white knight

on a sidenote: i would take reviews with a grain of salt because if you like jrpg's chances are you will like this game i think they were being a little harsh i myself would give the game 7 or 8 just because they were not mindblowing in an rpg doesn't merit such a low score i think if this were an above average fps instead of jrpg it would have easily scored higher

meepmoopmeep5930d ago

she's called Karma... and Karma is a cruel b*tch

Sexius Maximus5930d ago

It all depends on where you look chief...

http://www.gamedaily.com/ga...
4/10 for Folklore
or
http://xbox360.ign.com/obje...
8.2/10 for Lost Odyssey

My point was not to bash Folklore, it was to simply state that the PS3 has very little viable RPG's. I didn't mean to upset anyone, but you can't defend that genre no matter how bad you want to, there's just nothing there to defend. PS3 will GREAT RPG's one day, but that day has not come.

crank5930d ago

The point DUMB****, is that folklore is a great game that you have never played so shut the **** up.

Chief.

AuburnTiger5930d ago

" http://xbox360.ign.com/obje...
8.2/10 for Lost Odyssey"

I find it funny how IGN scores higher for Folklore (9.0) than Lost Odyssey (8.2)

Skerj5930d ago

Auburn's right, if you were going to do a review comparison you could have at least used reviews from the same site since they were done.

Sexius Maximus5930d ago

You missed my point entirely. All I was saying is that because LO got a 2.5/5 on ONE site, and Folklore got a 4/10 on ONE site, doesn't mean its the end all be all score. LO just got a 8.8/10 from Gametrailers. My point was that ratings are typically way off, because it comes down to personal preference. It sounds like you enjoyed Folklore, I'm glad to hear you liked it enough to defend it...In the same boat, I quite enjoyed Enchanted Arms, and that game was crazy mediocre too, but regardless of the bland ratings, I enjoyed it. Props to you for sticking up for Folklore, I'll even give you a bubble.

+ Show (12) more repliesLast reply 5930d ago
pharmd5929d ago

judgin by the commercials i must admit it looked better than that, truly, but then again so did lair!!

HarryEtTubMan5930d ago (Edited 5930d ago )

hahahahahhahahahahahhahahahahh ahahahahhahahahahah

That almost a bigger Flop than the 360 itself. LMAO.... PS3 is getting the big hits this year. And next. And the next.

Asuka5930d ago

and i would like to thankyou my friend, for if there weren't any people like you in this world, i would find no means to measure myself as a person in contrast too.

ruibing5930d ago

I would normally feel the same way as you guys if it were some other game since its about time those PS3-bashing gamers get a taste of their own medicine, but I just can't stay made at a high production JRPG even if its on a 360.

i Shank u5930d ago

the buttbox freefixme is teh flopz LUL'z ! : O !

ive noticed the majority of people on this site that like to flame consoles, like wario and harriet tubman, have no psn ID's or gamertags on their profile. they may not even play the games/systems they talk about

ngg123455930d ago (Edited 5930d ago )

That is an incredibly low score..

And I'll get like 5 ignores for saying that. IGN gives games 8's as if it is candy.

Hasn't even seen the sites of gamespot, edge, 1up, eurogamer, who are going to destroy this game.

Lumbo5930d ago

if you take into consideration that IGN rates on a 7-10 scale ... ;) (or so some people claim ...)

Iron Man 25930d ago

LOL Lost Odyssey is another to add to the growing list of garbage RPG's,Blue Dragon,Two Worlds,and now Lost Odyssey...LMFAO!XD

CrazzyMan5930d ago

REALLY!

Looks like not all reviewers give good scores to RUSHED games(like Lair, Mass Effect and Lost Odyssey -> all have framerate problems because games were rushed).
Guess, what EDGE score will be... =)) They could easy go lower then 5/10. =]

mintaro5930d ago

who gave a good score to lair?

Show all comments (100)
210°

Lost Odyssey Is Still One Of The Best Xbox RPGs Ever

17 years later, it still stands out.

Read Full Story >>
dualshockers.com
shinoff218378d ago

I liked blue dragon more. Lost odyssey is the shit though.

jznrpg78d ago

Two of the few games I still own for Xbox360 . I have Magna Carta 2 , Last Remnant but also have the PS4 version so I may have got rid of it and I have the DS version of Blue Dragon. I think and a few others but I forget what they are since I don’t dust them off. that’s about it.

shinoff218378d ago (Edited 78d ago )

Another one I still havent got to try is infinite undiscovery. I read it was pretty linear but I usually fk with tri ace(star oceans are great).

Really my only issue with lost odyssey was the level cap they hit you with throughout the game. I enjoy just relaxing and doing some grinding every once in awhile. Could've atleast given the option. Other then that. Excellent game.

I've said it before and I'll say it again. The 360 imo had atleast half or more that Gen of being the better jrpg system. I bought one earlier then I normally would have for some, and Alan wake. Japanese devs really got in their feelings that Gen and dropped the ball(thanks Phil phish, cocky ass ign, etc)

darthv7277d ago

You'd be better off playing Lost Odyssey on an XBO or Series X as no disc swapping and it looks and plays much better. Same with Blue Dragon. I still keep my 360 hooked up for games not on the bc list. for everything else, I use the series x now. Just last night I installed arkham origins as there is no 8th gen version like asylum/city.

I love having bc on xbox one/series hardware.

shinoff218377d ago

Darth

When I bought the the Xbox one off a couple worker. That was the first thing indid. Bought blue dragon and lost odyssey. Been waiting to catch infinite undiscovery on sale but I forget to check.

I used to own the 360 versions but I bought these digital. I'd like to track down the 360 ones again but no huge deal. I was actually playing through lost odyssey waiting for starfield to drop.

RaidenBlack77d ago

Is Lost Odyssey coming to PS, too?

cthulhucultist78d ago

The game was indeed amazing. Great characters, gameplay and story!

But the dream sequences penned by Shigematsu were sublime.

I still remember many of these stories and I have integrated in the past in my D&D campaign many years ago.

RpgSama78d ago

I'm not going to lie, I cried on more than on a couple of them

Dabigsiebowski78d ago

Microsoft should have just kept pumping money into these guys. Same with a lot of the other studios... the blundered hard.

Lost Odysee deserved a franchise even though development wasn't smooth

Michiel198978d ago

Am I the only one who doesn't wanna see every good game get sequel after sequel? It was a great game, but sometimes it's better to just make a one off and then create a new universe. Sadly that costs a lot more money and publishers don't wanna risk it, but I would definitely prefer it

shinoff218378d ago

I'm fine with sequels in jrpgs, even in the vain of ff sequels, all new stories and characters. It does get old in other genres though sometimes. For the most part I just game by game basis it all.

FinalFantasyFanatic78d ago

They could have done it like Final Fantasy, kept the title name and just start with a new world/characters, it's not like the creator isn't familar with that.

Concertoine78d ago

Idk, Japan never bit for Xbox despite their best efforts around this era. Mistwalker never exploded either, despite future partnerships with Nintendo whichhad a much better chance at success

BrainSyphoned78d ago

It's not like it has had any competition since 2007. Would really like to own the short stories from it in book form.

PapaBop77d ago

360 had some amazing JRPGs in it's early days, Blue Dragon, Eternal Sonata, Tales of Vesperia off the top of my head were all amazing games.

jznrpg78d ago (Edited 78d ago )

The problem with most MS games on 360 was they didn’t make the games they paid for them and that makes you less money in the long run and isn’t something you can continue to do especially with declining sales of consoles. MS should have been starting and growing studios from the beginning but they went for paid games and it leaves them without the knowledge and culture of making games.

shinoff218378d ago

Good points. Never thought of that like that back then.

Sgt_Slaughter78d ago

Not to mention killing the Japanese market that had all sorts of crazy and fun releases up until 2009-2010. They could have gained momentum on Nintendo and kept that going into the Xbox One era, but decided to "unify" efforts and that all but ended their presents in the country. Now, PS4's outsell the Xbox Series S three years into the new system's life cycle, and the 2/3DS at one point was doing the same.

Show all comments (42)
70°

Fifteen years on, Lost Odyssey is a perfect swansong for the formula Hironobu Sakaguchi perfected

It’s quite hard to believe, but Lost Odyssey turns fifteen years old today. A curious product of the time, it has arguably only got better with age - and not just because of what it is, but also what it represents.

andy85513d ago

Jeez doesn't seem 15 years. Very fond memories of this

FortWaba513d ago

The short stories that Kaim collects/remembers are truly emotional. I remember one in particular made my eyes water.

If you've never played this, try to hunt down an original copy, or emulate it. This game was a gem.

GoodGuy09513d ago

I wish there was a remaster. This and Last Story. Sad these games were released on the...wrong platforms...

kingnick512d ago

Considering all the early tech issues Unreal Engine 3 had combined with Japanese developers working with a foreign language engine Lost Odyssey on the PS3 would have been a tech disaster if it had used UE3.

Lost Odyssey's long load times and framerate drops are evidence of just how hard it was working with early builds of UE3, it's a miracle Lost Odyssey turned out as well as it did.

In a perfect world Lost Odyssey would have launched on the PS3 but I doubt Sony or anyone else would have funded the project if Microsoft didn't.

shinoff2183511d ago

It wouldve sold better thats for sure and maybe dude wouldnt be doing mobile games now

Show all comments (14)
827d ago
Jiub827d ago

Legend of Dragoon was amazing