160°

Home's zero tolerance chat censorship policy criticized

From the article: "We trust the collective PlayStation Home-playing community about as far as we can throw them, but we can't help but agree with a recent San Francisco Chronicle article that criticizes the "game's" ridiculously strict chat censorship policy. The article explores the case of Michael Marsh, who attempted to start a gay/straight alliance club, only to find that the words gay, lesbian and bisexual (all "preferred terms" in the gay community) were being blocked by the profanity filter; a policy Marsh worries could encourage players to think of them as pejorative terms."
Alternative Sources:
PlayStation Home filters 'o... - gamingtarget.com | By: KingJFS
PlayStation Home Features Z... - videogamelibrarian.com | By: KingJFS
KingJFS - contributor
Published: 357 days 17 hours ago | News | PlayStation 3
 
 

Showing: 1 - 35 of 35 Comments
Shut this user up Let user speak
Vip3r - 357 days 18 hours ago
1 -
It's unwinnable tbh. Someone will find something wrong and whine on about it. Persoanlly, I think it's best to have a good moderating system than have vulgur creep making Home a nightmare for other people minding their own business.
Shut this user up Let user speak
xjoshbx - 357 days 17 hours ago
1.1 - I agree...
One thing that i did notice that didn't make since to me is... "Christ" is filtered. WTF? Try saying merry christmas to someone. When i get home i'll try and name off a few gods/idols and see which are allowed.
Shut this user up Let user speak
lokiroo420 - 357 days 16 hours ago
1.2 -
Are these people really defending the right to be able to protest and push their gay rights onto ,for all they know, 10 and 12 year olds? I think it is outrageous that gays feel the need to ask young gamers about their sexual orientation, and if im not mistaken, isnt it illegal to do so? Sony has done the right thing in censoring home as much as they have, political, sexual, or any other cause outside of the gaming community has no place in sony's home, these cry babies need to grow up and take their little pride parades to where it will make a difference.
1.3 DragonWarrior46534 | 357 days 16 hours ago - User only got 1 bubble - Show
Shut this user up Let user speak
ChampIDC - 357 days 16 hours ago
1.4 -
I hope that's not the case DragonWarrior. That would make for many an unhappy Sony fan.
1.5 incogneato | 357 days 10 hours ago - User only got 1 bubble - Show
Shut this user up Let user speak
yesah - 357 days 6 hours ago
1.6 -
the hello one is kind of rediculous. especially since its one of the auto words sony put. Since you can read whatever you say, you dont know what censored or not. so you see people going around in home saying ****o and noone knows why. Also you cant say "something", since it contains "meth" i think sony is taking the censorshp a little out of hand. maybe on there own words should be censored but not if its a part of another word.

Hell i need some meth.
Shut this user up Let user speak
sinncross - 357 days 16 hours ago
2 -
Yeah well 'Christ' like other words is blasphemous, which is swearing nonetheless for many ppl.
Shut this user up Let user speak
JBaby343 - 357 days 15 hours ago
2.1 - Not Always Blasphemous
Christ is not blasphemy when speaking of Jesus. Only when taken out of context or using the title in vain.
2.2 Agent VX | 357 days 13 hours ago - User only got 1 bubble - Show
Shut this user up Let user speak
JBaby343 - 357 days 9 hours ago
2.3 - @ VX
You shouldn't be offended. Jesus was a real person not just found in the Bible but actually documented in Roman records as well including being crucified. If you don't want to believe the Bible it's your choice but it's not debatable that Jesus existed.

I believe in free speech but I also wouldn't want kids on Home exposed to vulgarity, racist comments, and the like. The problem of course becomes apparent with words such as christ which can be used in more than one manner or included in other words such as Christmas.

The best way would be for people to just use good sense and not say things that shouldn't be said in the first place. But that's just wishful thinking.
Shut this user up Let user speak
FTLightspeed - 357 days 6 hours ago
2.4 - not to change the subject but....
I recomend to watch the movie called Zeitgeist, enter their website its free and uploaded on the internet. A huge amount of historians from that period that never even mention Jesus, also Josephus is not a cofiable source make some research. Also tacitus and the other two historians that are mentioned as proofs never wrote the word jesus, thay anly referd to the christ and do not spend to much time speaking about him, so not much relevance. Not even the famous Plutarch writes about Jesus.
If you want to be factual do not confuse religion, base on faith, to science, base on logics and proofs. Religion is not wrong but it is just not based on this things, in can be a useful element to build principles and all that stuff.
Personally i think there is a moment in our maduration that we must reach by our own means what is the right or wrong, by reasoning, expereience, deduction, common sense or whatever. This way you have the absolute confidence and believe in yourself, also you act by the principles forged by living your life.
Shut this user up Let user speak
kewlkat007 - 357 days 16 hours ago
3 - and they called PS3 "The Mature Audience"..
I predicted this a while back....

Same sh!t just a different console...imagine if everyone had MICs out the box.
Shut this user up Let user speak
HDgamer - 357 days 16 hours ago
3.1 -
Imagine 4 chan on every gaming session.
Shut this user up Let user speak
ChampIDC - 357 days 16 hours ago
3.2 -
Yeah, I always wonder if PSN would end up like Live if everyone had a mic. No way to really tell.
Shut this user up Let user speak
dericb11 - 357 days 15 hours ago
3.3 -
We do have a older audience but do not forget the younger people too.
Think about a little kid hearing Fa**ot, Ni**er and all the racist and homo crap. Sony is watching out for future gamers too.

On a side not the first day of public release I go to the Mall and some guy dropped like 10 N words near the chess tables and they was full. Not only did I here it but the people who played chess had to deal with it and it not like the chess tables could be moved.
Shut this user up Let user speak
The_EE_God - 357 days 15 hours ago
3.4 - @HDgamer
This


Shut this user up Let user speak
TIKUP - 357 days 16 hours ago
4 - WTF
they let you say sh!t and f@ggot and FUK but not christ WTF SONY??
Shut this user up Let user speak
lokiroo420 - 357 days 15 hours ago
4.1 -
IM not sure about the rest of the world, but in the United States the catholic faith and children need to stay far away from each other.
Shut this user up Let user speak
JBaby343 - 357 days 15 hours ago
4.2 - ^^
Unfortunately many of the non-biblical aspects of Catholicism push people away from Christ instead of bringing them to Him.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Hellangelzx - 357 days 15 hours ago
5 -
This will probably be a good thing, and a bad thing.

Good thing- I won't have to listen to some random ass say the n word a hundred times.

Bad thing- I won't be able to have proper chats with people without seeing stars all the time.

They should use the censor they use on their forums.

Only bleeps out words that are definitively bad.

F*** N***** C***, S*** ect.

When you say a swear word on their forums, a bleep comes up, rather than stars or the word, they should use that system.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Lumbo - 357 days 15 hours ago
6 -
Erm, i get the feeling that i read this same text already, might it be possible that this is yet another duplicate?

On topic, i rather work with a wordfilter in place opposed to reading the racist, perverted or homophobic trashtalk of some retard. It has been stated that the crew is looking into the wordlist so some "finetuning" can be expected.

On the other hand i don't see any 'need' to make special rules for non-gaming clubs. Home is for gamers to meet up and find new contacts, not a gay or straight dating club. And for the love of the one above... 90% of the 'female' home avatars ain't graced with a female person on the controller. Really, i'll go and make a female avatar just to shot down some idiots -_-
Shut this user up Let user speak
Armyless - 357 days 6 hours ago
6.1 - Another fine post Lumbo
Keep 'em coming.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Spike47 - 357 days 15 hours ago
7 - You people complain too much for something thats free , Yesterday there was a big bug, now this morning I logged into Home with a new Theatre trailer and noticed improvements
, Kewlkat is Home was on the xbox360, all hell would break lose
Do you know how many 8-14 year olds asked their parents for xbox360s this holiday season?? That's Microsoft's crowd.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Menech - 357 days 15 hours ago
7.1 -
Its not a free service its payed for with the purchase of your Playstation 3. Nothing is fee in this world don't be naive + they plan to pay for its support with the purchase of in-game items and in its current state I have to say more so for the European version Sony has some cheek. How can something Sony put millions and millions into be free? its all payed for by the money from yours and my pocket.

Imagine if they made Home multi platform. And had the same server for both the PS3 and 360 gamers hell would really break lose then. A 14 year old kid would actually type something and the hole Sony crowd would all sudden start fitting on the sofa's. In disbelief someone spoke on there beloved home.

The FBI would be there in a matter of moments. "Agent" What's the matter doctor? "Doctor" It serious sir there in a state of shock they could never recover "Agent" But what could possibly of happened "Doctor" it appears someone spoke on home "Agent" Jesus mother of god what sort of sick bastard would do that.
Shut this user up Let user speak
romemac7 - 357 days 11 hours ago
7.2 - @menech
HOME free as far as i know, i don't need to pay anything to get in and enjoy HOME, unless your the only person paying $600 every time you log on HOME? but you are right you first need to buy a ps3 to get HOME for free, key word Free. unlike Microsoft where you pay $250 for a 360 and then need to pay $50 more a year to fully enjoy and be able to get on live to play online.

Romemac7...
Shut this user up Let user speak
Menech - 357 days 15 hours ago
8 -
Clearly they should just have filter options based on the age of the user signed up Sony account. Not allowing them to edit the option in-game They do ask your age for your PSN account right? I sort of forgot.

Although admittedly how many of us would love to run around screaming am playing a GayStation 3 from there mics at the same take getting chased by a Sony army + Nathan Drake and his virtual chainsaw.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Spike47 - 357 days 14 hours ago
9 - menech
you overexagerate things, you act like $400 is actually $600. Home is free because I'm not paying $50 a year for it.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Menech - 357 days 14 hours ago
9.1 -
If you have played all the "Free to Play" MMORPG's out there you would understand how utterly insane your way of thinking is but I guess you haven't experienced that. So I cant blame you for being so wrong I used to think that way myself.

Just try remember the million's invested in home didn't come from thin air. They came from the income from the Playstation brand. Where does some of the income from the Playstation Brand come from you ask? Your pocket You payed for Home I payed for Home I have every right to expect it to be worth its money.
Shut this user up Let user speak
ArmrdChaos - 357 days 13 hours ago
9.2 - Right at the very beginning....
Sony reps were quoted as saying...WE HOPE TO KEEP HOME FREE. I challenge anyone to dig up one respectable source where a Sony rep flat out promises to keep Home free forever. Home's fate will be decided on 2 things...how much money Sony has to put into it and how much revenue they get back from Advertising/Microtransactions. How much effort do you think it takes one 3D artist to build an object for home? Sony charges say a $1 for it...a fraction of it goes to the creation cost and the rest goes to pay for Home...whalah...you just paid for home and didn't even know it. Granted you don't have to buy any of it, but Sony will rely on the "keeping up with the Joneses" effect to drive it. So after you have bought all those 'cool' things for your make believe pad...how much did you actually spend for Home?
Shut this user up Let user speak
JBaby343 - 357 days 14 hours ago
10 - Wonder How Long...
Till the xbox fans jump on this one.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Heldrasil - 357 days 14 hours ago
10.1 -
Nah, us Xbox fans will just sit back and listen to you guys talk smack. It's mildly entertaining.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Spike47 - 357 days 14 hours ago
11 - Menech
with that logic you can't lose LOL. In other words, Home is a great bargain, lol spin that.
Shut this user up Let user speak
sinncross - 357 days 14 hours ago
12 - @ 2.1
Well that is what I meant, but you explained it much better I will admit.
Shut this user up Let user speak
Ryangp - 357 days 13 hours ago
13 - True
Just the other day i was gowing round like a crazy black guy shouting racist abuse at everyone... Good time
Add Comment (Gamer Zone)
Gamer Zone Posting Guidelines
The Gamer Zone is for members who want a more friendly and civilized discussion. This section is heavily moderated by the N4G staff, so leave your fanboyism at the door please. Members who are unable to behave in a mature and respectful manner will be temporarily or permanently restricted from posting in the Gamer Zone. Using words such as Xbots and Sony droids, or other words from the console war vocabulary, is strictly prohibited in this Zone.
Read More...
 
 
You must log in to post comments.
Username:  
Password:  
 
 
About N4G
N4G is a social game news site that covers the game industry 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
More Info... | Submit News