170°

Opinion : Singstar Vs Lips : It's competitive Karaoke, but who will come out on top?

Competitive Karaoke just got serious, but has Lips really got what it takes to blow Singstar away?

"Microsoft has already proven that it can create intuitive and well presented interfaces, great game lobbies and excellent online and community features in its games.We get the feeling that Lips will certainly look flashier, more next-gen than Singstar, but it's questionable whether it will get the essentials right on its first attempt: the speech recognition, pitch and rhythm detection and scoring system."

Read Full Story >>
gaming.hexus.net
Jamie Foxx5754d ago (Edited 5754d ago )

couldnt upset that franchise

i believe lips will go down the same route as scene it, 360 has not got the causual audience of say the wii or ps2

can you imagine 'right just finished gears 2 now lets go play lips' sorry just cant see it

Mc Fadge5754d ago

Scene It came out before Buzz, as a board game, not sure though :/

Will_Smith5754d ago

but seriously if you think LIPS has a fighting chance to beat Singstar you're not so bright, whats that?? want proof? ok..

http://en.wikipedia.org/wik...

Let LIPS compete with THAT... Its a bad ripoff in MS book of "Lets Copy Them Till We Win"

Dareaver15754d ago

so quickly many of you forget..... Karaoke Revolution was the first, and then they came out withKaraoke Revolution Party (which incorporated the dance pad, so you had to do both dance and sing; and the ps2 version incorporated the eye toy.)

Sony did not start everything. But that's what videogames do a lot of the time. They expand/innovate an original thought. That's what Singstar did and that's what Lips is going to do. Take an original idea and try to improve on it.

A question, does the 360 currently have a karaoke game.....? No, so wouldn't it be nice (from a gamers point of view) for 360 gamers to get a game for themselves.

Many of you need to really grow up. It's not really a "Me Too" universe, more or less; it's an "I want to bring a similar experience to my audience".

"Real Gamers" would want everyone to enjoy every aspect of gaming, not some (because i think my company did it first) we should be the only ones that are allowed to do it mentality.

They way many of you think, just imagine; the automotive industry, pc's, mp3 players, cell phones, tv's, and etc.

Game on people....

tatotiburon5754d ago

hey will can you plug your ipod for more song ins singstar?

Bnet3435754d ago

You can sing songs from your iPod or Zune. That's what separates Lips from SingStar. I think win Lips wins with that IMO.

KingME5754d ago

Well said, you hit the nail right on the head. Bubbles Up. Wish I could give you 2.

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 5754d ago
Xi5754d ago

Considering that singstar is a rip-off of music mixer for the original Xbox released well before singstar, and both are a rip off of karaoke revolution.

Will_Smith5754d ago

oh yeah, so whats the name of the "game" that was released on the original Xbox?

i'll be waiting

Dareaver15754d ago

karaoke revolution, which debuted on the PS2 first and was ported to XBox (which let you download more music). Then they pushed Karaoke Revolution to the next level when they created Karaoke Revolution Party, which incorporated the PS2's Eyetoy and the dance pads for the XBox and Gamecube.

Sony did not start everything, i hope you do know that....

Bnet3435754d ago

I don't know how many times I have to post this link:

http://www.xbox.com/en-US/g...

It was called Xbox Music Mixer. You could do a lot with it besides sing to your music, like connect with your PC.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 5754d ago
Stryfeno15754d ago

We will have to see how many units it moves in Europe. If MS is smart, they will have it available as a bundle.

Gregory House5754d ago

Lips doesn't stand a chance against SingStar in Europe. Instead of inventing a new idea to win the European audience, Microsoft tries to dethrone SingStar by making a clone of it? Why buy a knockoff when you can buy the real thing? Microsoft should just give up Europe already, they can't beat Sony in Europe! Just like how they can't beat Sony in Japan.

KingME5754d ago

I own singstar, and although I like, the song choice is pure garbage (At least for my taste in music (Hip hop / Rnb) Singstar only has 24 songs total in those genres combined. And some of the songs they have listed in those categories should be listed in the pop category. (About 13 of them)

Why they can't seem to find Rnb musics is beyond me. That reason along has me marking LIPS down as a release day buy. And trust me, if this sing any non drm song option works, there will be a lot of people buying it over singstar.

Another thing that annoys me about singstar is that the song choices are almost all 2 year old songs or older. Well, I have new songs on my ipod and zune. This feature along is a deal maker.

thebudgetgamer5754d ago

that they copy beeter then carbon paper?

THC CELL5754d ago

rip box 360 lost again

this game will never beat sing star its bigger than halo

Zerodin5754d ago

...love to look like complete idiots!

silverchode5754d ago

you called someone a droid, now who's the idiot.

Show all comments (38)
50°

Sony PS2 Hit SingStar Was Originally an Action-RPG

IGN India says: “ Interior Night’s Charu Desodt on bringing Singstar to life on the PS2, winning a BAFTA, and upcoming Xbox Series X|S and PC game, As Dusk Falls.”

80°

RIP Singstar, One Of The Most Important Games In PlayStation History

This may come as a bit of a shock to Americans, since it never really took hold in the US, but Singstar was one of the most important series ever released on a Sony console. And in January 2020, after 15 years of PlayStation karaoke, it’s finally going to be shuffled off the stage.

ApocalypseShadow1638d ago

This game could live on as a VR game. Karaoke as different created characters or franchise characters from other games. Sing as Kratos or Nathan Drake or Parappa the Rapper, etc and post to social media if you're into that internet thing. Would be funny. And interesting if you had individuals who could really sing. Alloy becomes a virtual singing idol.

Sounds crazy but it's creative for VR. And you could use Dreams to create your backgrounds and music videos. I don't really sing but don't think they should give up on Singstar.

RememberThe3571638d ago

I think your last point might be a big one. Who needs SingStar when Dreams is coming out?

timotim1638d ago

So if you invested potentially hundreds of dollars in the game with DLC songs, will all of it continue to work or are you just SOL now?

rainslacker1638d ago

It'll still work. You just won't have the online features. The game can be played locally either singing together, or competing against one another, and is generally considered a pretty good party game....if you go to parties where karaoke is a thing at least. It basically doubles as a karaoke machine.

I'm not into karaoke, and you'll just have to trust me that anyone would be happy that I don't try to sing publicly, or even privately among friends. But, I've been to parties where people are having fun with it, and it's about as hit or miss as going to a karaoke bar....without the one girl who wants to sing Shania twain songs, yet can't carry a tune, or hit a high note without your pet cat committing ritual suicide.....most of the time anyways.

JonTheGod1638d ago

I loved SingStar but it hasn't been supported most of this gen. It had a half-hearted revival with a couple of discs but very little of the PS3 library transitioned across. I will probably keep my PS3 just for SingStar when PS5 comes out.

PhoenixUp1638d ago

Many of Sony’s casual franchises are falling by the wayside

rainslacker1638d ago

SingStar was huge in the US. Where did the idea that it wasn't popular in the US come from? It wasn't a hardcore game, so the hardcore gaming community never really noticed it much, but the game was a huge money maker for Sony.

380°

Sony Is Shutting Down SingStar And Driveclub Servers In 2020

Sony is shutting down online servers for SingStar and Driveclub in early 2020.

Yi-Long1641d ago

Extremely disappointing how Sony has treated one of its best exclusives this generation. Love Driveclub. Such a shame it never received the love, attention and respect it deserved from Sony, post-launch.

Brave_Losers_Unite1641d ago

What is it that you want Sony to do with it exactly post launch?

Obscure_Observer1641d ago

@Brave_Losers_Unite

A PS4 Pro patch would be nice. Same goes to Bloodborne.

jukins1641d ago

@Obsucre the team was on the way to being closed and barely finished driveclub vr. A ps4 pro patch was asking to much

1641d ago
darthv721641d ago

That reminds me, i need to get the motorcycle expansion before it gets removed. I already got all the free dlc but that one is paid and I forgot about it.

DC is such a well made game. I'm so surprised Sony would let the devs slip right through their fingers. Motorstorm deserved a PS4 follow-up.

Skate-AK1641d ago

Bikes, along with the two or three paid DLC's got removed in August. Even though the DLC was cars, they had to put it under bikes because of trophy amount requirements. Can only get Bikes by buying a physical copy.

SierraGuy1640d ago

Physical copies may be worth something someday 🙆

KickSpinFilter1641d ago

Ya Driveclub turned out to be so dang amazing. Bummer this won't continue online. But SP lives on!

jukins1641d ago

What? It was broken on launch delayed an entire year had one of the best season passes ever new tracks new cars added streetbikes but it never received the love post launch?

rainslacker1640d ago

I think he means that the gaming press and community in general didn't show it any love post launch. I mean, you see broken games that people rave about how it's awesome they got fixed and get lots of articles about it, but you didn't really see that with DC, despite the launch issues being only trivial annoyance to one aspect of game play which offered up challenges to the player....and I guess online racing. Took like a month to fix, but the game was doomed to be neglected due to the console wars, and people moving on, and ultimately, was probably a big reason that Sony closed the studio, because they were having financial difficulties at the time, and had to make decisions based on sales.

rainslacker1640d ago (Edited 1640d ago )

I thought SingStar was one of their more successful franchises. I know during the PS3 days it was pretty popular. No one around here ever talked about it, but I know a lot of people who I wouldn't classify as gamers who were into it.

DCVR is amazing. Removes my biggest complaint about driving games, which is that 2D makes it hard to tell where you are in the corners to know when to turn. With VR, I can drive like I would a real car....assuming I actually drove that fast, and staying in lanes, and actually racing is so much more fun.

Makes me wish that GT:S had a full on VR mode for every race mode. I'd take the graphics hit to be able to race more than one car, on a mode that gives practically no progression.

Bikes is also fantastic.

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 1640d ago
masterfox1641d ago

everyone can make mistakes and definitely Sony made one by letting to die Driveclub, if you didn't know is still best looking racing game out-there , not only looks heavenly stunning but plays awesome as well, not sure how hard affected Sony to take such decision but for what we know is a very bad decision taken.

iplay1up21641d ago (Edited 1641d ago )

No, Horizon 4, and Forza Motorsport 7 absolutely look better than Drive Club. They are also Xbox One X enhanced and run in 4K.

IRetrouk1641d ago (Edited 1641d ago )

I play all 3, driveclub still looks better, from cars to graphical effects, understandable because horizon 4 is open world, as for forza 7, while it looks good, it still dont top driveclub, neither does gt sport for that matter, or project cars, or need for speed.

FanboySpotter1641d ago

As someone that still plays driveclub, forza horizon 4 is leaps above all. Free roaming with that fidelity or 60fps? Sweet jesus

rainslacker1640d ago (Edited 1640d ago )

DC both looks better, and drives better than either version of Forza. Forza has better competitor driver AI though.

I really love FH4, but I still think that DC looks and plays better.

jukins1641d ago

Please explain how sony let it die. They gave them an entire extra year to fix still promoted it even though the launch was broken had tons of content and still has lasted almost the entire gen. It's obvious you dont even play it online because even the ps plus version tracks barely can get more than 4 or 5 people let alone the full game. You act like thousands are still getting online everyday and sony just doesnt care

JackBNimble1641d ago

Last time I played was a few months ago and couldn't fine other players online .
I was playing sp because no one else was there.

1641d ago Replies(2)
dragonyght1641d ago

it wasn't really Sony the game receive a lot of post launch content. Driveclub got crucify for not being forza horizon.

1641d ago
+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 1640d ago
TGG_overlord1641d ago

I can only agree with Yi-Long and masterfox...Sony just made a HUGE blunder with no doubt.

MasterCornholio1641d ago

Don't really care about SingStar but alot of people liked Driveclub.

rainslacker1640d ago

I'd say a lot of people like SingStar as well. It was one of Sony's top selling games last gen. Plus, it had tons of content DLC/MT. It was a GaaS game, and was quite popular among the casuals. Basically just a karaoke game, which was fun at parties....for better or worse depending on your thoughts about karaoke at parties.

I guess the game has fallen off people's radar though, because it's hard to imagine Sony would drop it if it was still generating significant revenue like it used to.

monkey6021641d ago

I adore DriveClub and I've been playing It a lot the last couple months. I even just got Platinum in both DriveClub and DriveClub bikes this week. But the multiplayer in both is absolutely baron. There's no matches on either to play online. You need to arrange online meet ups

Doomeduk1641d ago

You'll still find a few of us still racing online on an evening fella and when I fired it up last week I had a couple of full lobbies.
Just needed a pro upgrade to 60 fps instead of the VR version and I think it would still be going strong now
I remember a few months before the devs were shutdown they talking about adding tire deformation and a few other things.. Damn shame

rainslacker1640d ago

I thought the VR version was awesome. Plus, it was it's own thing, and shouldn't have interfered with a PS4P update. the lack of update was likely due to the studio being shut down though.

jukins1641d ago

Thank you this is what people dont understand no one is playing online. All these fake supporters but they dont even play it. I'll join a race and it will cycle about 10 races before I actually find ONE other person

Yi-Long1640d ago

They could have kept the leaderboards up at least.

Show all comments (92)